Can you solve the birthday cake riddle? – Marie Brodsky

Alphabets Sounds Video

share us on:

In the lesson “Counting Candles: A Birthday Dilemma,” you face the challenge of determining your giant friend’s age to create a chocolate centerpiece for his birthday cake. Using a clever strategy within a tunnel beneath the cake, you can manipulate the state of the candles to count them efficiently, employing methods such as systematic guessing and doubling your guesses to minimize the number of trips needed. Ultimately, you discover that your friend is turning 12, allowing you to prepare for the celebration while hoping to avoid any repercussions from the giant.

Counting Candles: A Birthday Dilemma

Your friend’s birthday is fast approaching, and there’s a slight problem—you’ve forgotten his age. While you know he’s older than one, his timeless appearance makes it hard to guess whether he’s two or two hundred. Adding to the complexity, your friend is a giant, and forgetting his age could have dire consequences for you.

The Cake Conundrum

The baker has crafted an impressive cake resembling a small mountain range, and your task is to sculpt the giant’s age in chocolate as the centerpiece. Counting the candles would be the obvious solution, but the cake is too tall for you to see the top. Fortunately, the baker has designed an interior tunnel that allows you to activate the candles from below. This gives you a chance to count them while the giant sleeps.

The Candle Counting Strategy

As night falls, you don a full bodysuit and prepare to navigate through vanilla cream. Inside the tunnel, you can see whether the candle above you is lit and have the ability to switch it on or off. The candles are arranged in a single loop, and in the darkness, you can’t discern the tunnel’s shape or size. With no tools or means to leave marks, you need a clever strategy to count the candles.

Solving the Puzzle

There are several ways to tackle this problem. The simplest method involves using the state of the candles to mark your position. You can light the first candle you encounter or leave it on. As you move forward, you’ll eventually find another lit candle. The challenge is determining whether it’s a new candle or the starting one.

One approach is to turn off the candle and backtrack to the start, counting the candles as you go. If the starting candle is off when you return, you’ve completed the loop and discovered the giant’s age. If not, continue to the next lit candle and repeat the process. This method will eventually work, but it could be time-consuming if many candles are lit, especially if the giant is older.

Optimizing the Solution

To find a more efficient solution, consider testing hypotheses about the giant’s age. Suppose you guess he’s turning 10. Light the starting candle, walk forward 10 candles, switch the destination candle off, and return. If the starting candle remains lit, 10 isn’t the answer. If it’s off, 10 could be correct, but it might also be a multiple of 10, such as 5 or 2.

To refine your guess, turn on all candles from 1 to 11, switch the 11th candle off, and return. The first unlit candle you encounter will indicate the exact number of candles. If no candles are extinguished, the total is higher than 10. Increase your guess systematically, perhaps by 4 each time. If there are 99 candles, this method would require 24 round trips and nearly 2,700 candle visits.

Efficient Guessing

Instead of increasing guesses linearly, consider doubling them: 10, 20, 40, and so on. This approach allows you to reach high numbers quickly while starting with smaller intervals for fewer candles. After expecting a lengthy journey, you discover the giant is only turning 12. You quickly change into more appropriate attire, sculpt the chocolate numbers, and at the party, make a wish that you’re not downwind when your friend blows out his candles.

  1. Reflect on the strategies mentioned in the article for counting the candles. Which approach do you find most effective and why?
  2. Consider the challenges of navigating the tunnel and counting candles in the dark. How would you handle the uncertainty and lack of visibility in such a situation?
  3. The article describes a scenario where forgetting a friend’s age could have significant consequences. How do you usually handle situations where you need to remember important details about others?
  4. Discuss the importance of problem-solving skills in everyday life. How can the candle counting dilemma be related to real-life problem-solving scenarios?
  5. Think about the concept of efficient guessing as described in the article. How can this strategy be applied to other areas of decision-making in your life?
  6. The article presents a creative and humorous scenario. How does humor play a role in making complex problems more approachable for you?
  7. Reflect on a time when you had to devise a strategy to solve a problem without all the necessary tools or information. What did you learn from that experience?
  8. Consider the role of patience and persistence in solving the candle counting puzzle. How do these qualities impact your approach to challenges?
  1. Interactive Candle Counting Game

    Imagine you are inside the tunnel of the giant’s cake. Create a simple game where you can simulate lighting and extinguishing candles. Use a piece of paper to draw a circle and place small objects (like coins) to represent candles. Practice counting and marking your position by turning the coins over. This will help you understand the strategy of marking and counting candles.

  2. Math Problem Solving

    Write down different scenarios with a varying number of candles (e.g., 5, 10, 15). Use the method described in the article to determine the number of candles. Work through the problem step-by-step, and then check your answer by counting the candles directly. This will help you practice logical thinking and problem-solving skills.

  3. Group Discussion and Role Play

    Form small groups and discuss different strategies to count the candles efficiently. Role-play the scenario where one student acts as the giant, another as the baker, and others as the candle counters. This activity will help you understand the importance of teamwork and different approaches to solving a problem.

  4. Creative Writing

    Write a short story or a diary entry from the perspective of the person counting the candles. Describe the challenges you face and how you overcome them. Use your imagination to add details about the giant’s birthday party. This will help you practice creative writing and empathy by putting yourself in someone else’s shoes.

  5. Mathematical Hypothesis Testing

    Using the doubling strategy mentioned in the article, create a table to test different hypotheses about the giant’s age. Start with a guess and double it each time until you find the correct number. Record your findings and discuss how this method is more efficient than linear guessing. This will help you understand the concept of exponential growth and efficient problem-solving.

CountingThe action of finding the total number of items in a set by assigning a number to each item. – In math class, we practiced counting by twos to make it easier to add larger numbers.

CandlesObjects made of wax with a wick that can be burned for light or decoration, often used in celebrations. – For her birthday, we lit ten candles on the cake and counted them as we sang.

StrategyA plan or method for achieving a specific goal, especially in problem-solving. – To win the game, we needed a good strategy to outsmart our opponents.

PuzzleA game or problem that tests a person’s ingenuity or knowledge, often requiring critical thinking to solve. – We worked together to solve the math puzzle that challenged us to find the missing numbers.

AgeThe length of time that a person has lived or a thing has existed, often measured in years. – My age is twelve, and I can use that information to help solve problems about how old I will be in five years.

GuessTo estimate or make a judgment about something without having all the information. – I had to guess the answer to the math question because I couldn’t remember the formula.

EfficientPerforming a task in the best possible manner with the least waste of time and effort. – Using a calculator made my math homework more efficient, allowing me to finish faster.

SolutionThe answer to a problem or the way to solve it. – After working through the equations, we finally found the solution to the math problem.

MethodA particular way of doing something, especially a systematic way of solving a problem. – We learned a new method for dividing fractions that made it much easier to understand.

CriticalInvolving careful judgment or evaluation, especially in thinking and problem-solving. – It is critical to check your work in math to ensure that your answers are correct.

All Video Lessons

Login your account

Please login your account to get started.

Don't have an account?

Register your account

Please sign up your account to get started.

Already have an account?