| Criteria | 0-1 point | 0-4 points | 0-1 point (Extra Credit) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thesis | The thesis is missing or unclear. | The thesis is clear and addresses the prompt. | N/A |
| Evidence and Commentary | Little to no evidence or commentary is provided. | Some evidence and commentary are provided, but they may not effectively support the thesis. | N/A |
| Extra Credit (Sophistication) | N/A | N/A | An additional point will be awarded for demonstrating sophisticated analysis or use of language. |