Dogs are amazing creatures, and if you’re like me, you probably love them too! There’s always a fun debate about whether purebred or mixed-breed dogs are better. This year is especially exciting for dog lovers because seven new dog breeds are being introduced at the Westminster Dog Show! While puppies are undeniably cute, there’s a lot of science behind why there are so many different breeds and whether that’s good for dogs as a species.
Did you know that domesticated dogs might have been around for as long as 40,000 years? Originally, they probably looked a lot like wolves. However, the hundreds of dog breeds we see today have only been around for a few hundred years. Humans have selectively bred dogs to have specific traits, like certain colors, markings, and body shapes.
To create a new dog breed, there are strict rules to follow. Organizations like the American Kennel Club require proof that all dogs used to develop the new breed are purebred. Breeders often need to test their dogs’ DNA to ensure there’s enough genetic variation for the breed to be healthy.
Since 2003, scientists have been able to study the dog genome, thanks to research led by Ewen Kirkness at The Institute for Genome Research. They discovered that there’s more genetic variation between different breeds than within the same breed. For instance, a black Labrador and a golden Labrador are more genetically similar than a black Labrador and a bulldog. In fact, the genetic difference between breeds can be as high as 27.5%, while humans only have a genetic variation of about 5.4%.
When humans change dogs’ appearances, they are actually altering their genes. For example, a gene on chromosome 15 called insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF1) plays a big role in determining size. This gene is found in many small dog breeds, suggesting it’s been around for a long time. However, these changes have happened much faster than they would naturally.
Unfortunately, breeding dogs for specific looks can lead to health problems. For example, dogs with short snouts often have brains that are rotated backward, affecting their sense of smell. Another issue is Chiari malformation, which affects the skull and brain formation in small dogs bred to look “doll-like.” This can cause chronic pain, mobility issues, or even paralysis. Clare Rusbridge, a researcher, described it as “trying to fit a big foot into a small shoe,” which sounds quite uncomfortable.
These health concerns have led some breeders to push for stricter breeding regulations. Thankfully, responsible breeders use genetic science to maintain diversity, creating new breeds that are both healthy and happy.
Despite all the changes we’ve made, all dogs share a common ancestor that looked like a wolf. Over time, they evolved to become our best friends. So, when did this amazing transformation happen?
What’s your favorite dog breed? Personally, I love mixed breeds!
Choose a dog breed that interests you and research its history, characteristics, and any health concerns associated with it. Create a presentation to share your findings with the class. Be sure to include images and interesting facts!
Using colored beads to represent different genes, simulate the genetic variation between different dog breeds. Work in groups to create a visual representation of how genetic traits are passed down and how they differ between breeds.
Participate in a class debate on the pros and cons of purebred versus mixed-breed dogs. Research both sides of the argument and prepare to defend your position with evidence from the article and additional sources.
Imagine you are a dog breeder tasked with creating a new breed. Decide on the traits you want your breed to have and explain how you would ensure genetic diversity and health. Present your new breed to the class, including a drawing or digital image.
Attend a workshop where you will learn about the genetic factors that influence dog health. Participate in activities that demonstrate how genetic manipulation can affect a dog’s physical traits and health, and discuss ways to promote responsible breeding practices.
Sure! Here’s a sanitized version of the transcript:
—
I love dogs; I’ve always loved dogs. But there’s always the debate: purebred or mixed breed? It’s a great year to be a dog lover! Apparently, seven new dog breeds will be shown at the Westminster Dog Show! I don’t know about you, but dog shows give me mixed feelings. On a personal level, puppies are adorable, but the scientific part of me wants to know why there are so many different dog breeds and if that is good for the species.
Domesticated dogs might have been around for 40,000 years and all pretty much looked like wolves. However, the few hundred dog breeds we know and love today have only been around for a couple of hundred years at most. Humans have selectively bred dogs for temperament and physical traits, such as distinguishing markings, coat color, and other features like head and body shape.
