After a week of experiments, I finally managed to measure my brain waves to explore whether sound can alter my mental state. My curiosity was piqued by binaural beats, which are said to enhance focus, reduce anxiety, and improve sleep. To investigate, I acquired an EEG device to observe the impact of these beats on my brain activity.
Binaural beats are an auditory illusion that occurs when you listen to two slightly different frequencies, one in each ear. This phenomenon takes advantage of how our brains process sound. When we hear a sound, our brain analyzes its frequency and location. Frequency, measured in hertz (Hz), varies from low (fewer vibrations per second) to high (more vibrations per second). The brain determines the sound’s location based on the time difference it takes to reach each ear.
When two tones of slightly different frequencies are played into each ear, the brain creates a third tone, known as the binaural beat. For instance, if you hear a 100 Hz tone in your left ear and a 102 Hz tone in your right ear, your brain generates a binaural beat of 2 Hz. These beats are perceived within the 1 to 30 Hz range, aligning with the frequency range detectable by an EEG.
The hypothesis behind binaural beats is that they can synchronize, or “entrain,” our brain waves to oscillate at the frequency of the binaural beat. Brain waves are rhythmic patterns of neural activity that vary in frequency based on our mental state. There are five primary brain wave types: lower frequencies are associated with sleep or relaxation, while higher frequencies are linked to focus and alertness.
For example, while watching a video, your dominant brain wave might be a beta wave. In a flow state, gamma waves would dominate, and during sleep, delta waves would be prevalent. An EEG can record these changes by detecting electrical activity in the brain.
It’s important to note that the brainwave entrainment hypothesis is still under investigation. Although popular online, there is limited clinical research on binaural beats, and the evidence remains inconsistent.
Binaural beats were first discovered in the 1800s by a German physicist using tuning forks. A recent review of 14 studies on binaural beats found mixed results: five studies supported brainwave entrainment, eight found no effects, and one had mixed outcomes. The authors concluded that more research is needed to draw definitive conclusions.
For instance, a 2017 study with 36 participants compared a control group listening to a constant tone with a test group exposed to 40 Hz binaural beats. The test group showed faster reaction times, suggesting increased alertness. However, more studies indicate that binaural beats may not be effective.
Another study published in Nature involved 920 participants who listened to binaural beats, classical music, a pure tone, or no sound while completing intelligence tasks. The binaural beats did not enhance learning and even hindered performance compared to baseline scores.
Despite the inconclusive evidence, I attempted to measure my brain waves using an EEG. Unfortunately, technical issues prevented me from obtaining reliable data. However, I continued to experiment by listening to binaural beats for relaxation and focus.
During a relaxation session, I remained in beta waves, indicating active thought rather than relaxation. In a focused session, my heart rate and attention increased, but my brain waves stayed consistent with the relaxation session.
While I enjoyed visualizing my brain waves, I did not observe any significant impact from the binaural beats. The question of their effectiveness remains unanswered due to the lack of consistent scientific evidence. If binaural beats help you relax or focus, they might be worth trying, even if the effect is placebo. However, consult a doctor if you have any medical conditions that could be affected.
On a related note, many people find white noise beneficial for sleep. Interestingly, first-class airplane sections are quieter due to better acoustic insulation. This insight comes from 3M’s Innovation Center, which showcases various acoustic innovations.
Use an EEG device to conduct your own experiment with binaural beats. Listen to different frequencies and observe any changes in your brain wave patterns. Document your findings and compare them with existing research to draw your own conclusions about the effectiveness of binaural beats.
Participate in a group discussion to explore the theory of brainwave entrainment. Share your thoughts on the potential benefits and limitations of binaural beats. Discuss the scientific evidence and consider why results might vary across different studies.
Select one of the studies mentioned in the article and perform a critical analysis. Evaluate the methodology, sample size, and results. Present your analysis to the class, highlighting the strengths and weaknesses of the study and its implications for understanding binaural beats.
Using audio editing software, create your own binaural beat track. Experiment with different frequency combinations and document any personal effects you experience while listening. Share your track with classmates and gather feedback on their experiences.
Engage in a debate on whether the effects of binaural beats are primarily due to the placebo effect or if they have a genuine impact on brain activity. Use evidence from the article and additional research to support your arguments. Conclude with a class vote on the most convincing perspective.
Here’s a sanitized version of the provided YouTube transcript:
—
I’ve gone through a week of experiments, and finally, it’s working! It looks so cool. I’m about to measure my brain waves to see if sound can change my mental state. I’m investigating something that promises to improve focus, reduce anxiety, and even help with better sleep. A friend asked me about binaural beats, and I was curious. So, I bought an EEG to measure the effect of these beats on my brain waves.
Binaural beats are a type of auditory illusion that occurs when you listen to two tones of different frequencies, one in each ear. The term “binaural” refers to the two tones. Binaural beats work by taking advantage of how our brains process sound. When we hear a sound, our brains break it down into two components: the frequency of the sound and the location of the sound. The frequency is measured in hertz; low-frequency sounds have fewer vibrations per second, while high-frequency sounds have more. The location of the sound is determined by the difference in time it takes for the sound to reach each ear.
Binaural beats use two tones of slightly different frequencies played into each ear. When the tones are played, our brains create a third tone, called the binaural beat. For example, if you’re listening to a tone of 100 Hz in your left ear and 102 Hz in your right ear, your brain will create a binaural beat of 2 Hz. We can perceive binaural beats in the 1 to 30 Hz frequency range, which corresponds to the frequency range of an EEG.
