| Criteria | 1 – Below Expectations | 2 – Approaching Expectations | 3 – Meeting Expectations | 4 – Exceeding Expectations |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Plot Development | The plot is confusing and lacks a clear sequence of events. | The plot is somewhat developed but lacks coherence and consistency. | The plot is well-developed with a clear sequence of events that engage the reader. | The plot is intricately developed with a compelling sequence of events that captivate the reader. |
| Point of View | The point of view is unclear or inconsistent throughout the narrative. | The point of view is somewhat clear but could be more consistent. | The point of view is clear and consistent, enhancing the reader’s understanding of the story. | The point of view is expertly crafted, adding depth and perspective to the narrative. |
| Dialogue | Dialogue is minimal or unrealistic, detracting from the authenticity of the characters. | Dialogue is present but lacks variety or does not effectively convey character emotions. | Dialogue is realistic and enhances character development and plot progression. | Dialogue is engaging, authentic, and effectively advances the narrative. |
| Setting | The setting is vague or unrelated to the historical event, hindering the reader’s immersion. | The setting is somewhat described but lacks vivid details to transport the reader to the historical period. | The setting is vividly described, creating a strong sense of time and place relevant to the historical event. | The setting is richly detailed, immersing the reader in the historical period with sensory descriptions. |
| Spelling and Punctuation | Multiple spelling and punctuation errors that impede readability. | Some spelling and punctuation errors that occasionally disrupt the flow of the narrative. | Minor spelling and punctuation errors that do not significantly affect the readability of the narrative. | Almost perfect spelling and punctuation, enhancing the overall professionalism of the narrative. |