Quantum computing is a hot topic in the media today, and while the attention is great, there are some common misunderstandings. Quantum computing is complex, and it’s important to clarify some of these misconceptions. Here are five key points to help you better understand quantum computing.
Quantum computers are often described as machines made of qubits that can exist in a state of 0 and 1 simultaneously. This leads to the idea that they function like infinitely parallel computers. However, this is not entirely accurate. While qubits can exist in multiple states before measurement, once measured, they collapse to a single state. In contrast, parallel computing involves dividing a problem into smaller parts that can be solved independently and simultaneously. The architecture of parallel computers is fundamentally different from that of quantum computers, which do not operate by running independent processes that can be read at any time.
Imagine someone claims to have developed a quantum algorithm requiring a hundred qubits, and another person says they have a quantum computer with a hundred qubits. It might seem that the algorithm can run on that machine, but this is often not the case. The algorithm refers to ideal theoretical qubits, known as logical qubits, while the quantum computer refers to real physical qubits, which are subject to noise. This noise can disrupt quantum algorithms and destroy quantum states, making the quality of qubits crucial for performance.
Quantum error correction is a theoretical method to reduce noise in qubits by using multiple physical qubits to simulate one logical qubit. The number of physical qubits needed depends on their quality; better quality means fewer qubits are required. Estimates suggest that simulating one logical qubit could require anywhere from 10,000 to 100 physical qubits.
Many internet encryption methods rely on the difficulty of factoring large numbers with classical computers. Shor’s algorithm, a quantum algorithm, can theoretically factor these numbers much faster. However, to break standard 128-bit encryption, about a thousand qubits are needed, translating to a million or more physical qubits. Currently, the best quantum computers have only 72 qubits, so it will be a while before quantum computers can threaten internet encryption. For now, your online data remains secure.
There’s uncertainty about whether quantum computing will work at scale. Some experts argue that noise presents a significant challenge, making it difficult to achieve a million qubits working together without interference. Despite this, human ingenuity has overcome similar challenges before, such as detecting gravitational waves despite noise issues. While quantum computing and gravitational wave detection are different, continued efforts are necessary to explore the potential of quantum computing.
The term “quantum supremacy” is often misunderstood. It refers to the point when a quantum computer can perform a specific task better than the best classical supercomputers. Currently, classical computers can perform all tasks that quantum computers can, and more. A more accurate term might be “quantum advantage,” as quantum computers are not yet superior in all aspects.
Quantum computing holds exciting potential, especially in areas like quantum simulation, which is challenging for classical computers. Quantum computers could excel in simulating materials and understanding their properties, as well as in chemistry, where they could revolutionize the simulation of molecular interactions.
Thank you for engaging with this topic. If you’re interested in further exploring math and science through problem-solving, consider checking out Brilliant.org, a platform offering courses in physics, mathematics, and computer science. They provide engaging weekly challenges that are both educational and enjoyable.
Engage in a hands-on simulation of qubits using a quantum computing simulator. Explore how qubits can exist in multiple states and observe the collapse of these states upon measurement. This will help you understand the difference between quantum superposition and classical parallelism.
Participate in a debate where you argue the challenges of equating logical and physical qubits. Research the impact of noise on quantum algorithms and discuss strategies for improving qubit quality. This will deepen your understanding of the practical challenges in quantum computing.
Attend a workshop focused on quantum error correction techniques. Work in groups to simulate how multiple physical qubits can be used to create a single logical qubit. This activity will enhance your comprehension of the qubit requirements for effective quantum error correction.
Analyze the potential impact of quantum computing on internet encryption. Use case studies to evaluate how Shor’s algorithm could affect current encryption methods and discuss the timeline for when quantum computers might realistically pose a threat.
Study a real-world example of quantum supremacy, such as Google’s quantum supremacy experiment. Discuss the implications of this achievement and explore the concept of quantum advantage. This will help you grasp the current capabilities and future potential of quantum computing.
Here’s a sanitized version of the provided YouTube transcript:
—
Quantum computing is receiving a lot of attention in the media these days, which I think is fantastic. However, I’ve noticed some inaccuracies in the coverage. Quantum computing is quite complex, and I believe there’s room for more nuance. Here are my top five clarifications about quantum computing.
A standard description of quantum computing typically goes something like this: quantum computers are made of qubits, which can exist in a state of 0 and 1 simultaneously. All of the qubits are entangled, so they are treated as a single object that can be in many different states at once. Therefore, a quantum computer is often likened to an infinitely parallel computer. However, this description is not entirely accurate.
While it’s true that qubits can exist in multiple states before measurement, once you measure them, you only obtain one state. Parallel computing involves breaking down large problems into smaller chunks that can be solved independently on different processors, which are then recombined. The architecture of parallel computers is quite different from that of quantum computers. In a parallel computer, you have many independent processes running simultaneously, and you can read the states of any of those processes at any time.
