| Criteria | 1-4 points | 5-8 points | 9-12 points | 13-16 points | 17-20 points |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Organization | Writing lacks a clear beginning, middle, and end. Events are not in a logical order. | Writing has a basic beginning, middle, and end. Events are somewhat in a logical order. | Writing has a clear beginning, middle, and end. Events are in a logical order. | Writing has a strong beginning, middle, and end. Events flow smoothly and logically. | Writing has a compelling beginning, middle, and end. Events are expertly organized. |
| Content | Details are unclear and do not support the main idea. Main idea is difficult to identify. | Details are somewhat clear and support the main idea. Main idea is somewhat evident. | Details are clear and mostly support the main idea. Main idea is evident. | Details are vivid and fully support the main idea. Main idea is clearly stated. | Details are exceptionally vivid and enhance the main idea. Main idea is powerfully conveyed. |
| Grammar and Mechanics | Multiple errors in grammar, punctuation, and spelling that impede understanding. | Some errors in grammar, punctuation, and spelling that occasionally impede understanding. | Few errors in grammar, punctuation, and spelling that minimally impede understanding. | Minor errors in grammar, punctuation, and spelling that do not impede understanding. | Writing is virtually error-free in terms of grammar, punctuation, and spelling. |
| Word Count | Significantly below or above the required word count. | Slightly below or above the required word count. | Meets the required word count. | Meets and slightly exceeds the required word count. | Meets and significantly exceeds the required word count. |
| Overall Impression | Writing lacks engagement and fails to connect with the reader. | Writing is somewhat engaging but lacks a strong connection with the reader. | Writing is engaging and connects with the reader on some level. | Writing is highly engaging and effectively connects with the reader. | Writing is exceptionally engaging and deeply resonates with the reader. |