| Scoring Scale and Points | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Criteria / Topics | Needs Improvement | Approaching Standards | Meeting Standards | Exceeding Standards |
| Introduction | The introduction is unclear and does not grab the reader’s attention. | The introduction is somewhat clear but lacks a strong hook. | The introduction is clear and sets up the topic effectively. | The introduction is engaging and hooks the reader from the start. |
| Thesis Statement | The thesis statement is missing or unclear. | The thesis statement is present but needs more clarity. | The thesis statement is clear and directly addresses the topic. | The thesis statement is strong, clear, and effectively guides the essay. |
| Supporting Arguments | Supporting arguments are weak and lack evidence or examples. | Supporting arguments are somewhat developed but need more evidence. | Supporting arguments are well-developed with relevant evidence and examples. | Supporting arguments are strong, compelling, and thoroughly supported. |
| Counterarguments | Counterarguments are missing or not addressed effectively. | Counterarguments are mentioned but not fully developed. | Counterarguments are acknowledged and addressed with some depth. | Counterarguments are effectively integrated and refuted with strong reasoning. |
| Conclusion | The conclusion is abrupt and does not effectively summarize the essay. | The conclusion somewhat summarizes the main points but lacks a strong closing. | The conclusion effectively summarizes the main points and provides closure. | The conclusion is strong, impactful, and leaves a lasting impression. |