SpaceX’s Starship has undergone a remarkable transformation since its early prototypes. Initially, these prototypes appeared rough and unrefined, far from the sleek spacecraft we see today. This article explores how SpaceX evolved Starship’s design and manufacturing process, focusing on the crucial role of welding in achieving its current sophisticated appearance.
Starship’s journey began with a design intended to be made from carbon fiber, a strong and lightweight material. However, carbon fiber’s limitations at high temperatures led SpaceX to pivot to stainless steel. This decision was surprising, as stainless steel is heavier, but it offers superior heat resistance, allowing for a thinner heat shield. Additionally, stainless steel is significantly more cost-effective, priced at $3 per kilogram compared to carbon fiber’s $150 per kilogram.
Welding is a critical process in constructing Starship, involving the fusion of metal parts using intense heat. Initially, SpaceX faced challenges with welding due to the lack of a proper factory and experienced welders. The early prototypes used a method called flux-core welding, which, while effective in controlled environments, proved problematic in the open-air conditions SpaceX was working in.
The welds on the first prototypes were rough and prone to corrosion, leading to structural weaknesses. To address this, SpaceX began grinding down the welds to remove sharp edges and cracks, which could act as stress points under pressure. This process helped strengthen the welds and improve the overall integrity of the spacecraft.
SpaceX made significant improvements in welding techniques for subsequent prototypes. They transitioned to using thinner single sheets of stainless steel, reducing the amount of welding required. The company also switched from 301 to 304L stainless steel, which offers better corrosion resistance during welding.
To enhance precision, SpaceX adopted TIP-TIG welding, which provides more control over the welding arc and allows for deeper penetration into the metal. This technique results in thinner, more uniform welds and minimizes warping of the surrounding metal. Additionally, SpaceX invested in robotic welding machines, similar to those used in Tesla factories, to automate and refine the welding process further.
SpaceX has likely moved on to laser welding for many sections of Starship. Laser welding offers concentrated heat that penetrates deeper into the metal, allowing for single-pass welds. To ensure the welds are as strong as the surrounding metal, SpaceX employs a process called planishing. This involves hammering the welds to compress and harden them, matching the strength of the surrounding material and smoothing the welds’ finish.
While achieving a completely smooth, mirror-like finish on Starship is theoretically possible, it would require extensive polishing akin to the process used for the Bean sculpture in Chicago. Given the time and resources required, it’s unlikely SpaceX will pursue this level of finish. However, the advancements in welding and manufacturing have already resulted in a much more refined and robust spacecraft.
SpaceX’s commitment to innovation and rapid development is evident in Starship’s evolution. The company’s ability to adapt and improve its processes has been key to overcoming the challenges of building a spacecraft capable of withstanding the rigors of space travel.
SpaceX’s journey with Starship is a testament to the power of innovation and adaptation. By mastering advanced welding techniques and leveraging the benefits of stainless steel, SpaceX has created a spacecraft that is both functional and visually impressive. As the project continues to evolve, it will be exciting to see how SpaceX further refines Starship’s design and capabilities.
Participate in a hands-on workshop where you’ll explore different welding techniques used by SpaceX, such as flux-core, TIP-TIG, and laser welding. You’ll have the opportunity to practice these techniques on metal samples and understand their applications and limitations.
Attend a seminar focused on the properties of carbon fiber and stainless steel. Discuss the reasons behind SpaceX’s material choice for Starship, considering factors like heat resistance, cost, and weight. Engage in a debate on the potential future materials for spacecraft construction.
Work in teams to design a hypothetical factory layout for SpaceX that optimizes the welding process. Consider the integration of robotic welding machines and the flow of materials. Present your design and rationale to the class.
Analyze a case study on the evolution of Starship’s welding techniques. Identify the challenges SpaceX faced and the solutions they implemented. Discuss how these innovations could be applied to other industries or projects.
Engage in a virtual reality simulation that allows you to experience the welding process used in Starship’s construction. This immersive activity will help you understand the precision and skill required in advanced welding techniques.
