Have you ever wondered if there was such a thing as a “good” pirate? While pirates might seem cool in movies and stories, they were actually pretty dangerous and caused a lot of trouble in real life. This is the story of Edward England, a pirate captain who tried to be kind, even to his enemies, and ended up being abandoned by his own crew because of it.
Edward England’s early life is a bit of a mystery. We think he was born around 1685 in Ireland, but he doesn’t show up in history until he became a sailor. Back then, a big war called the War of Spanish Succession broke out when the King of Spain died without an heir. England was on the side that wanted to keep France and Spain separate. After the war ended in 1714, many sailors turned to piracy, but England found a job on a merchant ship sailing from Jamaica.
During one of his trips, England’s ship was attacked by pirates led by Captain Christopher Winter. England was forced to join Winter’s crew and ended up in Nassau, a pirate hotspot in the Caribbean. Even though he didn’t really want to be a pirate, he accepted his new life. By 1716, he was part of a crew trying to recover treasure from a Spanish fleet that had sunk off the coast of Florida. This treasure hunt led to a surge in piracy in the Caribbean.
In 1718, Edward England became the captain of his own ship, the Fancy. He decided not to accept a pardon offered by the British crown to stop being a pirate. Instead, he sailed to Africa and started capturing ships. In 1719, he had a successful year, capturing many ships with ease. However, after a violent encounter in a port town, he and his crew headed to the East Indies, arriving in Madagascar in 1720.
England’s luck changed when he met Captain James McRae of the Cassandra. They fought a fierce battle, and although England won, he lost many men. His crew began to resent him because he was too kind-hearted, even to his enemies. Eventually, his crew turned against him and left him stranded on a deserted island.
Luckily, the island had enough resources for England and a few loyal crew members to survive. They managed to build a small boat and sail to Madagascar. Unfortunately, England arrived in poor health and had to beg for help from other pirates. His story ends sadly, as he likely died in 1721 from a tropical disease.
Edward England’s story shows that even in the rough world of piracy, being too compassionate could lead to trouble. If you enjoyed learning about this pirate’s life, don’t forget to explore more fascinating stories from history!
Imagine you are Edward England. Write a diary entry describing a day in your life as a pirate captain. Include details about your ship, the Fancy, your crew, and your feelings about being a pirate. Share your diary entry with the class and discuss how England’s compassion might have affected his leadership.
Using a world map, trace Edward England’s journey from Ireland to the Caribbean, Africa, and finally Madagascar. Mark key locations mentioned in the article and research one interesting fact about each place. Present your map and findings to the class.
Divide into two groups and hold a debate on whether Edward England was a “good” pirate. One group will argue that his compassion made him a good pirate, while the other will argue that his actions still caused harm. Use evidence from the article to support your arguments.
Create a flag that represents Edward England’s values and leadership style. Think about symbols that reflect his compassion and experiences. Present your flag to the class and explain the meaning behind your design.
Imagine you are stranded on a deserted island like Edward England. List the resources you would need to survive and how you would use them. Work in groups to create a survival plan and present it to the class, explaining how you would ensure your group’s safety and well-being.
Here’s a sanitized version of the provided YouTube transcript:
—
Today’s video is brought to you by Babbel, the number one language app in the world with more than 10 million subscribers worldwide. The world is getting smaller, and your reasons for learning another language are growing. Whether your language needs are tied to international travel, professional necessity, or personal curiosity, there’s no better option than Babbel.
You may have tried some basic free apps from the app store, but Babbel goes beyond the basics with 14 languages and proven learning techniques. Why is Babbel better? With Babbel, you can count on experienced language teachers rather than just relying on machine learning like other apps. Plus, it’s completely ad-free, allowing you to focus on learning without distractions. Babbel teaches you about real-life situations you’ll encounter, making it practical and relevant.
It’s easy to jump in and practice whenever you have a moment, and those short practice sessions add up. Start learning a new language today with Babbel, and for a limited time, you can get up to 65% off the cost of a subscription. There’s a link below.
Now, was there ever such a thing as a good pirate? They might be popular today, but historically, they were responsible for a lot of hardship and sorrow. The freedom and danger of life on the open sea may romanticize pirates in our minds, but they were ruthless criminals. This is the story of Edward England, a pirate captain who tried to spare the lives of his fiercest enemies and was marooned by his own men for his efforts.