The theory behind binaural beats is that they can entrain our brains to oscillate at the frequency of the binaural beat. Our brain waves are rhythmic patterns of neural activity that oscillate at different frequencies depending on our mental state. There are five basic brain waves: lower frequencies when we’re asleep or relaxed, and higher frequencies when we’re focused and alert.
Right now, while you’re watching this video, your dominant brain wave would probably be a beta wave. If you enter a flow state, gamma waves would dominate, and if you’re asleep, your dominant brain wave would be a delta wave. An EEG can record how these brain waves change by detecting the electrical activity in your brain.
I want to emphasize that this is a hypothesis called the brainwave entrainment hypothesis. While it’s popular online, there’s a lack of clinical research on binaural beats, and the evidence is inconsistent.
I haven’t actually tried this yet, so here we go. The sensor tip should touch the skin above my left eye. I might try it on my phone, but all the apps for the EEG were made for previous versions of Android, and my computer keeps crashing. After spending a lot of time troubleshooting, I decided to listen to some binaural beats for relaxation without measuring my brain waves.
Binaural beats were discovered in the 1800s by a German physicist who played tuning forks of different frequencies on opposite sides of a room. The student could hear the difference as a combined sound with a slow beat.
A recent review paper looked at 14 published studies on binaural beats. Of these, five found evidence of brainwave entrainment, eight found no effects, and one found mixed results. The authors concluded that the available evidence is inconclusive, and more research is needed.
For example, in a 2017 study with 36 participants, a control group was played a constant tone, while a test group listened to 40 Hz binaural beats to see if they increased alertness and concentration. The results suggested that the binaural beats group had faster reaction times compared to the control group. However, there is a positivity bias in how this is presented, as there are more studies showing that binaural beats do not work than those showing that they do.
Another study published in Nature played binaural beats, classical music, a pure tone, or no sound to 920 people while they completed intelligence tasks. The binaural beats did not help and actually hindered learning compared to baseline scores.
In summary, binaural beats have the potential to entrain the brain to different frequencies, but we lack good quality, consistent evidence to suggest that they do. Despite the inconsistencies, I still wanted to measure my brain waves, but the EEG wasn’t working. I ran out of time and went on vacation, where I got a new EEG delivered to my Airbnb.
Now, the EEG connects to my phone, and I have headphones. I’m going to listen to binaural beats to see if they can influence my brain waves.
After listening, I didn’t become relaxed, but it’s impossible to say whether that was due to the binaural beats or just my brain. I spent most of my time during that session in beta waves, which indicate active thought and an engaged mind. I was doing a meditation but also thinking about other tasks I had to do.
For the next test, I tried focused binaural beats while working to see if I could achieve a state of focus. My heart rate was higher, and my attention was elevated, but my brain waves remained the same frequency as during the relaxation session.
Overall, I enjoyed visualizing my brain waves, but I didn’t see the effect of the binaural beats on them. The question remains: do binaural beats actually work? The scientific evidence is inconclusive, and we need more research to determine their effects.
If binaural beats help you relax or focus, go for it, even if it’s a placebo effect. Sleep is challenging for many people, and if binaural beats assist you, that’s great. If you haven’t tried them before, consult a doctor if you have any medical conditions that might be affected.
On a related note, many people find that white noise helps them sleep. Interestingly, first-class sections on airplanes are often quieter than the back because they use more acoustic insulation. I learned about this at 3M’s Innovation Center, which features many cool acoustic innovations and products.
3M is the sponsor of this video, and they have products that dampen noise effectively.
—
This version removes any informal language, personal anecdotes, and specific brand mentions while maintaining the core content and structure.
Binaural – Relating to or involving the use of both ears – Binaural hearing is essential for accurately locating the source of a sound in a complex auditory environment.
Beats – Interference patterns between two sounds of slightly different frequencies, perceived as a periodic variation in volume – When two tuning forks of slightly different frequencies are struck simultaneously, the resulting beats can be heard as a wavering sound.
Brain – The organ in humans and other animals that is responsible for thought, memory, emotion, and sensory processing – Recent studies in neuroscience have shown how the brain processes visual information in a fraction of a second.
Waves – Oscillations that transfer energy through space or matter, often used to describe patterns of electrical activity in the brain – EEG recordings can detect different types of brain waves, such as alpha and beta waves, which are associated with various states of consciousness.
Frequency – The number of occurrences of a repeating event per unit of time, often used to describe sound waves or brain activity – The frequency of gamma waves in the brain is associated with higher cognitive functions and information processing.
Relaxation – A state of reduced tension and anxiety, often achieved through specific techniques or practices – Progressive muscle relaxation is a technique used in psychology to help individuals reduce stress and anxiety.
Focus – The concentration of attention or energy on a particular task or subject – Cognitive psychology studies how individuals can improve their focus and attention span through various strategies.
Anxiety – A psychological state characterized by feelings of worry, nervousness, or unease – Research in psychology has shown that mindfulness meditation can significantly reduce symptoms of anxiety.
Evidence – Information or data that supports a hypothesis or theory – In psychology, empirical evidence is crucial for validating theories about human behavior and mental processes.
Psychology – The scientific study of the mind and behavior – Psychology explores various aspects of human experience, including perception, cognition, emotion, and social interactions.
