A Case of ‘What-Ifs’

Alphabets Sounds Video

share us on:

In this lesson, students learn how engineers use “what-if” questions to solve problems by following the engineering process, which includes defining the problem, brainstorming solutions, building prototypes, and testing them. The lesson emphasizes the importance of understanding variables—elements that can change and affect outcomes—and encourages students to practice their engineering skills by asking questions that help anticipate different scenarios. By engaging in this thought process, students can develop critical thinking and problem-solving abilities similar to those of engineers.
  1. What are some “what-if” questions you can think of that might help you solve a problem?
  2. Can you name a variable that you can control when trying to solve a problem? How does it help?
  3. Why do you think asking “what-if” questions is important for engineers when they are working on a project?

Understanding the “What-Ifs” Like an Engineer

Have you ever wondered, “What if I run out of popcorn during a movie?” or “What if it rains when I’m walking home without an umbrella?” These are the kinds of “what-if” questions we all ask ourselves sometimes. But did you know that engineers ask these questions every day? It’s a big part of how they solve problems!

The Engineering Process

When engineers face a problem, like figuring out how to cross a gorge, they follow a series of steps called the engineering process. First, they define the problem. In this case, it’s “How can we get across the gorge?” Then, they think of different solutions and pick the best one based on what materials they have and how well it solves the problem. After that, they build a prototype, which is like a practice version of their solution, and test it. If it doesn’t work, they try again. Engineers never give up!

What Are Variables?

There’s another important part of the engineering process: defining variables. A variable is something that can change. Sometimes engineers can control these variables, and sometimes they can’t. For example, if you want to see how high a ball bounces, you can change the height from which you drop it or the type of ball you use. But you can’t change gravity, which pulls the ball down to Earth.

Variables in Action

Let’s think about crossing the gorge again. What are the variables? One variable we can control is the weight of the hang glider. We can make it lighter by leaving things behind or heavier by adding more weight. We can also change the design, like the size or angle of the wings, just like when you make a paper airplane. But we can’t control the wind or gravity.

Asking “What-If” Questions

Once engineers know what variables might change, they start asking “what-if” questions. For example, “What if the wind is stronger than usual?” or “What if we leave our umbrella behind?” These questions help engineers decide if their solution will work before they try it out. It’s like making sure everything is ready before you jump into action!

Practice Your Engineering Skills

By asking “what-if” questions, you can practice thinking like an engineer. It helps you identify variables and think about how they might affect your solution. And don’t worry about forgetting what you’ve learned—just keep asking those questions and exploring new ideas!

  • Can you think of a time when you asked a “what-if” question? What was it about, and how did you try to find an answer?
  • Imagine you are planning a picnic. What “what-if” questions might you ask to make sure everything goes smoothly? How would you solve any problems that come up?
  • Have you ever built something, like a tower with blocks or a paper airplane? What variables did you think about, and how did you change them to make your creation better?
  1. Build Your Own Bridge: Gather some simple materials like popsicle sticks, tape, and string. Try to build a small bridge between two chairs or tables. As you build, think about the variables you can control, like the length of the bridge or the materials you use. Ask yourself, “What if I use more sticks?” or “What if I make the bridge wider?” Test your bridge by placing small objects on it to see how much weight it can hold. Can you make it stronger by changing one of the variables?

  2. Paper Airplane Experiment: Make a few paper airplanes using different designs. Test how far each airplane flies. Think about the variables you can change, such as the size of the wings or the weight of the paper. Ask “what-if” questions like, “What if I fold the wings differently?” or “What if I add a paperclip to the nose?” Record your observations and see which design flies the farthest.

  3. Weather Watch: Keep a weather journal for a week. Each day, write down the weather conditions and think about how they might affect your daily activities. Ask yourself questions like, “What if it rains today?” or “What if it’s windy?” Discuss with a family member or friend how these variables might change your plans and what solutions you could come up with to adapt to the weather.

All Video Lessons

Login your account

Please login your account to get started.

Don't have an account?

Register your account

Please sign up your account to get started.

Already have an account?