ClassX Video Lessons Youtube Channel Science Time Did We Receive a Signal From Aliens? Brian Greene on Space Travel & ET
The question of whether advanced civilizations inevitably destroy themselves is a thought-provoking one. This idea is a potential explanation for the Fermi Paradox, which asks why we haven’t encountered extraterrestrial life despite the vastness of the universe. It’s possible that by the time a civilization develops the technology for interstellar travel, it may have already met its demise. This is a sobering thought, especially when considering the challenges humanity faces on Earth.
The Fermi Paradox highlights the contradiction between the high probability of extraterrestrial life and the lack of evidence for it. While the night sky, filled with stars and planets, suggests we are not alone, physicist Enrico Fermi reminds us that we need concrete evidence to confirm the existence of aliens. The Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI) is dedicated to finding such evidence by monitoring electromagnetic signals from space.
SETI uses radio telescopes to detect artificial signals, which would be characterized by their repetitive nature and narrow bandwidths. A significant event in this search was the detection of the “Wow! signal” on August 15, 1977, by the Big Ear radio telescope at Ohio State University. This strong radio signal, originating from the direction of the constellation Sagittarius, remains one of the most compelling candidates for an extraterrestrial transmission.
In recent years, the discovery of BLC1 (Breakthrough Listen Candidate 1) has reignited interest in the search for alien signals. Detected in 2019 and reported in 2020, BLC1 appeared to come from Proxima Centauri, the closest star to our solar system. This signal, characterized by its narrow frequency range, sparked excitement about the possibility of extraterrestrial life.
However, further analysis suggested that BLC1 might not be a signal from an alien civilization. Researchers, including Brian Metzger, proposed that the signal could be attributed to a magnetar, a type of neutron star with intense magnetic fields. This highlights the complexity of distinguishing between natural cosmic phenomena and potential extraterrestrial communications.
While radio signals are one way we imagine communicating with aliens, there may be other methods beyond our current understanding. The lack of evidence for extraterrestrial life doesn’t necessarily mean it doesn’t exist. It could mean that we need to take the initiative to explore space and seek out other civilizations.
Our current fastest spacecraft, the Parker Solar Probe, travels at 330,000 miles per hour. While impressive, this speed is insufficient for reaching distant stars. Concepts like the Alcubierre warp drive, which theoretically manipulates space-time to allow faster-than-light travel, offer intriguing possibilities, though they remain speculative.
Alternative methods, such as solar sails or wormholes, could also enable interstellar travel. The theory of relativity suggests that traveling near the speed of light could allow humans to explore vast distances within a lifetime, despite the immense scales involved.
Humanity has always been driven by a spirit of exploration, whether it’s traversing the Earth or delving into the mysteries of the universe. This innate curiosity is crucial for our future as a species. By uniting our efforts and focusing on exploration rather than conflict, we may one day achieve interstellar travel and discover new worlds.
In conclusion, while the search for extraterrestrial life continues, the journey itself is a testament to our desire to understand the universe. Whether through advanced technology or the power of human imagination, the quest to explore the cosmos remains an integral part of our identity.
Engage in a structured debate with your classmates about the Fermi Paradox. Divide into two groups: one supporting the idea that advanced civilizations inevitably destroy themselves, and the other arguing against it. Use evidence from the article and additional research to support your arguments.
Participate in a workshop where you analyze simulated radio signals. Learn to distinguish between natural cosmic phenomena and potential extraterrestrial communications. Use software tools to examine signal patterns and discuss your findings with peers.
Work in teams to design a theoretical concept for interstellar travel. Consider technologies like the Alcubierre warp drive, solar sails, or wormholes. Present your concept to the class, explaining the scientific principles and potential challenges involved.
Research the history and current efforts of the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI). Create a presentation that outlines SETI’s methodologies, significant findings like the “Wow! signal,” and future directions in the search for alien life.
Write a short story or essay imagining humanity’s first contact with an extraterrestrial civilization. Consider the implications for society, science, and culture. Share your story with the class and discuss the potential realities of such an encounter.
