Criteria |
0 Points |
1 Point |
2 Points |
3 Points |
Thesis Statement |
No clear thesis statement |
Weak thesis statement |
Thesis statement is present but lacks clarity |
Strong, clear thesis statement that presents a compelling argument |
Argument Development |
Argument is missing or unclear |
Argument is weak and lacks support |
Argument is somewhat developed with some support |
Argument is well-developed with strong supporting evidence |
Organization |
Essay lacks structure and coherence |
Organization is confusing and hinders understanding |
Essay is somewhat organized but may be difficult to follow |
Essay is well-organized with clear transitions between ideas |
Counterarguments |
No acknowledgment of counterarguments |
Counterarguments are mentioned but not effectively addressed |
Counterarguments are acknowledged but not fully developed |
Counterarguments are effectively addressed and refuted |
Conclusion |
Conclusion is missing or does not effectively summarize the argument |
Conclusion is weak and does not leave a lasting impact |
Conclusion is present but lacks a strong closing statement |
Conclusion effectively summarizes the argument and leaves a lasting impact |