“`html
| Criteria | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Introduction | Poor introduction with unclear thesis | Basic introduction but thesis needs improvement | Clear introduction with a somewhat effective thesis | Engaging introduction with a strong thesis statement |
| Supporting Points | Points are unclear and not supported | Some points lack support | Most points are supported with some evidence | All points are well-supported with relevant evidence |
| Organization | Essay lacks logical order and coherence | Some organization but transitions are weak | Essay is mostly organized with clear transitions | Well-organized with smooth transitions between ideas |
| Concluding Statement | Weak or missing conclusion | Basic conclusion that restates thesis | Conclusion summarizes main points | Strong conclusion that leaves a lasting impression |
| Grammar and Mechanics | Multiple errors in grammar and mechanics | Some errors in grammar and mechanics | Few errors in grammar and mechanics | Almost no errors in grammar and mechanics |
“`