| Criteria | 4 Points | 3 Points | 2 Points | 1 Point |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Neatness | Front page is exceptionally neat and well-organized. Text and images are clear and easy to read. | Front page is neat and organized. Most text and images are clear and easy to read. | Front page is somewhat neat. Some text and images are difficult to read. | Front page is messy and disorganized. Text and images are unclear and hard to read. |
| Accuracy | All facts and details about the setting, plot, and characters are accurate and well-researched. | Most facts and details about the setting, plot, and characters are accurate and well-researched. | Some facts and details about the setting, plot, and characters are accurate, but there are noticeable errors. | Many facts and details about the setting, plot, and characters are inaccurate or missing. |
| Creativity | Article is highly creative, showing unique and unpredictable ideas that enhance the theme. | Article is creative, with some unique ideas that relate to the theme. | Article shows limited creativity, with few unique ideas related to the theme. | Article lacks creativity and does not present unique ideas related to the theme. |
| Elements (Who, What, Where, When, Why, How) | All elements are clearly and thoroughly addressed, providing a complete understanding of the article’s topic. | Most elements are addressed, providing a good understanding of the article’s topic. | Some elements are addressed, but the article lacks clarity in understanding the topic. | Few elements are addressed, resulting in a poor understanding of the article’s topic. |
| Connection to Theme | Article makes a strong and clear connection to one of the themes, with insightful analysis. | Article makes a clear connection to one of the themes, with some analysis. | Article makes a weak connection to one of the themes, with little analysis. | Article does not make a clear connection to any of the themes. |