Did you know that ketchup and mustard have been around for thousands of years and have fascinating histories? Let’s dive into the stories of these two popular condiments and learn how they became the perfect partners for hot dogs and hamburgers!
Mustard has been part of human history for a very long time. It might even be one of the first crops ever grown by people! The mustard plant first appeared in China about 6,800 years ago. When we talk about mustard, we’re referring to the plant and its seeds, not the yellow sauce you put on your sandwich.
The seeds from the mustard plant were used as spices and in medicine long before they became a condiment. Ancient texts from India and Sumeria, dating back to around 2000 BCE, mention mustard seeds. About 2,500 years ago, the Greeks and Romans started mixing ground mustard seeds with grape juice to create a paste. This was the early version of mustard as we know it today.
Mustard seeds contain special compounds that give mustard its spicy kick and have health benefits. The Greeks and Romans believed mustard could help with many health issues, and even the famous doctor Hippocrates praised it for its ability to relieve pain.
The first recorded recipe for mustard as a condiment was written by a Roman named Lucius Junius Moderatus Columella in the first century CE. His recipe used ground mustard seeds and an acid, similar to how mustard is made today.
Ketchup’s story begins in China around 300 BCE. The word “ketchup” comes from a Chinese dialect and originally referred to a fish sauce made by fermenting fish, soybeans, and other ingredients. This sauce was quite different from the tomato-based ketchup we use today.
Fermentation is a process that breaks down food without oxygen, creating interesting byproducts like ethanol (used in beer and wine) and monosodium glutamate (MSG), which enhances flavor. The original ketchup was a salty, savory sauce that could be stored for long periods, making it perfect for long sea voyages.
As ketchup traveled the world, it changed. British traders discovered it in Southeast Asia and brought it back to England in the early 1700s. English recipes for ketchup included ingredients like anchovies, mushrooms, and even beer. Over time, ketchup became a term for any spiced sauce served with meals.
When the Romans brought mustard seeds to what is now France, the seeds thrived in the fertile soil. By the 9th century, French monasteries were producing mustard as a major source of income. French royalty loved mustard, and it became a staple in their diets.
Dijon mustard, a creamy variety, became famous in France. In 1634, it was declared that true French mustard could only be made in Dijon. The recipe was tweaked by Jean de Dijon, who used sour grape juice instead of vinegar, giving Dijon mustard its unique taste.
Mustard arrived in America with European settlers, but the bright yellow mustard we know today didn’t appear until 1904. At the World’s Fair in Chicago, the French’s company introduced their new yellow mustard, made with turmeric, and it quickly became a favorite hot dog topping.
Ketchup also made its way to America and evolved into the tomato-based version we love today. Despite their popularity, neither ketchup nor mustard is the top-selling condiment in the U.S. That title goes to ranch dressing!
In a previous episode, we explored whether dark roast coffee has more caffeine. The answer is a bit tricky. While roasting doesn’t significantly change caffeine levels, dark roast beans lose more water, making them less dense. So, a cup of dark roast coffee might have slightly more caffeine if measured by weight. However, many factors can affect caffeine content, so choose your coffee based on taste!
Now you know the rich history of ketchup and mustard, two condiments that have traveled the world and stood the test of time. Next time you enjoy a hot dog or hamburger, you’ll have a fun story to share!
Research the key historical events in the development of ketchup and mustard. Use this information to create a timeline poster. Include dates, locations, and interesting facts about how these condiments evolved over time. Share your timeline with the class and discuss the most surprising facts you discovered.
Bring in different types of mustard and ketchup, such as Dijon, yellow mustard, and tomato ketchup. Conduct a taste test with your classmates. Rate each condiment on flavor, texture, and spiciness. Discuss how the ingredients and preparation methods might affect the taste and popularity of each type.
Work in groups to create a short commercial promoting either ketchup or mustard. Highlight its historical significance and unique qualities. Use props, costumes, and creative storytelling to make your commercial engaging. Present your commercial to the class and vote on the most persuasive one.
