Have you ever noticed how ice floats or why cans and jars might bulge or even explode in the freezer? This happens because when water freezes, it expands. But what if we compress water instead? Interestingly, when water is compressed, it melts. However, it takes a lot of pressure to make this happen. For instance, an ice cube that’s 4 degrees Celsius below freezing can withstand about 500 times the atmospheric pressure before it starts to melt. But it will melt under such pressure!
So, what happens if you try to freeze water while it’s compressed? Imagine cooling water below 0 degrees Celsius inside a super-strong pressure vessel that can’t bulge or stretch. If the water is liquid, it should freeze below 0 degrees Celsius. But if it’s frozen, it expands, creating pressure, which should cause it to melt. This seems like a paradox, right? But it’s actually a fascinating concept explained by a phase diagram.
A phase diagram shows whether a substance is solid, liquid, or gas at different temperatures and pressures. For water, at normal atmospheric pressure, cooling it down turns it from a liquid to a solid. However, if you increase the pressure, solid water can turn back into a liquid, even at temperatures below freezing.
Now, if you don’t let the water expand when it freezes, only some of it can freeze because the expansion creates pressure. This pressure eventually becomes high enough to prevent any more liquid water from freezing at that temperature. On the phase diagram, this is represented by following the line between liquid and solid towards colder temperatures and higher pressures.
If you continue to cool the container, more bits of water can freeze and expand until the pressure again stops further freezing. The colder the container, the higher the percentage of ice and the pressure inside. Eventually, at very low temperatures and high pressures, the remaining liquid water can freeze into a different phase of ice, called ice III. Ice III contracts and becomes denser when it freezes, creating more space and allowing the entire container to freeze solid. This means some of the ice will be our normal ice (ice Ih), and some will be ice III.
So, there is no paradox after all. The phase of water can be more complex than just solid or liquid.
If you’re intrigued by these scientific concepts, you might be interested in exploring more with Brilliant. Brilliant is an interactive learning platform that offers courses in science and math, ranging from logic to computer science and even quantum mechanics. It’s designed for curious learners of all ages and skill levels. To dive deeper into these subjects, you can sign up at Brilliant.org/MinutePhysics. The first 200 people will get 20% off an annual Premium subscription, giving you full access to all of Brilliant’s courses and puzzles, with new content added monthly.
Conduct a simple experiment to observe the effects of pressure on ice. Use a heavy book or weight to apply pressure to an ice cube and observe any changes. Document your observations and relate them to the concepts of phase diagrams and pressure-induced melting.
Draw a phase diagram for water, marking the different states (solid, liquid, gas) and the transitions between them at various pressures and temperatures. Use this diagram to explain how water behaves under different conditions, including the formation of ice III.
Investigate the different phases of ice beyond the common ice Ih. Prepare a presentation on ice III and other exotic ice phases, explaining their properties, how they form, and their significance in scientific research.
Use simulation software to model the behavior of water under varying pressures and temperatures. Analyze the results to understand how pressure affects the freezing and melting points of water. Share your findings with the class.
Engage in a classroom debate about the paradox of freezing water under pressure. Use evidence from phase diagrams and scientific principles to argue whether or not it is truly a paradox. Reflect on how scientific understanding can resolve apparent contradictions.
Water – A transparent, odorless, tasteless liquid that is a compound of hydrogen and oxygen, essential for most plant and animal life and the most widely used solvent. – Water is a crucial component in the study of thermodynamics due to its unique properties, such as high specific heat capacity.
Pressure – The force exerted per unit area on the surface of an object, often measured in Pascals (Pa). – In physics, pressure is a key factor in understanding how gases behave under different conditions, as described by the ideal gas law.
Freezing – The process through which a liquid turns into a solid when its temperature is lowered below its freezing point. – When water undergoes freezing, it expands and forms ice, which is less dense than liquid water.
Ice – The solid form of water, produced by freezing, that is less dense than its liquid form. – Ice floats on water because its crystalline structure occupies more space, making it less dense than liquid water.
Phase – A distinct state of matter characterized by homogeneous physical properties, such as solid, liquid, or gas. – The phase of a substance can change when energy is added or removed, such as when ice melts into water.
Diagram – A graphical representation that illustrates relationships between different variables or concepts, often used in scientific contexts. – A phase diagram is used to show the conditions of temperature and pressure under which a substance exists in different phases.
Liquid – A state of matter characterized by a definite volume but no fixed shape, allowing it to flow and conform to the shape of its container. – In a liquid state, molecules are closely packed but can move past one another, which allows liquids to flow.
Solid – A state of matter characterized by structural rigidity and resistance to changes in shape or volume. – Solids have a fixed shape and volume due to the closely packed arrangement of their particles.
Temperature – A measure of the average kinetic energy of the particles in a substance, often measured in degrees Celsius or Kelvin. – Temperature is a fundamental concept in thermodynamics, affecting the state and behavior of matter.
Compress – To reduce in volume by applying pressure, often resulting in an increase in density. – Gases can be compressed more easily than liquids or solids due to the greater distance between their molecules.
