| Scoring Scale | 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. First, answer the question with a clear claim. | Response does not address the question or lacks a clear claim. | Response partially addresses the question with a vague claim. | Response addresses the question with a somewhat clear claim. | Response clearly answers the question with a strong, clear claim. |
| 2. Then, cite the relevant evidence based on your knowledge of the content referred to in the prompts. | No relevant evidence cited. | Minimal relevant evidence cited, but lacks depth. | Some relevant evidence cited, but may not fully support the claim. | Multiple pieces of relevant evidence cited that strongly support the claim. |
| 3. Finally, explain the relevance of your evidence and how it relates to your response. | No explanation of evidence relevance or its connection to the response. | Minimal explanation of evidence relevance or its connection to the response. | Some explanation of evidence relevance, but lacks clarity or depth. | Thorough explanation of evidence relevance and its strong connection to the response. |