| Criteria | 0 Points | 1 Point | 2 Points | 3 Points |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Thesis Statement | No clear thesis statement | Weak thesis statement | Thesis statement is present but lacks clarity | Strong, clear thesis statement that presents a compelling argument |
| Argument Development | Argument is missing or unclear | Argument is weak and lacks support | Argument is somewhat developed with some support | Argument is well-developed with strong supporting evidence |
| Organization | Essay lacks structure and coherence | Organization is confusing and hinders understanding | Essay is somewhat organized but may be difficult to follow | Essay is well-organized with clear transitions between ideas |
| Counterarguments | No acknowledgment of counterarguments | Counterarguments are mentioned but not effectively addressed | Counterarguments are acknowledged but not fully developed | Counterarguments are effectively addressed and refuted |
| Conclusion | Conclusion is missing or does not effectively summarize the argument | Conclusion is weak and does not leave a lasting impact | Conclusion is present but lacks a strong closing statement | Conclusion effectively summarizes the argument and leaves a lasting impact |