Next, consider this scenario: someone claims to have developed a quantum algorithm that requires a hundred qubits to run, and another person says they have built a quantum computer with a hundred qubits. A typical person might think that the algorithm can simply be run on that machine, but this is often not the case. The two parties are usually referring to different types of qubits. The algorithm refers to an ideal theoretical qubit, known as a logical qubit, while the quantum computer refers to real physical devices, which could be based on atoms or photons. These physical qubits are subject to noise, which can disrupt quantum algorithms and destroy quantum states. Therefore, the quality of qubits is crucial for the performance of a quantum computer.
Theoretically, there is a method to mitigate noise in qubits using quantum error correction, which involves using multiple physical qubits to simulate one logical qubit. The number of physical qubits needed depends on the quality of those physical qubits; higher quality means fewer qubits are required. Estimates suggest that it could take anywhere from 10,000 to 100 physical qubits to simulate one logical qubit.
Moving on to internet encryption: much of it relies on the difficulty of factoring large numbers using classical computers. Shor’s algorithm is a quantum algorithm that can theoretically factor these large numbers exponentially faster than the best classical algorithms. However, for standard 128-bit encryption, you would need about a thousand qubits for Shor’s algorithm to run, which translates to needing a million or more physical qubits. Currently, the best quantum computer has 72 qubits, so it will be a long time before we reach that million-qubit mark. For now, your internet secrets are safe.
Another important point is that no one can say for certain whether quantum computing will ever work at scale. Some experts argue that noise is such a significant challenge that achieving a million qubits working together without interference may be impossible. While this is a valid concern, I remain optimistic about human ingenuity. For instance, many believed we would never detect gravitational waves due to noise issues, yet the LIGO team achieved this remarkable feat. Although quantum computing and gravitational wave detection are not directly comparable, the only way to find out if we can achieve quantum computing at scale is to keep trying.
Finally, I want to address the term “quantum supremacy.” I believe it’s a misleading name because it doesn’t accurately describe what it refers to. I’ve discussed this topic in detail in another video, but essentially, quantum supremacy is the moment when a quantum computer can perform a specific task better than the best classical supercomputers. Currently, classical computers can perform all tasks that quantum computers can, and more. The term “quantum supremacy” suggests that a quantum computer can do everything a classical computer can do and more, which is not the case. It should be referred to as a “quantum advantage” or something similar.
I hope this clarifies some misconceptions and provides a more nuanced understanding of what quantum computers can and cannot do. Personally, I am excited about the future of quantum computing, especially its potential applications in quantum simulation. This area is particularly challenging for classical computers, but quantum computers could excel at simulating materials and understanding their properties, such as strength and durability. In chemistry, simulating molecular interactions, such as how a drug molecule interacts with various biomolecules in the body, could be groundbreaking.
Thank you for watching, and I appreciate the support from the sponsor of this video, Brilliant.org. They offer a platform where you can engage with math and science through problem-solving that feels like puzzles. They provide a range of courses in physics, mathematics, and computer science, and I enjoy their weekly challenges. If that sounds interesting, check out Brilliant.org. I’ve included a link in the description below. Thanks again, and I’ll see you in the next video!
—
This version maintains the key points while removing any informal language and ensuring clarity.
Quantum – Quantum refers to the smallest possible discrete unit of any physical property, often used in the context of quantum mechanics, which studies the behavior of matter and energy at the atomic and subatomic levels. – In quantum physics, particles can exist in multiple states at once, a phenomenon known as superposition.
Computing – Computing is the process of utilizing computer technology to complete a given goal-oriented task, involving both hardware and software systems. – Quantum computing leverages the principles of quantum mechanics to process information in ways that classical computers cannot.
Qubits – Qubits are the basic units of information in quantum computing, analogous to bits in classical computing, but capable of representing 0, 1, or both simultaneously due to superposition. – The entanglement of qubits allows quantum computers to solve complex problems more efficiently than classical computers.
Algorithms – Algorithms are step-by-step procedures or formulas for solving problems, often used in computer science to perform calculations, data processing, and automated reasoning tasks. – Quantum algorithms, like Shor’s algorithm, can factor large numbers exponentially faster than the best-known classical algorithms.
Error – Error in computing refers to the difference between a computed, estimated, or measured value and the true, specified, or theoretically correct value. – Quantum error correction is essential for maintaining the integrity of information in quantum computing systems.
Encryption – Encryption is the process of converting information or data into a code, especially to prevent unauthorized access, often using complex algorithms. – Quantum encryption promises to provide secure communication channels that are theoretically immune to eavesdropping.
Classical – Classical, in the context of physics and computing, refers to systems that follow the laws of classical mechanics or traditional computing models, as opposed to quantum systems. – Classical computers use bits as the smallest unit of data, whereas quantum computers use qubits.
Simulation – Simulation is the imitation of the operation of a real-world process or system over time, often used in scientific research to model complex systems. – Quantum simulation can provide insights into molecular and material properties that are difficult to study experimentally.
Noise – Noise in quantum computing refers to any unwanted disturbances that affect the quantum states of qubits, leading to errors in computation. – Reducing noise is crucial for improving the accuracy and reliability of quantum computations.
Supremacy – Quantum supremacy is the point at which a quantum computer can perform a calculation that is infeasible for any classical computer to achieve in a reasonable amount of time. – Google’s demonstration of quantum supremacy marked a significant milestone in the field of quantum computing.
