“We never sleep” was the motto of the Pinkerton National Detective Agency, a famous detective agency known for its logo featuring a watchful eye. This logo inspired the term “private eye.” The agency was founded by Allan Pinkerton, a Scottish immigrant who became a legendary detective. Born on August 25, 1819, in Glasgow, Scotland, Pinkerton grew up in a tough neighborhood called the Gorbals. His father, William, died when Allan was young, leaving the family struggling financially. Allan had to leave school early to work and support his family.
Allan started as a journeyman cooper, making barrels for a living. He married Joan Carfrae, and they had three children together. While working as a cooper, Allan got involved in Chartism, a movement pushing for workers’ rights. The government wasn’t happy about this and tried to suppress the movement. After a confrontation with the law, Allan decided to leave Scotland and sail to America with his wife.
The journey to America was tough. Allan had to work on the ship to pay for their passage. After a challenging voyage, they finally reached Montreal with little more than their health and a few pennies. They aimed to settle in Chicago, where Allan’s friend Bobby Fergus lived. With Fergus’s help, Allan found work at a brewery, but he soon decided to start his own cooperage in Dundee, Illinois.
Allan’s life took a turn when he accidentally discovered a group of counterfeiters while gathering lumber. He informed the sheriff, and together they captured the criminals. This event marked the beginning of his detective career. Allan’s reputation grew when he helped catch another counterfeiter, although the criminal later escaped. Despite his success, Allan initially wanted to return to making barrels.
However, life in the countryside became dull, and when offered a deputy position by Sheriff Dearborn, Allan accepted. He continued to work as a cooper but also took on law enforcement duties. He even became involved with the Underground Railroad, helping escaped slaves find safety, which led to conflicts with the local church.
Allan moved to Chicago to become a deputy sheriff in Cook County. His bravery and integrity earned him respect, but also enemies. He survived an assassination attempt when a bullet hit his hand instead of his back. In 1849, Allan became Chicago’s first police detective but left after a year due to political issues. He then worked as a special agent for the United States Post Office, gaining more recognition.
In the early 1850s, Allan founded the Pinkerton National Detective Agency with attorney Edward Rucker. The agency quickly became known for its work with railroads, investigating thefts, fraud, and bank robberies. Allan also supported anti-slavery efforts and knew John Brown, a famous abolitionist.
During the American Civil War, Allan served as head of the Union Intelligence Service. He is credited with possibly saving President Abraham Lincoln from an assassination attempt. Despite some mistakes in his espionage work, Allan’s skills were recognized by Lincoln.
After the war, the Pinkerton Agency continued to thrive, but Allan’s health declined after a stroke in 1869. He passed most responsibilities to his sons. The agency pursued notorious criminals like the Reno Gang and Jesse James but faced criticism for its violent actions against labor movements. Allan Pinkerton died on July 1, 1884, and his sons continued the agency, which became infamous for its role in labor disputes.
Research the life of Allan Pinkerton, focusing on his journey from Scotland to America, his career as a detective, and his role during the Civil War. Create a presentation to share with the class, highlighting key events and achievements in his life. Use visuals and storytelling techniques to make your presentation engaging.
Participate in a class debate on the ethics of private detective work, using Allan Pinkerton’s methods and actions as a case study. Consider both the positive impacts and the controversies surrounding his agency. Prepare arguments for both sides and engage in a respectful discussion with your classmates.
Write a short detective story inspired by Allan Pinkerton’s adventures. Incorporate elements of mystery, suspense, and historical context. Share your story with the class, and discuss how you drew inspiration from Pinkerton’s real-life experiences.
Engage in a role-playing game where you and your classmates take on the roles of detectives in the Pinkerton Agency. Work together to solve a fictional case, using clues and teamwork to uncover the truth. Reflect on the challenges and skills required in detective work.
Research the Pinkerton Agency’s involvement in labor disputes and its impact on labor movements in the late 19th century. Write a report analyzing the agency’s actions and their consequences. Discuss your findings with the class, considering different perspectives on the agency’s role in history.
Here’s a sanitized version of the transcript:
—
Today’s video is sponsored by NordVPN. Give yourself options online by going to nordvpn.com/bio to get a two-year plan at a huge discount, plus a free gift. More on them in just a bit.
“We never sleep” was the slogan that greeted everyone who walked through the doors of the most famous detective agency in the world: the Pinkertons. Their logo, featuring a vigilant, unblinking eye, gave rise to the term “private eye.” The agency was founded by Allan Pinkerton, a Scottish immigrant and the subject of today’s video. He came from humble beginnings and led a quiet life making barrels until fate thrust him into the middle of the action. As it turned out, Pinkerton took to adventure like a duck to water.