Here’s a sanitized version of the provided YouTube transcript:
—
This video is supported by KiwiCo. If you’ve been following Starship from the very beginning, you will know that it didn’t always look this good. The first Starship prototypes appeared quite rough, not like something that could survive a journey into space. The Starships that SpaceX produces now look much more sophisticated, with smoother metalwork and less noticeable welds.
So how did Starship evolve from its initial appearance to its current form in just a few years? And will it ever look completely smooth and shiny like it does in the renders? To answer these questions, we need to explore why Starship looks the way it does, specifically why it’s big and shiny instead of white and thin like most rockets.
Starship wasn’t always intended to look like a 1940s sci-fi rocket. In fact, it was originally meant to be made from carbon fiber, and production had already begun in California. This seemed like the most logical plan since carbon fiber is extremely strong and SpaceX already had most of their workforce based in California. So it surprised everyone when a stainless steel Starship prototype appeared in a small village in Texas. Over time, people began to realize what a great decision this was.
Although carbon fiber is very strong, it starts to break down at around 200 degrees Celsius. Therefore, it would require a very thick heat shield to survive the 1600-degree temperatures during multiple reentries. While stainless steel is heavier, it can withstand much higher temperatures, allowing for a much thinner heat shield. Additionally, stainless steel is significantly cheaper than carbon fiber, costing just $3 per kg compared to $150.
However, this wasn’t the first stainless steel rocket to be made. Back in the 1960s, NASA created an Atlas rocket from incredibly thin stainless steel. This was so thin that unless the rocket was constantly pressurized, gravity alone would crush it—and it did!
Even if SpaceX had chosen carbon fiber, it’s hard to envision how Starship would have been manufactured. To create carbon composites, the fibers must be layered in a specific way to ensure strength in every direction. Then, the composites need to be cured in a large pressure oven. For Starship’s 9-meter-wide sections, SpaceX would have needed an oven larger than anything that currently exists.
This is where stainless steel excelled. It could be assembled quickly using basic and affordable methods. Thus, SpaceX began working on the world’s shiniest rocket. However, one of the biggest challenges with the initial Starship prototypes was the welding. Initially, each ring was made from several sheets of 301 stainless steel, which were around 4.5mm thick. The original Starship crew was contracted from a water tower company and lacked experience in building rockets, resulting in welding standards that were not ideal.
Welding is the process of fusing two metals with a hot torch. The early Starship prototypes used a welding method called flux-core. In this method, a voltage is passed through a metallic wire, forming an arc that melts both the wire and the metal, filling any cracks or air bubbles. Flux-core welding is effective in controlled environments, but SpaceX faced challenges as they didn’t have a proper factory—just a large tent. Most of the welding was done outside by welders without rocket experience, which contributed to the initial poor appearance of Starship.
The welds on the first Mark 1 prototype were heavily corroded, with cracks and rough edges. To improve these welds, SpaceX began grinding them down until they were flush with the surface. Although this seemed like a poor attempt to restore shininess, it was actually done to strengthen the welds. Sharp edges and tiny cracks can act as pressure points that could lead to larger cracks once Starship is pressurized. Grinding the surface removed these defects and reduced the chance of weld failure.
In theory, each weld should be as strong as the surrounding metal. However, the initial Starship tests proved otherwise. Mark 1 exploded when one of the horizontal welds failed, sending the bulkhead flying. Consequently, SpaceX implemented significant improvements for the next Starship prototype. Each ring was now made from thinner single sheets of stainless steel, requiring much less welding. They also transitioned from 301 to 304L stainless steel, which is more resistant to corrosion during welding.
At this point, they upgraded to TIP-TIG welding, which provided more control over the welding arc, allowing for deeper welding into the metal. This produced thinner welds and minimized warping of the surrounding metal. SpaceX also began purchasing robotic welding machines from companies like Liburdi and Kuka, similar to those used in Tesla factories. With these upgrades, SpaceX automated a significant portion of the process, resulting in cleaner and more precise welds. They also started installing more stringers on the inside of Starship’s hull to prevent the metal from buckling under its own weight.