To qualify as an official breed, a new dog breed must meet very specific requirements. Many organizations, like the American Kennel Club, demand proof that every dog used to create the new breed was a certified purebred. In many cases, breeders need to have their dogs’ DNA and genotype tested to show an acceptable DNA variation sample for the breed.
Since 2003, researchers have been able to see exactly what that genetic pool looks like, thanks to an effort led by Ewen Kirkness at The Institute for Genome Research, which sequenced the dog genome. They also studied the genomes of different breeds and found that the variation of genes was greater between dogs of different breeds than within the same breed. For example, a black Labrador and a golden Labrador will have less variation than a black Labrador and a bulldog. Interestingly, the variation can be as much as 27.5 percent between dogs of different breeds, even though they are essentially the same species. In comparison, humans only have a genetic variation of 5.4 percent.
When humans alter dogs’ shapes and colors, they are actually affecting their genes. For instance, size is largely controlled by one gene on chromosome 15 called insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF1), which influences body size in humans and mice. Its mutation can be found in many unrelated smaller breeds, suggesting it is ancient. Even though it’s a few thousand years old, this change has occurred faster than it would have naturally.
With all this genetic manipulation, some unexpected issues have arisen. Breeding for aesthetic purposes can lead to unintended consequences, such as health problems in certain breeds. For example, studies have shown that changes in a dog’s face can also affect their brain structure. In dogs with short snouts, their brains have rotated backward, and the smell region is located differently than in other breeds. These kinds of brain changes are common in various dog breeds.
Another study found that Chiari malformation in dogs alters their skull and brain formation. This physical defect occurs in many small dogs bred to look more “doll-like,” resulting in a larger forehead and changes in brain shape. It can lead to chronic conditions like headaches, mobility issues, or even paralysis. One of the lead authors of the study, Clare Rusbridge, described the condition as “trying to fit a big foot into a small shoe,” which sounds quite uncomfortable.
The physical defects caused by inbreeding are a significant concern, prompting some breeders to advocate for stricter regulations and practices. Fortunately, there are responsible breeders who use genetic science to ensure they maintain genetic diversity, resulting in new breeds that are both healthy and happy.
While we’ve bred dogs to be stronger, smaller, or even more docile, they all share a common ancestor that resembled wolves from thousands of years ago. At some point, dogs evolved to become man’s best friend. When did this transformation occur?
So, what’s your favorite dog breed? Mine’s a mixed breed.
—
This version maintains the original content’s essence while ensuring clarity and appropriateness.
Dogs – Domesticated mammals that are often kept as pets and are known for their loyalty and companionship. – Dogs have been used in scientific studies to understand animal behavior and genetics.
Breeds – Specific groups within a species that have distinct characteristics, often developed through selective breeding. – Different breeds of dogs can have unique traits, such as size and coat color, due to selective breeding.
Genetics – The study of heredity and the variation of inherited characteristics. – Genetics helps scientists understand how certain traits are passed from parents to offspring.
Evolution – The process by which different kinds of living organisms develop and diversify from earlier forms over generations. – The theory of evolution explains how species adapt to their environments over time.
Health – The state of being free from illness or injury, often studied in biology to understand how organisms function. – Scientists study the health of ecosystems to ensure that all species within them can thrive.
Traits – Characteristics or features of an organism that can be inherited or influenced by the environment. – Traits such as eye color and height are determined by an individual’s genetic makeup.
Variation – The differences in physical traits among individuals of the same species. – Genetic variation is important for the survival of a species as it allows for adaptation to changing environments.
Breeding – The process of mating and producing offspring, often used to enhance desirable traits in animals and plants. – Selective breeding in agriculture has led to crops that are more resistant to pests.
Species – A group of living organisms consisting of similar individuals capable of exchanging genes or interbreeding. – The classification of species helps biologists understand the diversity of life on Earth.
Science – The systematic study of the structure and behavior of the physical and natural world through observation and experiment. – Science allows us to explore and understand the complex processes that govern life on our planet.