Allan Pinkerton was born on August 25, 1819, in Glasgow, Scotland, in one of the poorest and most crime-ridden areas of the city known as the Gorbals. He was the second of two sons of William Pinkerton and Isabelle McQueen, alongside his older brother Robert. His father’s job was somewhat uncertain; some sources say he was a police sergeant, while others say he was a jailer. Regardless, William Pinkerton was injured on the job and died when Allan was still a child, leaving the family in dire financial straits. Both Pinkerton boys had to find work, which meant Allan had to forego finishing school to support his family.
In the 1841 census, Allan’s occupation was listed as journeyman cooper (a barrel maker), while his older brother was a blacksmith. For some reason, a nine-year-old boy named John Robertson is also listed as part of the household, although his relationship to the family is unclear. Allan Pinkerton married Joan Carfrae, another native of Glasgow, the following year, and they remained married until his death, having three children together.
While working as a cooper, Allan became involved in Chartism, a movement for reforms benefiting the working class. The government was not pleased with this development and tried to suppress the movement. Although many Chartist protests were peaceful, there were occasional clashes with the police. In 1842, after the Chartists gathered over three million signatures for their petition to be discussed in Parliament, they were turned down, leading to a wave of strikes and riots throughout the UK. The state responded by arresting many involved in the movement. Following a confrontation with the law, Allan found that a warrant had been issued for his arrest. With few options, he decided to leave Scotland under the cover of darkness and sail to America with his new wife.
Ironically, the Pinkertons themselves would eventually become anti-union hired agents used by American industrialists to oppress the working class. Allan’s arrival in the New World was anything but smooth; he had to work as a cooper on the ship to pay for his passage. After a four-week voyage, the vessel got caught in ice off the coast of Nova Scotia, forcing all passengers to leave everything behind and row to safety in lifeboats. By the time they reached Montreal, they only had their health and a few pennies.
The newlyweds intended to go to Chicago, where Allan had a friend named Bobby Fergus from the Gorbals. However, they had to spend an extra week in Montreal so Allan could work a bit and earn enough money for the trip to Illinois. Things improved once they arrived in Chicago; Fergus allowed them to stay with him until they got settled and found Allan a job at Lill’s Brewery as a cooper. This was their life for about a year, but eventually, Allan thought he would be more successful if he owned his own cooperage. Consequently, in 1843, the couple relocated to Dundee, Illinois, which was mainly inhabited by Scottish immigrants. There, Allan built a small cabin for himself and Joan next to the Fox River, right in the path of ranchers and farmers traveling to and from the market.
Allan worked diligently, waking up at 4:30 AM and going to bed at 8:30 PM, seven days a week, with no drinking, smoking, or dancing—just barrels all the time. His dedication paid off, and his cooperage business thrived. His wife considered those days the best of their lives, but destiny had other plans.
A career as a private eye landed in Pinkerton’s lap by chance. He often visited a remote island with good trees for lumber. One day in 1847, he noticed remnants of a campfire, which piqued his curiosity. After several failed attempts to discover who else was visiting the island, he decided to try at night and stumbled upon a ring of counterfeiters. He notified the sheriff, and together they staked out the island. After witnessing the criminals firsthand, the sheriff formed a posse and took down the entire ring. Pinkerton received credit for the bust, but he still intended to return to his old job.
However, shortly after, he got a second case when the owner of a local general store asked for help identifying another counterfeiter. Reluctantly, Pinkerton agreed, identified the criminal, and arranged for his arrest in Chicago. Although the counterfeiter escaped custody after bribing a policeman, Pinkerton’s reputation was made.
Despite wanting to return to cooping, life in the middle of nowhere began to seem a little boring. When Sheriff Dearborn offered him a position as deputy, Pinkerton jumped at the chance. He still built barrels but swapped his tools for a cudgel when needed. Around this time, he became involved with the Underground Railroad, offering his home as a safe house for escaping slaves. This brought him into conflict with the local Baptist church, which was already wary of him due to his lack of religious beliefs and his fiery temperament.
Eventually, Pinkerton was offered the position of deputy sheriff in Cook County, headquartered in Chicago. He accepted and soon sold his cooperage, moving to the big city.
Now, a quick question: how many times have you been on the internet and noticed ads that seemed tailored to your search history? Or worried about someone tracking your online activity? Fortunately, today’s video is sponsored by NordVPN, which helps internet users enhance their online experience. You may have heard me talk about what NordVPN can do for you: encrypting your internet data, moving your online activity to another location with just one click, and providing access to over 5,000 servers in 60 countries.
