Edward Snowden: Hero or Traitor?

Alphabets Sounds Video

share us on:

The lesson explores the complex narrative surrounding Edward Snowden, who, in 2013, leaked classified NSA documents revealing extensive government surveillance on American citizens. While some view him as a courageous whistleblower advocating for privacy rights, others label him a traitor for compromising national security. Snowden’s actions ignited global debates about privacy, government oversight, and the balance between security and civil liberties, leaving a lasting impact on public discourse and policy.

Edward Snowden: Hero or Traitor?

Unveiling the Secrets

Throughout US history, there have been several significant leaks that exposed government secrets, such as the Pentagon Papers and the Iraq War Logs. However, one of the most impactful leaks occurred in 2013 when Edward Snowden, a contractor for the National Security Agency (NSA), revealed how the agency was secretly collecting data on millions of Americans. This revelation shocked the world and sparked intense debates about privacy and government surveillance.

Who is Edward Snowden?

Edward Snowden, a young computer expert from North Carolina, became a controversial figure overnight. Currently living in Russia under asylum, he is seen by some as a brave whistleblower who risked everything to expose the truth. Others view him as a traitor who betrayed his country. Snowden’s story is complex and filled with contradictions, making it difficult to categorize him as simply a hero or a villain.

The Early Years

Born on June 21, 1983, in Elizabeth City, North Carolina, Snowden grew up in a family with strong military ties. His grandfather was a rear admiral, and his father worked in the Coast Guard. Despite this background, Snowden faced challenges during his high school years, eventually dropping out due to illness. However, he discovered his passion for technology while taking computer classes at Anne Arundel Community College, located near the NSA headquarters.

Entering the World of Intelligence

After the September 11 attacks, US intelligence agencies sought tech-savvy individuals to help combat new threats. Snowden transitioned from a security guard to an IT role at the NSA and later joined the CIA, working in Geneva, Switzerland. Despite enjoying the benefits of his job, he became disillusioned with the agency’s operations and resigned in 2009. He then worked as a contractor for Dell on NSA projects.

Growing Concerns

In 2010, the release of the “Collateral Murder” video by Wikileaks changed public perception of US military actions. Snowden became increasingly concerned about the lack of oversight on government surveillance. By 2011, he began downloading classified documents, preparing to reveal them to the world. In 2012, he reached out to the Tor Project, which focuses on internet privacy, and later joined Booz Allen Hamilton for greater access to sensitive information.

The Leak

In December 2012, Snowden contacted journalist Glenn Greenwald, setting the stage for the release of NSA documents. By May 2013, Snowden had left Hawaii and traveled to Hong Kong with a cache of classified files. On June 6, 2013, Greenwald’s first article on NSA surveillance practices was published, causing a global uproar. Snowden was soon identified as the source of the leaks.

Life on the Run

As the news spread, Snowden’s life changed dramatically. He sought asylum and managed to evade capture with the help of various individuals. On June 23, 2013, he arrived in Moscow, where he was granted temporary refugee status.

The Impact

Snowden’s revelations had a profound impact worldwide. In the UK, intelligence agencies took steps to protect their operations, while in the US, President Obama initiated a review of surveillance practices. The leaks also influenced data protection laws in the EU and other countries. Snowden’s legacy remains a topic of debate, symbolizing the ongoing discussion about privacy and government surveillance. Whether seen as a hero or a traitor, his story continues to unfold, leaving an indelible mark on history.

  1. How did the article change or reinforce your perception of Edward Snowden as either a hero or a traitor?
  2. What aspects of Snowden’s early life and career do you think most influenced his decision to leak NSA documents?
  3. In what ways do you think Snowden’s actions have impacted global discussions on privacy and government surveillance?
  4. How do you feel about the balance between national security and individual privacy in light of Snowden’s revelations?
  5. What are your thoughts on the role of whistleblowers in society, and how does Snowden’s story fit into this narrative?
  6. How do you think Snowden’s background and personal experiences shaped his views on government transparency?
  7. What lessons can be learned from Snowden’s story about the ethical responsibilities of individuals working in intelligence and technology fields?
  8. How do you think Snowden’s legacy will influence future policies on data protection and surveillance?
  1. Debate: Hero or Traitor?

    Engage in a classroom debate where you take on the role of either defending or opposing Edward Snowden’s actions. Research his motivations, the impact of his leaks, and the legal implications. Present your arguments and counterarguments to your classmates, and be prepared to answer questions from the opposing side.

  2. Timeline Creation

    Create a detailed timeline of Edward Snowden’s life and the events leading up to and following the 2013 leaks. Include key moments from his early years, career in intelligence, and the aftermath of the leaks. Use visuals and multimedia elements to make your timeline engaging and informative.

  3. Research Project: Government Surveillance

    Conduct a research project on the evolution of government surveillance practices in the US and globally. Explore how Snowden’s revelations have influenced these practices and discuss the balance between national security and individual privacy. Present your findings in a report or presentation format.

  4. Role-Playing: The Journalist’s Perspective

    Assume the role of a journalist like Glenn Greenwald. Write an article or create a video report on the Snowden leaks, considering the ethical dilemmas and journalistic responsibilities involved. Discuss how you would handle sensitive information and the potential consequences of publishing such material.

  5. Mock Trial: Edward Snowden

    Participate in a mock trial where you assume the roles of prosecution, defense, and jury members. Examine the legal charges against Snowden and present evidence and testimonies. Deliberate on whether Snowden’s actions were justified or if he should be held accountable for his leaks.