We often include a note in our pirate biographies known as the “Johnson Disclaimer.” The main contemporary source for the life of Edward England is the book “General History of the Pirates” by Captain Charles Johnson, whose accuracy is questionable. The identity of the author is not truly known, as Charles Johnson was a pseudonym for one or multiple writers. With that in mind, there is uncertainty surrounding Edward England’s early life, as he does not appear in the historical record until he became a sailor.
We estimate that Edward England was born around 1685 in Ireland. In November 1700, King Charles II of Spain died without an heir, causing a power struggle that triggered the War of Spanish Succession. England was part of the side that wanted to keep the kingdoms of France and Spain separate. After the war ended in 1714, many sailors turned to piracy, but England found legitimate employment as a mate aboard a merchant sloop sailing out of Jamaica.
During one voyage, the ship was attacked by a pirate vessel captained by Christopher Winter, who forced England to join his crew. Winter sailed back to Nassau, a haven for many pirates in the Caribbean. Edward England joined their ranks, and although he seemed reluctant to become a pirate, he accepted this new life.
By 1716, he was part of Henry Jennings’s crew, fighting to recover treasure from a Spanish fleet that sank off the coast of Florida. The 1715 treasure fleet was filled with gold and silver, and when news of the sunken fleet reached Jennings, he set out to salvage the treasure. This led to a wave of piracy in the Caribbean, and eventually, the British crown appointed Captain Woods Rogers as the first governor of the Bahamas in 1717 to suppress piracy.
Many pirates accepted the King’s pardon, including Henry Jennings, but Edward England did not. By 1718, he was captain of his own ship, the Fancy, and chose to continue his life as a pirate. He sailed to the coasts of Africa, where he began taking prizes, capturing numerous ships with little effort.
In 1719, England had a successful year, capturing over a dozen prizes. However, after a violent encounter with locals in a port town, he and his crew decided to head to the East Indies. They arrived at Madagascar in early 1720, targeting mainly Indian and Dutch merchant ships.
England’s fortunes changed when he encountered Captain James McRae of the Cassandra, leading to a violent engagement. Despite winning the battle, England suffered heavy losses, and resentment grew among his crew due to his compassionate nature. Eventually, his crew turned against him, leading to his marooning on a deserted island.
Fortunately, the island was uninhabited but had plenty of resources. After some time, England and a few crew members managed to build a small boat and sail to Madagascar. However, he arrived in poor health and reduced to begging for help from other pirates.
Charles Johnson does not mention Edward England’s ultimate fate, but other sources suggest he died shortly after in 1721, possibly from a tropical disease. It was an ignoble end for a man perceived as too compassionate for his own good.
If you found this video interesting, please hit the thumbs up button below and don’t forget to subscribe. Check out our fantastic sponsor, Babbel, linked below. Thank you for watching!
—
This version maintains the core content while removing any inappropriate or sensitive language.
Edward – A common name in English history, often associated with kings and other historical figures. – Edward was a popular name among English monarchs, with several kings named Edward ruling over England in the past.
England – A country that is part of the United Kingdom, known for its rich history and cultural heritage. – England has a long history of monarchy, with famous rulers like Queen Elizabeth I and King Henry VIII.
Pirate – A person who attacks and robs ships at sea, often during the 17th and 18th centuries. – Pirates were notorious for their daring raids on merchant ships in the Caribbean during the Golden Age of Piracy.
History – The study of past events, particularly in human affairs. – Learning about history helps us understand how past events have shaped the world we live in today.
Sailor – A person who works on a ship, especially one who is involved in navigating or operating the vessel. – The sailor skillfully navigated the ship through the stormy seas to reach the safety of the harbor.
Treasure – A collection of valuable items, such as gold, silver, and jewels, often sought after by pirates. – The legend of the hidden treasure on the deserted island attracted adventurers from all over the world.
Caribbean – A region consisting of the Caribbean Sea, its islands, and the surrounding coasts, known for its historical significance in trade and exploration. – The Caribbean was a hotspot for pirate activity due to its busy trade routes and numerous islands.
Compassion – A feeling of deep sympathy and concern for the suffering of others, often accompanied by a desire to help. – The captain showed compassion by ensuring that all crew members were well cared for during the long voyage.
Crew – A group of people who work together on a ship, responsible for its operation and maintenance. – The crew worked tirelessly to repair the ship after it was damaged in the storm.
Survival – The act of continuing to live or exist, especially in difficult conditions. – The survival of the shipwrecked sailors depended on their ability to find food and fresh water on the deserted island.