| Criteria | 0-1 points | 2-3 points | 4-5 points |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thesis Statement | Thesis is unclear or missing | Thesis is present but needs improvement | Clear and strong thesis statement |
| Research | Little to no research evident | Some research included but lacks depth | Thorough research evident with varied sources |
| Organization | Disorganized and hard to follow | Some organization but transitions are weak | Well-organized with clear transitions |
| Evidence | Lack of supporting evidence | Some evidence provided but not well integrated | Strong evidence that supports the thesis |
| Analysis | Little to no analysis of research | Some analysis but lacks depth | Thoughtful analysis that demonstrates understanding |