Here’s a sanitized version of the provided YouTube transcript:
—
Is it the case that any sufficiently advanced civilization destroys itself? Is that a common quality? I mean, that’s another potential answer to the Fermi Paradox: why aren’t they here? Because by the time they reached the technological development necessary to travel here, they may have destroyed themselves. This is an unfortunate but not hard-to-imagine possibility, based on events that have occurred here on Earth.
We’ve discussed the Fermi Paradox many times in our videos. The question of whether there is life elsewhere in the universe is fundamental to our core curiosity, and it will never be satisfied until we have a definitive answer. While we may be captivated when we look at the night sky, filled with countless stars and Earth-like planets, and think we cannot possibly be alone in the galaxy, physicist Enrico Fermi reminds us that we need evidence to infer the existence of aliens, hence his famous paradox.
But what if there was actual physical evidence suggesting extraterrestrials are communicating with us? How would our worldview change if we found out aliens made contact? The Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI) constantly monitors electromagnetic radiation for signs of transmissions from civilizations on other planets. Many radio frequencies penetrate Earth’s atmosphere well, leading to the development of radio telescopes that investigate the cosmos using large antennas. These signals would be easy to recognize as artificial due to their repetitive nature and narrow bandwidths.
One way of discovering an extraterrestrial civilization might be to detect artificial radio emissions from outside our solar system. On August 15, 1977, the Ohio State University’s Big Ear radio telescope picked up a strong band radio signal that appeared to come from the direction of the constellation Sagittarius and bore the expected hallmarks of extraterrestrial origin. It became known as the “Wow! signal” after astronomer Jerry R. Ehman discovered the anomaly a few days later while reviewing the recorded data. He was so impressed by the result that he circled the reading of the signal’s intensity and wrote the comment “Wow!” The Wow! signal remains the strongest candidate for an extraterrestrial radio transmission ever detected.
However, only in the past three years have things gotten quite interesting. BLC1, which stands for Breakthrough Listen Candidate 1, was a candidate SETI radio signal detected and observed during April and May 2019 and first reported in December 2020. This signal coincided with the direction of the solar system’s closest star, Proxima Centauri. The signal appeared to be a tight beam, very constrained within a specific frequency range, and seemed to be coming from Proxima Centauri, which is about four light-years away.
Yuri Milner, who has been supporting research in science and the search for extraterrestrial intelligence, has been backing researchers in their efforts to scour the sky for signals of extraterrestrial intelligence. When a signal like this appears, the natural thought is that maybe extraterrestrial life is out there. It’s always exciting; I wrote a short story years ago about a boy on a mission to rendezvous with the first life we have made contact with beyond Earth, and indeed, the signal is from Proxima Centauri. It would be fascinating if that story had some basis in reality.
Many papers have been written to explain the origin of BLC1. A paper released shortly before the news about BLC1 reported the detection of a bright, long-duration optical flare accompanied by a series of intense coherent radio bursts from Proxima Centauri. However, it’s challenging to know for certain if these events are related. A study proposed that the chance of a radio-transmitting civilization emerging near the Sun’s closest stellar neighbor is extremely small, making BLC1 very unlikely to be a technological radio signal from the Alpha Centauri system. Yet, people still hold hope that it could be an alien civilization sending us a signal.
By carefully analyzing new data, Brian Metzger and his colleagues concluded that the fast radio burst recently observed is likely due to a magnetar, which is a type of neutron star with very powerful magnetic fields. In this case, the belief is that this kind of object is the source of the radio signatures. So, it’s not extraterrestrial communication but rather an exotic and intriguing source of these signals.
Of course, radio signals are not the only way we think aliens might communicate with us. Perhaps there are methods of communication that we cannot even fathom. However, from our perspective, there is no distinction between a civilization that is so advanced we cannot detect it and one that doesn’t exist. This presents a challenge with the surge of recent UFO footage. If fuzzy video clips of unidentified flying objects—what the U.S. government calls unidentified aerial phenomena—are the only evidence suggesting aliens exist and are visiting us, then we are certainly nowhere near answering the question of whether we are alone.
