| Criteria | 4 Points | 3 Points | 2 Points | 1 Point |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Introduction | The introduction clearly states the writer’s opinion and provides a strong hook to engage the reader. | The introduction states the writer’s opinion and provides a hook to engage the reader. | The introduction states the writer’s opinion but lacks a strong hook to engage the reader. | The introduction does not clearly state the writer’s opinion and lacks a hook to engage the reader. |
| Reasons and Information | Provides strong and relevant reasons and information to support the opinion, with clear examples and details. | Provides relevant reasons and information to support the opinion, with some examples and details. | Provides limited reasons and information to support the opinion, with few examples and details. | Does not provide reasons and information to support the opinion. |
| Organization | Organizes ideas in a clear and logical manner, with smooth transitions between paragraphs. | Organizes ideas in a mostly clear and logical manner, with some transitions between paragraphs. | Organizes ideas in a somewhat clear and logical manner, with limited transitions between paragraphs. | Organizes ideas in a confusing and illogical manner, with no transitions between paragraphs. |
| Conclusion | The conclusion restates the opinion and provides a strong closing statement. | The conclusion restates the opinion and provides a closing statement. | The conclusion restates the opinion but lacks a strong closing statement. | The conclusion does not effectively restate the opinion or provide a closing statement. |
| Grammar and Spelling | Uses correct grammar, spelling, and punctuation throughout the essay. | Uses mostly correct grammar, spelling, and punctuation throughout the essay, with some errors. | Uses limited correct grammar, spelling, and punctuation throughout the essay, with noticeable errors. | Uses incorrect grammar, spelling, and punctuation throughout the essay. |