Welcome to an intriguing exploration of history’s infamous figures! Today, we’re diving into the life of Harry Thaw, a man whose actions captivated the nation in what was dubbed the “trial of the century.” This story is based on an original article by Ru Alexander and was featured in a Biographics episode hosted by K.L. Smallwood.
The phrase “trial of the century” has often been used to describe sensational court cases that capture public attention. One of the earliest and most shocking instances was the 1906 murder of the celebrated architect Stanford White by Harry Thaw. This case was not just about a crime; it was a scandal involving wealth, power, and a dramatic love triangle.
Harry Kendall Thaw was born on February 12, 1871, in Allegheny City, Pennsylvania. He was the son of William Thaw Sr., a railroad magnate, making Harry one of the wealthiest young men in America. Despite his privileged upbringing, Harry exhibited troubling behavior from a young age, including paranoia and violent outbursts. His family’s wealth often shielded him from the consequences of his actions.
Harry’s education was marked by frequent expulsions from prestigious schools, but his father’s influence ensured he was admitted to the University of Pittsburgh to study law. However, Harry had little interest in academics and eventually transferred to Harvard, only to be expelled after a reckless incident involving a shotgun.
With his father’s passing in 1889, Harry inherited a vast fortune, allowing him to live a life of excess. He became known for his extravagant parties and frequent travels between Allegheny, New York City, and Europe.
At the heart of this story is a complex love triangle involving Harry Thaw, Evelyn Nesbit, and Stanford White. Evelyn Nesbit, born on December 25, 1884, was a renowned model whose beauty captivated many. After moving to New York City in 1900, she became one of the most sought-after models of her time.
Stanford White, a prominent architect, was significantly older than Evelyn and became infatuated with her. Their relationship began when Evelyn was just 16, marked by manipulation and exploitation. Despite the troubling dynamics, their relationship lasted about a year.
During this period, Evelyn met Harry Thaw, who was determined to win her over. Their relationship was tumultuous, with Thaw obsessed with avenging Evelyn’s honor against White. Eventually, Evelyn agreed to marry Thaw in 1905.
On June 25, 1906, during a performance at Madison Square Garden, Harry Thaw shot and killed Stanford White, claiming it was to protect his wife’s honor. The murder shocked the nation and led to a highly publicized trial in 1907.
Thaw’s defense argued that he was temporarily insane at the time of the murder. After a lengthy legal battle, he was found not guilty by reason of insanity and was committed to a mental institution. Despite his release, Thaw’s life continued to be marked by violence and legal troubles until his death on February 12, 1947.
Following her tumultuous marriage, Evelyn Nesbit returned to the stage and built a steady career in theater. She lived a long life, passing away on January 17, 1967, at the age of 82.
Thank you for joining us on this journey through history. We hope you found this story as fascinating as we did. If you enjoyed this exploration, feel free to share your thoughts and feedback. Stay curious and keep exploring the intriguing stories of the past!
Research another historical trial that was dubbed the “trial of the century” and prepare a presentation comparing it to Harry Thaw’s trial. Focus on the societal impact, media coverage, and legal outcomes. Present your findings to the class, highlighting similarities and differences.
Engage in a role-playing debate where you take on the roles of key figures in the Harry Thaw case, such as Harry Thaw, Evelyn Nesbit, Stanford White, and the legal teams. Debate the motives, actions, and ethical considerations involved in the case. This will help you understand the perspectives and motivations of each individual.
Participate in a workshop where you analyze the psychological aspects of Harry Thaw’s behavior. Discuss the potential mental health issues he may have faced and how they were addressed during the trial. Consider modern psychological theories and how they might apply to this historical case.
Write a short story or script that explores an alternate ending to the Harry Thaw case. Consider how different decisions or societal attitudes might have changed the outcome. Share your creative work with the class and discuss the implications of your alternate ending.
Watch a documentary or biographical film about the Harry Thaw case or a similar historical event. Analyze the film’s portrayal of the events, characters, and historical accuracy. Write a review or reflection on how the film contributes to your understanding of the case and its impact on society.
Here’s a sanitized version of the provided YouTube transcript:
—
Hello and welcome to another episode of Biographics! I’m your interim host, K.L. Smallwood. Yes, that’s my real name—feel free to look it up on social media; the links are below if you don’t believe me. Today, we’re talking about Harry Thaw, the original killer playboy. This video is based on an original article by Ru Alexander. If they provided any social links for us, you can find them below alongside my own.
Let’s get into it. The phrase “trial of the century” is a short and snappy phrase that grabs people’s attention. That’s probably why the press has relied on it whenever dealing with a high-profile court case, to drum up as much interest as possible for a juicy story. Even we here at Biographics haven’t shied away from using that old adage when describing some of the stories we’ve covered, such as the trial of Roscoe “Fatty” Arbuckle for the murder of Virginia Rappe or the trial of Dr. Sam Shepard, who stood accused of killing his wife. Those videos were presented by our previous host, Simon Whistler, who we wish all the best. Hopefully, I’m doing well in his stead.
But today, we’re going back even further. It’s one of the first cases to ever earn the moniker of “trial of the century,” and to this day, it remains one of the most intriguing and shocking: the 1906 murder of renowned American architect Stanford White at the hands of the mentally unstable playboy Harry Thaw, ostensibly to protect the honor of his wife, famous supermodel Evelyn Nesbit.