If we do not hear from aliens at all, that doesn’t mean it’s evidence of their absence. It may suggest that we should be the ones to start exploring space and try to communicate with them. If our civilization survives and reaches distant stars to find life elsewhere, our descendants will be the ones called aliens. But who knows how far into the future that scenario lies, if at all?
Our current fastest spacecraft, the Parker Solar Probe, has reached an impressive speed of 330,000 miles per hour. Depending on perspective, this is either extremely fast or slow. If we want to reach distant alien worlds, we need better, more efficient ways for space travel. The Alcubierre warp drive is a speculative concept based on a solution to Einstein’s field equations in general relativity. Theoretically, this drive would create a wave that contracts space ahead of the spacecraft and expands space behind it. Although this metric is consistent with Einstein’s equations, constructing such a drive may not be feasible.
Fortunately, it is not the only way for radically fast space travel. I think it’s all quite exciting. The idea of using solar sails and taking that first step to Mars is vital and valuable. Building wormholes, as depicted in science fiction, or trying to travel near the speed of light could allow us to traverse interstellar distances. Without such advancements, our colonization efforts will occur at a very slow rate.
One of the beauties of relativity is that if you travel near the speed of light, you can actually go arbitrarily far in a human lifetime. People often ask how that’s possible, given that you can’t travel billions of light-years. However, due to the nature of space and time, it is theoretically possible to achieve this.
Putting the physics of space and time manipulation aside, how do we terraform other planets? How do we explore beyond our local neighborhood without relying on relativity? I believe we have long been a species of explorers, both in the literal sense of traveling from one part of the world to another and in the metaphorical sense of exploring our minds, the quantum realm, or the mysteries of the universe.
This exploratory spirit is fundamentally part of who we are. With all our faults, we are, as far as we know, the only hope for this corner of the galaxy to achieve interstellar travel. If we unite our strengths and work together instead of scheming to destroy one another, we might see light at the end of the tunnel—or a wormhole—where a spacecraft full of our descendants appears, united in celebration, and begins exploring space.
Thanks for watching! If you enjoyed this video, please show your support by subscribing and ringing the bell to never miss future videos.
—
This version removes any informal language, filler words, and personal anecdotes while retaining the core ideas and information.
Signal – A detectable physical quantity or impulse by which information can be transmitted. – The radio telescope detected a faint signal from a distant galaxy, sparking interest among astronomers.
Extraterrestrial – Originating, located, or occurring outside Earth or its atmosphere. – Scientists are constantly searching for extraterrestrial life forms that might exist on planets orbiting other stars.
Fermi – Referring to Enrico Fermi, an Italian-American physicist known for his work on the development of quantum theory, nuclear and particle physics, and statistical mechanics. – The Fermi paradox questions why, given the high probability of extraterrestrial life, there is no evidence of such civilizations contacting us.
Paradox – A statement or phenomenon that contradicts itself or defies intuition. – The twin paradox in relativity theory illustrates how time can pass at different rates for individuals in different frames of reference.
Space – The vast, seemingly infinite expanse that exists beyond the Earth’s atmosphere, where celestial bodies are located. – The study of space has led to numerous technological advancements and a deeper understanding of the universe.
Travel – The act of moving through space, especially in the context of moving between celestial bodies or through the universe. – Space travel requires overcoming significant challenges, such as radiation exposure and the effects of microgravity on the human body.
Civilization – A complex society characterized by the development of cultural, technological, and governmental structures. – The discovery of an advanced extraterrestrial civilization would have profound implications for humanity’s understanding of its place in the universe.
Telescope – An optical instrument designed to make distant objects appear nearer, containing an arrangement of lenses or mirrors or both. – The Hubble Space Telescope has provided invaluable data, allowing astronomers to observe distant galaxies and nebulae.
Universe – The totality of known or supposed objects and phenomena throughout space; the cosmos. – The Big Bang theory is the prevailing cosmological model explaining the early development of the universe.
Exploration – The action of traveling in or through an unfamiliar area in order to learn about it, especially in the context of space. – The exploration of Mars has been a major focus of recent space missions, with rovers providing detailed analyses of the planet’s surface.
