Student |
Subject |
Grade |
Class |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reagan Stanley | English | Grade 6 | AM ELA |
Essay Summary:
In the Scottish legend “Clever Maggie of Tollishill,” the character Maggie demonstrates determination by not giving up, finishing what she starts, and attempting the impossible. Maggie’s resilience is evident in her efforts to save her farm, pay rent, and fulfill a seemingly impossible task set by the earl.
Essay Grade:
| Criteria | Score | Explanation |
|---|---|---|
| Organization | 3 | The essay has a clear introduction and conclusion, but there are some inconsistencies in paragraphing. The paragraphs could be more clearly separated to improve the overall organization. |
| Content | 4 | The essay includes relevant details, facts, and examples that support the main idea. The examples from the text effectively demonstrate Maggie’s determination. |
| Grammar and Mechanics | 3 | The writing has some errors in punctuation and capitalization, but they do not significantly impact readability. Proofreading for these errors would improve the overall quality of the essay. |
| Vocabulary | 3 | The essay uses some age-appropriate vocabulary, but there could be more variety and precision in word choices. Using more descriptive language would enhance the reader’s understanding and engagement. |
| Overall Impression | 3 | The writing is generally engaging and shows effort, but there are areas for improvement. The essay could benefit from more polish and attention to detail. |
Total Score: 16/20
Overall, Reagan has done a good job in writing the essay. The content is strong, with relevant examples from the text that effectively demonstrate Maggie’s determination. The essay could be improved by paying more attention to organization, specifically in separating paragraphs more clearly. Additionally, proofreading for errors in punctuation and capitalization would enhance the readability of the essay. To further enhance the essay, Reagan could use a wider variety of vocabulary and make more precise word choices. Overall, Reagan has shown effort and engagement in writing the essay. Great job!
Essay:
“Clever Maggie of Tollishill”
Have you ever read a legend? In the old Scottish legend “Clever Maggie of Tollishil”, the author Marilyn Helmer describes her character Maggie’s determination in three ways. Maggie shows that when she sets her mind to something, no one can stop her. Maggie also shows that she finishes what she started. Like when no one was paying the rent but Maggie saved up her money and paid him even though no one else was.
The first way Maggie showed determination was by not giving up. The text stated that in paragraph four Maggie said, “We’ll not give up the farm, Thomas. Not after all the work we’ve put into it.” When someone wants to show determination they won’t give up. In paragraph four itt stated that Maddie showed determination and would not give up to save her farm no matter what.
The second way that Maggiie showed determination was that she finished what she started. In paragraph twenty one Maddie showed that she finished what she started by walking four hundred miles from Scotland to London just to pay the rent to the earl even though everyone else wasn’t. I know people show determination by finishing what they started no matter what. The text stated that she walked four hundred miles just to pay the rent to the earl. Maggie showed that she finished what she started.
The third way that Maggie showed determination was by trying to do the impossible. In paragraph eleven the earl stated, “Bring me a snowball in June, and I’ll consider your rent paid in full.” Then Maggie showed determination by saying, “Thank you, sir, you shall have your snowball in June.” You should always try to do the impossible even if everyone says you can’t do it. The earl said that she couldn’t do it, but Maggie didn’t let that bring her down and she did the impossible.
To sum it up, Maggie showed determination in three different ways. By not giving up to save the farm. Maggie also showed it by finishing what she started like when she walked four hundred miles just to pay the rent for the earls freedom. Maggie also showed determination by trying to do the impossible. Like when the earl said she can’t bring him a snowball in June. But Maggie showed him that he was wrong and brought him a snowball in June.