| Criteria | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Clear Thesis | Thesis is unclear and lacks focus | Thesis is somewhat clear but needs more focus | Thesis is clear and focused | Thesis is exceptionally clear and focused |
| Claim 1 Supports Thesis | Claim 1 does not support the thesis | Claim 1 weakly supports the thesis | Claim 1 adequately supports the thesis | Claim 1 strongly supports the thesis |
| Claim 2 Supports Thesis | Claim 2 does not support the thesis | Claim 2 weakly supports the thesis | Claim 2 adequately supports the thesis | Claim 2 strongly supports the thesis |
| Counter Argument | Counter argument is missing or irrelevant | Counter argument is weak or unclear | Counter argument is relevant but needs more development | Counter argument is strong and effectively challenges the original claim |
| Concise Conclusion | Conclusion is missing or does not summarize the claim | Conclusion is vague and lacks clarity | Conclusion is clear but could be more concise | Conclusion is concise and effectively summarizes the claim |
| Spelling and Grammar | Multiple spelling and grammar errors throughout | Some spelling and grammar errors present | Few spelling and grammar errors present | No spelling or grammar errors |