Invent a new recipe that features ketchup or mustard as a key ingredient. Consider how these condiments can enhance the flavor of your dish. Write down the recipe and prepare a sample to share with the class. Explain why you chose certain ingredients and how they complement the condiment.
Divide the class into two teams, one representing ketchup and the other mustard. Research the health benefits, historical significance, and cultural impact of each condiment. Hold a debate to argue which condiment is superior. Use facts and persuasive language to support your position.
Here’s a sanitized version of the provided YouTube transcript:
—
Around 300 BCE, people in China were experimenting with making a pungent paste out of fermented fish guts. A few centuries later, the Greek historian Pliny shared a method to treat scorpion stings using the ground-up seeds of a common plant. These are the unlikely origin stories of ketchup and mustard.
Hi, I’m Justin Dad, and I’m Justin Dodd. Welcome to Food History, and a shout-out to Bradley Jones and the No Diet Diet Club for suggesting ketchup in condiments as topics. People in the United States spend over a billion dollars on ketchup and mustard each year, but neither item was invented here. So how did two condiments with thousands of years of history become associated with hot dogs and hamburgers?
Let’s start with mustard. It has been around for a while; in fact, it may have been among the first crops ever cultivated. Mustard first appears in the archaeological record in China around 6800 years ago. When I say mustard, I’m referring to the plant and its seeds, not the condiment that comes from them. There are multiple species of mustard plant, most being members of the Brassica family. Mustard is closely related to broccoli and cabbage.
The seeds harvested from the plant were used as a spice in medicine before they became a condiment. Indian and Sumerian texts from around 2000 BCE mentioned them in this context. The paste-like form of mustard showed up roughly 2500 years ago when the Greeks and Romans blended ground-up mustard seeds with unfermented grape juice to make a smooth mixture. The term mustard may come from the Latin for “hot must.”
The first version of this concoction wasn’t necessarily food; it may have been used more for its medicinal properties. Mustard seeds are rich in compounds called glucosinolates, which break down to produce isothiocyanates, powerful antioxidants that fight inflammation and give mustard its tingling kick. The Greeks and Romans applied mustard’s medicinal properties to almost every ailment imaginable. Hippocrates praised its ability to soothe aches and pains.
In the first century CE, Roman agriculture writer Lucius Junius Moderatus Columella published the first recorded recipe for mustard as a condiment, calling for an acid and ground mustard seeds—the same basic formula used to make mustard today.
Meanwhile, the evolution of another popular condiment was underway halfway across the world. Ketchup first appeared in China around 300 BCE. In the Amoy dialect of Chinese, ketchup means the brine of pickled fish. The name is pretty much the only thing that that version of ketchup had in common with the bottle of red stuff in your fridge. It was actually much more like garum, a Mediterranean fish sauce that was once widely popular in ancient Roman cuisine.
Modern versions of garum can still be found today in high-end restaurants. The Chinese fish sauce known as ketchup was likely made by fermenting ingredients like fish, soybeans, and meat byproducts. Fermentation is a pathway for breaking down carbohydrates when oxygen isn’t available. Both aerobic respiration and fermentation create adenosine triphosphate (ATP), which gives energy.
Fermentation creates byproducts that can be of great interest to humans. One such byproduct is ethanol, which gives us beer and wine through alcohol fermentation. Another is monosodium glutamate (MSG), which naturally occurs in many foods and can enhance flavor. The fish paste created by fermentation added a salty, savory depth of flavor to various dishes and could be stored on ships for months without spoiling.
As ketchup spread to different parts of the globe, it underwent transformations. Trade routes carried it to Indonesia and the Philippines, where British traders discovered and fell in love with the seasoning. Upon arriving in Great Britain in the early 1700s, Western cooks found ways to make it their own. One of the first English recipes for ketchup, published in Eliza Smith’s 1727 book “The Complete Housewife,” called for anchovies, shallots, cloves, and horseradish. Some recipes used oysters, while others omitted the fish entirely.
