| Criteria / Topics | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Plot and Structure | The story lacks a clear conflict and solution. | The conflict and solution are somewhat clear, but could be more developed. | The conflict and solution are clear and well-developed. | The conflict and solution are clear, well-developed, and engaging. |
| Character Development | The characters are not well-developed and their actions do not make sense. | The characters are somewhat developed, but their actions could be more realistic. | The characters are well-developed and their actions are mostly realistic. | The characters are well-developed, realistic, and show growth or change. |
| Setting | The setting is not described or does not contribute to the story. | The setting is somewhat described, but could be more detailed or relevant. | The setting is described and contributes to the story. | The setting is vividly described and enhances the story. |
| Dialogue and Voice | The dialogue is confusing or does not sound like real conversations. | The dialogue is somewhat clear, but could be more realistic or engaging. | The dialogue is clear, realistic, and helps to develop the characters. | The dialogue is clear, realistic, engaging, and reveals the characters’ personalities. |
| Conventions | The writing has many errors in grammar, punctuation, and spelling. | The writing has some errors in grammar, punctuation, and spelling. | The writing has few errors in grammar, punctuation, and spelling. | The writing has no errors in grammar, punctuation, and spelling. |
| Organization | The story is disorganized and difficult to follow. | The story is somewhat organized, but could be more coherent. | The story is well-organized and easy to follow. | The story is well-organized, with a clear beginning, middle, and end. |
| Elaboration | The story lacks details and descriptions. | The story has some details and descriptions, but could be more vivid. | The story has enough details and descriptions to engage the reader. | The story has rich details and descriptions that bring it to life. |