| Criteria | 0-1 Points | 2-3 Points | 4-5 Points |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thesis Statement | Thesis is unclear or missing | Thesis is present but lacks clarity | Thesis is clear, focused, and presents a strong argument |
| Analysis of Symbolism | Lacks analysis of symbolism | Some analysis of symbolism present but superficial | Thorough analysis of symbolism with insightful connections |
| Characterization | Minimal discussion of characterization | Some discussion of characterization but lacks depth | In-depth analysis of character development and motivations |
| Organization | Essay lacks structure and coherence | Some attempt at organization but lacks consistency | Well-organized with clear introduction, body paragraphs, and conclusion |
| Evidence and Examples | Little to no evidence or examples provided | Some evidence and examples included but not well-integrated | Strong use of textual evidence and examples to support analysis |