SpaceX didn’t stop there. They have likely moved on to laser welding for many of Starship’s sections. Laser welding allows for more concentrated heat that penetrates deeper into the metal, enabling the ring segments to be welded in a single pass. To further enhance the strength of each weld, another process is necessary. When Starship’s stainless steel is produced, it undergoes cold rolling, which compresses the metal and stretches the grains, making it stronger and harder. However, welding causes the metal in that area to soften. This is where SpaceX’s giant planishing machine comes into play. Planishing involves hammering the welds down and compressing them until they match the hardness of the surrounding metal, which also smooths the finish of the welds.
But will Starship ever have a completely smooth finish like a mirror? To answer this, we can look at the famous Bean sculpture in Chicago. Made from several stainless steel sheets, this structure underwent an 8-month polishing process involving a crew of 24 people using various grades of sanding grit. To achieve a similar finish on Starship, the entire body would need to go through this process to avoid visible lines around the welds, making it unlikely that SpaceX will pursue this.
Regardless, SpaceX is fully committed to Starship, and it’s impressive to see this project come together so quickly. Speaking of amazing projects, KiwiCo creates engaging hands-on projects designed to inspire kids in STEAM—science, technology, engineering, art, and math. Each monthly crate is designed by experts and tested by kids, featuring interesting projects like a walking robot that teaches engineering design through a series of cranks and gears powered by a motor.
KiwiCo offers nine different subscription options for various age groups and topics, providing hours of entertainment and learning each month. Each box includes all the supplies needed for that month’s project, eliminating the need for extra trips to the store. To support Primal Space and try out KiwiCo, visit kiwico.com/primalspace30 for 30% off your first month. If you’d like to support the channel further, consider becoming a Patron, where you can provide input on each video and gain exclusive access to our Discord server. Thank you for watching, and I’ll see you in the next video.
—
This version removes any informal language, maintains a professional tone, and ensures clarity while preserving the original content’s meaning.
Welding – The process of joining two materials, usually metals, by causing coalescence, often through the application of heat or pressure. – Example sentence: In the engineering workshop, students learned various welding techniques to join metal components effectively.
Stainless – A type of steel known for its resistance to corrosion and staining, typically containing chromium. – Example sentence: The laboratory equipment was made of stainless steel to ensure durability and resistance to chemical reactions.
Steel – An alloy of iron and carbon, and sometimes other elements, used extensively in construction and manufacturing for its strength and durability. – Example sentence: The new bridge design incorporated high-strength steel to withstand heavy loads and harsh weather conditions.
Prototypes – Early models or samples of a product built to test a concept or process, often used in engineering and design to evaluate feasibility. – Example sentence: The engineering team developed several prototypes of the new engine to test its efficiency and performance under different conditions.
Techniques – Methods or skills used to accomplish a specific task, often involving specialized knowledge or tools in engineering and physics. – Example sentence: Advanced computational techniques were employed to simulate the fluid dynamics in the aerospace project.
Manufacturing – The process of converting raw materials into finished products through the use of machinery, tools, and labor. – Example sentence: The course on manufacturing processes covered topics such as casting, machining, and additive manufacturing.
Metal – A class of elements characterized by high electrical and thermal conductivity, malleability, ductility, and a lustrous appearance, commonly used in engineering applications. – Example sentence: Understanding the properties of different metals is crucial for selecting the right material for engineering applications.
Design – The process of creating a plan or convention for the construction of an object or system, often involving problem-solving and creativity. – Example sentence: The students were tasked with the design of a sustainable energy system for their capstone project.
Challenges – Problems or obstacles that require innovative solutions, often encountered in engineering and scientific research. – Example sentence: One of the major challenges in the project was developing a cost-effective method for recycling composite materials.
Innovation – The introduction of new ideas, methods, or products, often leading to advancements in technology and engineering. – Example sentence: The innovation in battery technology has significantly improved the efficiency and range of electric vehicles.