With NordVPN, you can also utilize their threat protection upgrade, which blocks ads, eradicates web trackers, checks for malware, and more. Right now, as part of a special deal, you can get a two-year plan at a huge discount, plus an additional month for free. If you try NordVPN and change your mind, they offer a 30-day money-back guarantee. Just head to nordvpn.com/bio for the deal or follow the link in the description box below.
Now back to today’s video.
Pinkerton worked full-time as a deputy sheriff and impressed many with his courage, integrity, and willingness to confront armed thugs. This earned him enemies and even an attempt on his life when someone tried to shoot him from behind. Fortunately, he was in the habit of walking with his left arm behind his back, so the bullet hit his hand and didn’t penetrate further. The Chicago Daily Democratic Press reported on the incident, noting that the bullet shattered the bone five inches from his wrist.
In 1849, Pinkerton was appointed Chicago’s first police detective, but he only held the position for a year before leaving due to political interference. His reputation, however, secured him a new post as a special agent with the United States Post Office, where he excelled and earned mentions in the local press. With such praise, his ambitions grew, and he eventually quit his job to open his own detective agency.
In the early 1850s, alongside Chicago attorney Edward Rucker, Allan Pinkerton founded the Northwestern Police Agency, which was quickly rebranded to the Pinkerton National Detective Agency. Contrary to popular belief, this was not the first known private detective agency; there were earlier examples in Europe and America.
The agency’s early years were fruitful, primarily working for railroads on protection services and theft investigations, along with cases of fraud, counterfeiting, and bank robbery. Pinkerton also became well-known for his anti-slavery activities and was acquainted with John Brown, a radical abolitionist leader.
When the American Civil War erupted in 1861, Pinkerton fought on the Union side and served as head of the Union Intelligence Service. His most famous moment came when he may have saved President Abraham Lincoln from an assassination attempt known as the Baltimore Plot.
Although there is ongoing debate about the plot’s authenticity, Pinkerton’s actions convinced Lincoln of his detective skills, leading to his appointment in charge of Union intelligence. However, Pinkerton’s military espionage efforts were often filled with errors, and he found himself caught in political conflicts.
After the war, demand for the Pinkertons remained high, but Allan Pinkerton’s health declined after suffering a stroke in 1869. He eventually returned to the office but delegated most of the work to his sons.
The Pinkertons pursued notorious criminals like the Reno Gang and Jesse James, but their reputation suffered due to their violent actions against labor movements. Allan Pinkerton died on July 1, 1884, and his sons continued the agency, overseeing some of the bloodiest labor union clashes in American history, forever tainting the Pinkerton name.
—
This version removes any inappropriate language and maintains a more neutral tone while preserving the essential information.
Alliance – A formal agreement or treaty between two or more nations to cooperate for specific purposes – During World War I, the alliance between France, Russia, and Britain was known as the Triple Entente.
Detective – A person, especially a police officer, whose occupation is to investigate and solve crimes – In the 19th century, the Pinkerton National Detective Agency played a significant role in labor disputes and criminal investigations.
Agency – An organization, company, or bureau that provides a particular service, especially one that is part of a government – The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) is a government agency responsible for investigating federal crimes in the United States.
Civil – Relating to ordinary citizens and their concerns, as distinct from military or ecclesiastical matters – The civil rights movement of the 1960s was a pivotal era in American history, advocating for the equal rights of African Americans.
War – A state of armed conflict between different countries or different groups within a country – The American Civil War, fought from 1861 to 1865, was a significant conflict that determined the fate of slavery in the United States.
Abolitionist – A person who advocated or supported the abolition of slavery in the U.S. – Harriet Tubman was a renowned abolitionist who helped many enslaved people escape to freedom via the Underground Railroad.
Rights – Legal, social, or ethical principles of freedom or entitlement – The Bill of Rights, the first ten amendments to the U.S. Constitution, guarantees essential rights and liberties to American citizens.
Criminal – A person who has committed a crime or is involved in illegal activities – Al Capone was a notorious criminal during the Prohibition era, known for his involvement in organized crime.
Labor – Work, especially physical work, done for wages – The labor movement in the late 19th and early 20th centuries fought for better working conditions and fair wages for workers.
Espionage – The practice of spying or using spies to obtain political or military information – During the Cold War, espionage played a crucial role as both the United States and the Soviet Union sought to gather intelligence on each other.