Popular bases for ketchup around this time included peaches, plums, celery seed, mushrooms, nuts, lemon, and beer. These sauces were often salty, flavorful, and had a long shelf life, but they varied greatly. The word ketchup evolved into a catch-all term for any spiced condiment served with a meal.
Mustard received its own makeover when it was imported to different parts of Europe. The Romans invaded what is now France in the 1st century BCE, and the mustard seeds they brought thrived in the region’s fertile soil. Locals, including monks in the French countryside, embraced the new condiment. By the 9th century, monasteries had turned mustard production into a major source of income.
Pope John XXII was said to be such a fan that he appointed a grand mustard maker to his court. French royalty also developed a taste for mustard; King Louis XI made it an essential part of his diet. There are many types of mustard—yellow, spicy brown, English, Chinese, and German—but to some, mustard is synonymous with the creamy Dijon variety that first took hold in France centuries ago.
In 1634, it was declared that true French mustard could only be made in Dijon. The recipe was an important part of French cuisine, but innovator Jean de Dijon tinkered with the formula, swapping traditional vinegar with the sour juice of unripe grapes. This change gave Dijon mustard its smooth taste and creamy texture. Most modern Dijon uses white wine or wine vinegar to imitate that original flavor.
Mustard also arrived in America shortly after the first European settlers. However, American yellow mustard didn’t appear until much later. At the World’s Fair in Chicago in 1904, the French’s company debuted its new cream salad mustard, which was made neon yellow by adding turmeric. They chose hot dogs as a canvas for the condiment, and French’s yellow mustard remains a classic hot dog topping more than a century later.
Ketchup and mustard have secured their positions as culinary heavyweights. Surprisingly, though, neither product is the top-selling condiment in the U.S.; that distinction belongs to ranch dressing, which is a billion-dollar industry.
In our last episode, we promised to answer a food or drink-related question from the comments. Vincent Shabbos Jr. asked whether dark roast coffee has more caffeine. The answer is a bit complicated. Caffeine is not significantly affected by the roasting process, but the beans themselves are. Dark roasted beans lose more water and become less dense, so a cup of dark roast coffee made with the same mass of coffee grinds might have a bit more caffeine. However, many variables are at play, so your best bet is to order coffee based on your preferred taste.
—
This version removes any inappropriate or unnecessary content while maintaining the essence of the original transcript.
History – The study of past events, particularly in human affairs. – The history of ancient Egypt includes the construction of the pyramids.
Mustard – A condiment made from the seeds of a mustard plant, used for flavoring food. – In ancient Rome, mustard was used to enhance the flavor of meats.
Ketchup – A sweet and tangy sauce typically made from tomatoes, vinegar, sugar, and spices. – Ketchup was first made in America in the 19th century and quickly became popular.
Ancient – Belonging to the very distant past and no longer in existence. – The ancient civilizations of Mesopotamia were among the first to develop writing systems.
Fermentation – A chemical process by which molecules such as glucose are broken down anaerobically. – Fermentation was used in ancient times to make bread and alcoholic beverages.
Spices – Aromatic or pungent plant substances used to flavor food. – Spices like cinnamon and pepper were highly valued in ancient trade routes.
Seeds – The unit of reproduction of a flowering plant, capable of developing into another such plant. – Farmers in ancient civilizations saved seeds from their best crops for planting the next season.
Europe – A continent located entirely in the Northern Hemisphere and mostly in the Eastern Hemisphere. – The Renaissance was a period of great cultural and scientific advancement in Europe.
America – A continent comprising the totality of North and South America. – The discovery of America by Europeans in 1492 led to significant historical changes.
Recipes – Instructions for preparing a particular dish, including a list of the ingredients required. – Ancient Roman recipes often included ingredients like honey and vinegar.