**Sanitized Transcript:**

The Pentagon Papers, the Iraq War Logs… US history is full of infamous leaks that exposed government actions. But there’s one set of leaks that stands out above the rest. In 2013, a contractor with the National Security Agency (NSA) quietly handed a cache of documents to The Guardian, detailing how the NSA had been collecting information on millions of Americans while misleading Congress. It was one of the most explosive stories of the post-9/11 era. The individual behind it? Edward Snowden.

A young computer expert from North Carolina, Snowden is now a controversial figure. Currently living in asylum in Russia, he is both admired and criticized by many. To some, he is a courageous whistleblower who sacrificed everything to reveal the truth. To others, he is viewed as a modern-day defector. However, the reality is more nuanced than either portrayal. Snowden’s life is filled with contradictions and complexities.

**Early Years – The Drop Out**

If you know the name Elizabeth City, North Carolina, it’s likely due to the Coast Guard base, one of the busiest in the US. The Snowden family was no exception to the base’s influence. Edward Joseph Snowden was born on June 21, 1983, into a family with strong military ties. His maternal grandfather was a rear admiral, and his father worked in the Coast Guard. This background instilled a deep respect for military service in Snowden, but it was also marked by the gradual breakdown of his parents’ marriage.

Lonnie and Elizabeth Snowden, high school sweethearts, married young. Despite Elizabeth’s epilepsy, she managed to work as a district court clerk, moving the family to Maryland in 1992. However, their new life was not easy. As their marriage deteriorated, young Snowden faced challenges in high school. Despite his intelligence, he struggled academically and ultimately flunked out after missing months of school due to illness.

In an attempt to turn things around, Snowden enrolled in computer classes at Anne Arundel Community College, where he discovered his exceptional tech skills. His location in Ellicott City, near NSA Headquarters, would later prove significant.

In 2003, the US invaded Iraq, prompting a nationwide call for recruits. Feeling compelled to join, Snowden enlisted in May 2004 but was discharged after a short time due to injuries. He returned to Maryland, unemployed, until he found a security guard job at the Centre for Advanced Study of Language, which was backed by the NSA.

**A World of Shadows**

After the Soviet Union’s collapse, US intelligence agencies downsized, but everything changed after September 11, 2001. Faced with new threats, agencies sought to recruit tech-savvy individuals. Within months, Snowden transitioned from security to IT at the NSA. By mid-2006, he received a job offer from the CIA, which he accepted, leading to a position in Geneva, Switzerland.

While he enjoyed the perks of his job, including travel and a comfortable lifestyle, he became increasingly disillusioned with the CIA’s operations. In 2008, he witnessed actions that troubled him, leading to his resignation in 2009. After leaving the CIA, Snowden took a job as a contractor for Dell, working on NSA projects.

**Secret Plots and “Spooky Types”**

In 2010, the release of the “Collateral Murder” video by Wikileaks marked a turning point in public perception of US military actions. As Snowden became aware of the NSA’s activities, he grew concerned about the lack of public scrutiny regarding government surveillance. By 2011, he began downloading classified documents that would later be revealed to the world.

In early 2012, Snowden reached out to the Tor Project, which focused on internet privacy. As he prepared to leak NSA secrets, he changed jobs again, this time to Booz Allen Hamilton, where he had greater access to sensitive information.

**The Heist of the Century**

In December 2012, Snowden contacted journalist Glenn Greenwald, leading to a series of communications that would culminate in the release of NSA documents. By May 2013, Snowden had made plans to leave Hawaii, where he had been working, and traveled to Hong Kong with a cache of classified documents.

On June 6, 2013, Greenwald’s first article detailing NSA surveillance practices was published, triggering a significant response from the agency. Within days, Snowden was identified as the source of the leaks.

**The Fugitive**

As the news broke, Snowden’s life changed dramatically. He sought asylum, and with the help of various individuals, he managed to evade capture. On June 23, 2013, he arrived in Moscow, where he was granted temporary refugee status.

**The Aftermath**

The fallout from Snowden’s revelations was profound. In the UK, intelligence agencies took measures to protect their operations, while in the US, President Obama initiated a review of surveillance practices. The leaks also influenced data protection laws in the EU and other countries.

Snowden’s legacy remains complex. He has become a symbol of the debate over privacy and government surveillance. While some view him as a hero, others see him as a traitor. His story continues to evolve, and the final chapter has yet to be written.

HistoryThe study of past events, particularly in human affairs. – The history of the Roman Empire provides valuable insights into the governance and culture of ancient civilizations.

GovernmentThe governing body of a nation, state, or community. – The government implemented new policies to address the economic challenges facing the country.

SurveillanceClose observation, especially of a suspected spy or criminal. – The government’s increased surveillance measures raised concerns about citizens’ privacy rights.

PrivacyThe state or condition of being free from being observed or disturbed by other people. – The debate over digital privacy has intensified with the rise of social media and data collection practices.

WhistleblowerA person who informs on a person or organization engaged in an illicit activity. – The whistleblower exposed the corruption within the government agency, leading to significant reforms.

IntelligenceThe collection of information of military or political value. – The intelligence gathered by the agency was crucial in preventing the potential threat to national security.

LeaksThe release of confidential information to the public. – The leaks of classified documents sparked a global debate on the ethics of government transparency.

AsylumProtection granted by a nation to someone who has left their native country as a political refugee. – The journalist sought asylum in a foreign country after exposing government corruption in his homeland.

DocumentsWritten, drawn, presented, or recorded material that provides information or evidence. – The historical documents revealed new insights into the founding fathers’ intentions when drafting the Constitution.

LegacySomething transmitted by or received from an ancestor or predecessor from the past. – The legacy of the civil rights movement continues to influence contemporary discussions on equality and justice.

All Video Lessons

Login your account

Please login your account to get started.

Don't have an account?

Register your account

Please sign up your account to get started.

Already have an account?