What made this case so compelling? One contemporary reporter listed all the qualities of this murder scandal that gripped the nation: wealth, degeneracy, rich old men, delectable young chorus girls, and adolescent artists. This is the story of a love triangle that ended in murder, making front-page news all over the country as America waited to find out what fate would befall Harry Thaw, the killer playboy.
Harry Kendall Thaw was born February 12, 1871, in Allegheny City, Pennsylvania, to William Thaw Sr. and his second wife, Mary Copley. To say that Harry was born with a silver spoon in his mouth would be an understatement; his father was a railroad magnate estimated to be among the 100 richest people in America at the time. Unsurprisingly, young Harry lacked nothing in his life, even though he exhibited paranoid behavior and was prone to outbursts of violence from a young age. At no point did anyone really try to correct his conduct or get him professional help, likely due to his family’s wealth and status.
If Harry got into trouble at school and was expelled, his father would simply move him to another fancy private school. From a young age, Harry was taught that his money and social status placed him above the rules of society. He never really did well in school, but this didn’t matter when it was time for college. His father ensured he got accepted into the University of Pittsburgh to study law, although there was little studying to be had. In 1889, William Thaw died, leaving behind a giant trust fund for Harry and a generous yearly allowance—more money than most could spend in several lifetimes. Harry Thaw was now very wealthy and free to indulge in his every whim.
After his father’s passing, Harry transferred to Harvard, primarily for bragging rights, as he had no real interest in scholarly pursuits. He was expelled after an incident involving a shotgun, and he soon remembered he was a millionaire and could do whatever he wanted. After finishing his “education,” he spent his time between Allegheny and New York City, with frequent trips to Europe, where he developed a reputation for his lavish parties.
Harry Thaw might be the focus of this story, but he was only one part of a lethal love triangle. The other two key figures were Evelyn Nesbit and Stanford White.
Evelyn Nesbit was born on Christmas Day in 1884 in a small community outside of Pittsburgh. After her father’s passing, she began modeling at a young age and quickly gained fame for her beauty. In 1900, she and her mother moved to New York City, where Evelyn became one of the most sought-after models of her time.
Stanford White, a prominent architect, was 30 years older than Evelyn and became infatuated with her. Their relationship began when Evelyn was just 16, and it was marked by manipulation and exploitation. White’s influence over her was significant, and despite the troubling nature of their relationship, it continued for about a year.
During this time, Evelyn met Harry Thaw, who was determined to win her over. Their relationship was complicated by Thaw’s obsession with avenging her honor against White. After a tumultuous courtship, Evelyn agreed to marry Thaw in 1905.
The couple moved to Pittsburgh, but Thaw’s violent tendencies soon resurfaced. On June 25, 1906, during a performance at Madison Square Garden, Thaw shot and killed Stanford White in a fit of rage, claiming it was to avenge his wife’s honor.
Thaw was arrested and charged with first-degree murder. His trial, which began in 1907, garnered significant media attention. The defense argued that Thaw was temporarily insane, and after a lengthy legal battle, he was found not guilty by reason of insanity.
Following his release, Thaw divorced Evelyn and continued to live a life marked by violence and instability. He faced legal troubles throughout his life, including charges of assault and subsequent commitments to mental institutions. Thaw died on February 12, 1947, at the age of 76.
Evelyn Nesbit, after her tumultuous marriage, returned to the stage and found a steady career in theater. She passed away on January 17, 1967, at the age of 82.
Thank you for tuning into this episode of Biographics. As mentioned at the start, I’ve been your interim host, K.L. Smallwood. You can find links to my socials below, along with links to the original article and our sister channels. We appreciate everyone for watching this video. If you liked it, please leave a like and a comment. I welcome any feedback on my hosting style as I strive to fit in with the Biographics brand. Subscribe if you haven’t already, and as always, have a great day!
—
This version removes inappropriate language and sensitive content while maintaining the essence of the original transcript.
History – The study of past events, particularly in human affairs. – The professor emphasized the importance of understanding history to avoid repeating past mistakes.
Sociology – The study of the development, structure, and functioning of human society. – Sociology provides insights into how social institutions influence individual behavior and societal trends.
Trial – A formal examination of evidence in a court, typically with a judge, to decide guilt in a case of criminal or civil proceedings. – The trial of the century captivated the nation, as it involved high-profile figures and complex legal arguments.
Murder – The unlawful premeditated killing of one human being by another. – The historian analyzed how the murder of the archduke acted as a catalyst for the onset of World War I.
Scandal – An action or event regarded as morally or legally wrong and causing general public outrage. – The political scandal of the 1970s led to widespread distrust in government institutions.
Wealth – An abundance of valuable possessions or money. – The sociology course examined how wealth disparity contributes to social inequality.
Power – The ability or capacity to do something or act in a particular way, often to influence others. – The rise of industrial power in the 19th century reshaped global economic and political landscapes.
Love – An intense feeling of deep affection, often examined in historical and sociological contexts regarding its impact on human relationships. – The letters exchanged between the historical figures revealed a love that defied societal norms of their time.
Violence – Behavior involving physical force intended to hurt, damage, or kill someone or something. – The sociology lecture explored how systemic violence can perpetuate cycles of poverty and oppression.
Insanity – The state of being seriously mentally ill; madness, often discussed in historical contexts regarding its treatment and perception. – The treatment of individuals deemed to have insanity in the 19th century reflects broader societal attitudes towards mental health.
