Defining Success

Alphabets Sounds Video

share us on:

In this lesson, we explored how engineers develop solutions to problems by defining what a successful solution entails. A solution is evaluated based on specific criteria, which serve as a checklist to determine its effectiveness and practicality. Using the example of crossing a canyon, we learned that the best solution is one that meets most or all of the established criteria, highlighting the importance of critical thinking in engineering problem-solving.
  1. What are some examples of solutions that engineers create to solve problems?
  2. How do engineers decide if a solution is successful or not?
  3. Why is it important for a solution to meet certain criteria?

Understanding Engineering Solutions

Hey there! Today, we’re diving into the world of engineering, but instead of focusing on problems, we’re going to talk about solutions. Engineers are always solving problems, but how do they know when they’ve found a successful solution? Let’s find out!

What is a Solution?

A solution is something that engineers design or build to solve a problem. For example, the telephone was created to help people communicate over long distances. Refrigerators keep our food fresh, and light bulbs help us see in the dark. These are all solutions to specific problems.

Defining Success

When engineers talk about success, they mean finding a solution that effectively solves the problem. But how do they decide which solution is the best? They use something called “criteria” to help them. Criteria are like a checklist of things the solution needs to do to be considered successful.

An Example: Crossing a Canyon

Imagine we have a problem: we need to get across a deep canyon with a river at the bottom. As an engineer, I need to figure out what my solution should do. Here’s my checklist:

  • It should get me to the other side safely.
  • It should be something I already have or can easily get.
  • It would be great if I could use it again once I’m on the other side.

If Superman were real and nearby, he could fly me across. But since he’s not, I have to use what I have. I have a tent, so I could make a hang glider out of it. It meets all my criteria: it’s safe, I already have it, and I can reuse it as a tent later.

Choosing the Best Solution

In engineering, the best solution is the one that meets all or most of the criteria. So, in our canyon example, the hang glider is the best choice because it ticks all the boxes. Remember, this is just a fun example, and you shouldn’t try to fly across a canyon with a tent!

So, that’s how engineers define success and choose the best solutions. They use criteria to make sure their solutions are effective and practical. Keep this in mind next time you face a problem—think like an engineer!

  • Can you think of a problem you have faced at home or school? What kind of solution did you come up with, or how did you solve it?
  • Imagine you are an engineer and need to create a new toy. What criteria would you use to decide if your toy is successful?
  • Have you ever used something in a different way than it was meant to be used, like using a book as a doorstop? How did it solve your problem, and what made it a good solution?
  1. Build Your Own Bridge: Gather some simple materials like popsicle sticks, string, and tape. Challenge yourself to build a bridge that can hold a small toy car. Think about the criteria your bridge needs to meet: it should be strong enough to hold the car, it should be stable, and it should be long enough to span a gap between two books. Once you’ve built your bridge, test it with the toy car. Did it meet all your criteria? If not, how can you improve it?

  2. Design a Solution for a Problem at Home: Look around your home and find a small problem that needs solving. It could be something like organizing your toys or keeping your pencils from rolling off the table. Think like an engineer and come up with a solution. Draw a picture of your idea and list the criteria that will make your solution successful. Share your idea with a family member and see if they have any suggestions to make it even better!

  3. Observation Walk: Take a walk around your neighborhood or a local park with an adult. Look for examples of engineering solutions, like bridges, playground equipment, or streetlights. Discuss what problem each solution is solving and what criteria might have been used to design it. For example, a playground slide should be safe, fun, and durable. Can you think of any improvements or new solutions that could be added to your community?

All Video Lessons

Login your account

Please login your account to get started.

Don't have an account?

Register your account

Please sign up your account to get started.

Already have an account?