On a December night in 1910, Manuel Bonilla and a group of heavily armed accomplices boarded a borrowed yacht in New Orleans. Their mission was to reclaim power in Honduras by any means necessary and they had a powerful backer, the future leader of the infamous organization known as “El Pulpo” or “The Octopus,” for its extensive reach. This organization was actually the United Fruit Company, now known as Chiquita Brands International.
Bananas have been cultivated in Southeast Asia for thousands of years and eventually made their way to the Americas in the early 1500s. Slaves were responsible for cultivating them in plots alongside sugar plantations, and there were many different varieties of bananas, most of which looked nothing like the ones we find in supermarkets today.
In the 1800s, captains from New Orleans and New England traveled to the Caribbean in search of coconuts and other goods. They began experimenting with banana cultivation and eventually sold the fruit in the U.S. In an effort to grow their own bananas, US fruit companies bribed and lobbied government officials in Central America and even funded coups to ensure they had allies in power. By the 1930s, United Fruit dominated the region and owned over 40% of Guatemala’s arable land. They cleared rainforests in multiple countries to build plantations, railroads, ports, and towns to house workers.
From Guatemala to Colombia, United Fruit’s plantations only grew Gros Michel bananas, making them highly susceptible to disease epidemics due to a lack of biological diversity. This is exactly what happened in the 1910s when a fungus began to devastate Gros Michel banana plantations, first in Panama and then throughout Central America. To combat the Panama Disease, banana companies abandoned infected plantations, leaving thousands of farmers and workers jobless.
After World War II, the dictatorships with which United Fruit had partnered in Guatemala and Honduras were replaced by democratically elected governments. In the 1950s, several Latin American countries elected governments that called for land reform. However, El Pulpo was unhappy and launched propaganda campaigns against Arbenz and called on its deep connections in the U.S. Government for help. Citing fears of communism, the CIA orchestrated the overthrow of the democratically elected Arbenz in 1954.
The same year in Honduras, thousands of United Fruit workers went on strike until the company agreed to recognize a new labor union. With the political and economic costs of running from the Panama Disease escalating, United Fruit finally switched from Gros Michel to Panama disease-resistant Cavendish bananas in the early 1960s. Today, bananas are no longer as economically vital in Central America, and the United Fruit Company, now known as Chiquita, has lost its grip on Latin America.
However, the modern banana industry still faces its own set of problems. Cavendish bananas, the most popular variety, require frequent applications of pesticides, creating hazardous conditions for farm workers and ecosystems. Although they are resistant to the particular pathogen that affected Gros Michel bananas, Cavendish farms lack biological diversity, making the banana trade vulnerable to another pandemic.
Imagine you are a government official in Central America during the 1800s. The United Fruit Company is trying to bribe you to allow them to grow bananas. Role play this scenario with a partner, discussing the ethical implications and potential consequences of your decision.
Conduct a research project on the environmental impact of banana cultivation in Central America. Focus on the clearing of rainforests for plantations and the effects of pesticide use on ecosystems. Present your findings in a short report or presentation.
Participate in a class debate on the topic of land reform versus economic stability. One side will argue for the rights of local farmers and the need for land reform, while the other will argue for the economic stability provided by companies like United Fruit.
Study the Panama Disease crisis in detail. Analyze how the lack of biological diversity in banana plantations contributed to the crisis and discuss what could have been done differently to prevent it. Write a short essay on your findings.
Based on what you’ve learned about the history of the banana industry and its current challenges, make predictions about the future of the industry. Consider factors like biological diversity, pesticide use, and political influence. Share your predictions in a class discussion.
Banana – A curved, yellow fruit grown in tropical climates – Example sentence: I ate a banana for breakfast this morning.
Slaves – A person who is forced to work for another against their will – Example sentence: During the 1700s, many people were kept as slaves in the American South.
Cultivation – The act of developing land for agricultural or other purposes – Example sentence: The cultivation of the newly-discovered lands was a major factor in the settlement of the Americas.
Southeast Asia – The region in Asia that consists of countries such as Vietnam, Cambodia, and Thailand – Example sentence: Many exotic spices can be found in the markets of Southeast Asia.
Caribbean – A group of islands located in the Caribbean Sea – Example sentence: The Caribbean is known for its beautiful blue waters and white sand beaches.
New Orleans – A major port city in the US state of Louisiana – Example sentence: People travel from all over the world to attend the annual Mardi Gras celebration in New Orleans.
New England – A region in the northeastern United States consisting of the states of Connecticut, Rhode Island, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, and Maine – Example sentence: I love visiting New England in the fall when the leaves change color.
Gros Michel – An old variety of banana that is no longer commonly grown – Example sentence: The Gros Michel was once the most popular variety of banana in the world.
El Pulpo – An old variety of banana that is no longer commonly grown – Example sentence: The El Pulpo banana was popular in South and Central America, but is now almost extinct.
Chiquita Brands – A multinational corporation that is one of the largest producers and distributors of bananas in the world – Example sentence: Chiquita Brands is known for its iconic yellow bananas with the blue label.
Shipping – The transportation of goods by sea or air – Example sentence: Shipping is an important part of the global economy.
US Fruit Companies – Companies based in the United States that produce and distribute fruit products – Example sentence: US fruit companies have a significant presence in Central American countries.
Central America – A region in the southern part of North America consisting of the countries of Belize, Guatemala, El Salvador, Honduras, Nicaragua, Costa Rica, and Panama – Example sentence: Central America is known for its unique cultures and natural beauty.
Panama Disease – A fungal disease that is fatal to banana plants – Example sentence: The Panama Disease has caused the extinction of many varieties of bananas.
Jacobo Arbenz – The president of Guatemala from 1951 to 1954 – Example sentence: Jacobo Arbenz proposed land reform that threatened the interests of US fruit companies in Guatemala.
Labor Union – An organization that represents the collective interests of workers – Example sentence: The labor union advocated for better wages and working conditions for its members.
Cavendish Bananas – A type of banana that is resistant to the Panama Disease and is the most widely produced variety of banana in the world – Example sentence: Cavendish bananas are the most popular type of banana in the United States.
Pesticides – Substances used to kill pests, such as insects, weeds, and fungi – Example sentence: Farmers use pesticides to protect their crops from pests.
