| Criteria / Topics | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Exposition | The exposition is unclear and lacks important details. | The exposition is somewhat clear but lacks some important details. | The exposition is clear and includes some important details. | The exposition is clear and includes most important details. | The exposition is clear and includes all important details. | The exposition is clear, includes all important details, and engages the reader. | The exposition is clear, includes all important details, engages the reader, and sets up the story effectively. | The exposition is clear, includes all important details, engages the reader, and sets up the story effectively with a strong hook. |
| Rising Action | The rising action is unclear and lacks important details. | The rising action is somewhat clear but lacks some important details. | The rising action is clear and includes some important details. | The rising action is clear and includes most important details. | The rising action is clear and includes all important details. | The rising action is clear, includes all important details, and builds suspense. | The rising action is clear, includes all important details, builds suspense, and keeps the reader engaged. | The rising action is clear, includes all important details, builds suspense, keeps the reader engaged, and leads to the climax effectively. |
| Climax | The climax is unclear and lacks impact. | The climax is somewhat clear but lacks impact. | The climax is clear and has some impact. | The climax is clear and has significant impact. | The climax is clear, has significant impact, and creates a turning point in the story. | The climax is clear, has significant impact, creates a turning point in the story, and keeps the reader engaged. | The climax is clear, has significant impact, creates a turning point in the story, keeps the reader engaged, and leads to the falling action effectively. | The climax is clear, has significant impact, creates a turning point in the story, keeps the reader engaged, leads to the falling action effectively, and resolves the conflict. |
| Falling Action | The falling action is unclear and lacks important details. | The falling action is somewhat clear but lacks some important details. | The falling action is clear and includes some important details. | The falling action is clear and includes most important details. | The falling action is clear and includes all important details. | The falling action is clear, includes all important details, and wraps up the story. | The falling action is clear, includes all important details, wraps up the story, and provides closure. | The falling action is clear, includes all important details, wraps up the story, provides closure, and leaves the reader satisfied. |
| Reflection | The reflection is unclear and lacks insight. | The reflection is somewhat clear but lacks some insight. | The reflection is clear and includes some insight. | The reflection is clear and includes most insight. | The reflection is clear and includes all insight. | The reflection is clear, includes all insight, and shows growth or understanding. | The reflection is clear, includes all insight, shows growth or understanding, and connects to the overall theme or message. | The reflection is clear, includes all insight, shows growth or understanding, connects to the overall theme or message, and leaves a lasting impression on the reader. |
| Varied Sentences | The essay lacks varied sentence structures. | The essay includes some varied sentence structures. | The essay includes several varied sentence structures. | The essay includes many varied sentence structures. | The essay includes a wide variety of sentence structures that enhance the writing. | The essay includes a wide variety of sentence structures that enhance the writing and engage the reader. | The essay includes a wide variety of sentence structures that enhance the writing, engage the reader, and create a smooth flow. | The essay includes a wide variety of sentence structures that enhance the writing, engage the reader, create a smooth flow, and showcase the writer’s skill. |
| Grammar | The essay has numerous grammatical errors that hinder understanding. | The essay has several grammatical errors that occasionally hinder understanding. | The essay has a few grammatical errors that occasionally hinder understanding. | The essay has minimal grammatical errors that do not hinder understanding. | The essay has very few grammatical errors that do not hinder understanding. | The essay has virtually no grammatical errors. | The essay has virtually no grammatical errors and demonstrates a strong command of grammar. | The essay has virtually no grammatical errors, demonstrates a strong command of grammar, and showcases the writer’s skill. |