| Criteria | 10 | 5 |
|---|---|---|
| Intro/Conclusion | Clear and engaging introduction that sets up the essay and conclusion that effectively summarizes key points | Introduction and/or conclusion lacks clarity or does not effectively summarize key points |
| Topic Sentences and Transitions | Strong topic sentences that clearly introduce main ideas and smooth transitions between paragraphs | Weaker topic sentences and/or transitions that may disrupt the flow of the essay |
| Evidence | Thorough and relevant textual evidence that supports analysis and is properly integrated | Some evidence provided but may lack depth or relevance to the analysis |
| Commentary | Insightful analysis and commentary that effectively connects evidence to thesis | Analysis is present but may lack depth or clarity in connecting evidence to thesis |
| Style, Vocabulary, Sentence Structure | Sophisticated writing style with varied vocabulary and sentence structures that enhance the essay | Writing style may be less sophisticated with limited vocabulary and repetitive sentence structures |
| Mechanics and Coherence | Essay is well-organized, coherent, and free of grammatical errors | Some organizational issues or grammatical errors present that impact clarity |
| MLA Format | Essay follows MLA format guidelines accurately for citations and formatting | Some deviations from MLA format guidelines present |