Countries are like sports teams; they have their mascots. Some are strong, some are cute, and some are just made-up. In the United States, we chose a special one. But America’s first big scientific challenge wasn’t about rockets or nuclear bombs; it was about a moose!
In the early days of America, understanding nature was crucial. People needed to know about the weather, how to find animals to hunt, and which plants were safe to eat. Across the ocean in Europe, science was mostly for the rich and famous. One such celebrity was the Count of Buffon, a bit like a modern-day science superstar.
Buffon wrote popular books about nature, but he had a negative view of America. He came up with the “Theory of American Degeneracy,” claiming that animals in America were smaller and weaker than those in Europe. He even suggested that animals brought to America would become less smart and less attractive. Buffon never visited America, but he described it as a cold and harsh place where people would lose their humanity.
This negative image was a problem for young America, which needed support from Europe. Thomas Jefferson, who was busy writing the Declaration of Independence and being the Governor of Virginia, decided to take on Buffon’s claims. Jefferson wrote a book to show that American animals were not smaller and that there was actually a greater variety of species in America.
One exciting discovery was the bones of a giant creature called “The Incognitum.” Jefferson thought these bones were from a mammoth, similar to ones found in Siberia. However, they were actually from a mastodon, a different prehistoric animal.
Buffon dismissed Jefferson’s claims, saying the “American Mammoth” was just a regular elephant and that the harsh American environment had caused its extinction. Jefferson, like many scientists of his time, didn’t believe in extinction and thought these giant creatures might still be out there.
Jefferson’s fossil findings didn’t convince Buffon, so he had another idea: to send a real-life example of American wildlife—a 7-foot-tall moose! While Jefferson was in France, his friend General John Sullivan worked hard to capture a moose. After three years, they finally succeeded, but they left the remains behind when sending it to France.
Jefferson was disappointed, but soon after, a crate with the moose arrived in Northern France. Jefferson sent it to Buffon, who, according to Jefferson, admitted his mistake and promised to update his theory. Sadly, Buffon passed away before he could do so.
Even though Jefferson’s moose mission didn’t directly change Buffon’s ideas, it helped shape America’s identity and pride. Writers like Washington Irving and Henry David Thoreau defended America and celebrated its nature. By the mid-1800s, the idea of American degeneracy had faded away.
Thomas Jefferson was not just a politician; he was a scientist who fought for America’s moose. His efforts contributed to the spirit of opportunity and pride that defines the nation. Stay curious, and if you want to learn more about this fascinating story, check out the book “Mr. Jefferson and the Giant Moose” by Lee Dugatkin.
Imagine you are Thomas Jefferson or the Count of Buffon. Prepare arguments to defend your position on the “Theory of American Degeneracy.” Work in pairs, with one student representing Jefferson and the other Buffon. Present your arguments to the class and engage in a friendly debate. This will help you understand the perspectives of both historical figures.
Choose an American animal that was part of Jefferson’s argument against Buffon. Research its characteristics, habitat, and significance in American history. Create a short presentation or poster to share your findings with the class. This will help you appreciate the diversity and uniqueness of American wildlife.
Write a letter as if you were Thomas Jefferson trying to convince Buffon of the richness of American wildlife. Use persuasive language and include facts about American animals. Share your letter with a classmate and discuss how effective your arguments are. This activity will enhance your persuasive writing skills.
Research the mastodon, the prehistoric animal Jefferson thought was a mammoth. Create a timeline of its existence and extinction, and compare it with other extinct animals. Present your timeline to the class. This will help you understand the concept of extinction and the history of prehistoric creatures.
Design a new mascot for America that represents its scientific achievements and natural diversity. Draw your mascot and write a short description explaining your choice. Share your design with the class and discuss how it reflects America’s identity. This creative activity will encourage you to think about national symbols and their meanings.
Here’s a sanitized version of the provided YouTube transcript:
—
Countries are like sports teams: they have their mascots. Some are powerful, some are adorable, and some are completely fictional. Here in the United States, we chose this one.
America’s first, and perhaps most significant scientific battle wasn’t the space race or the atom bomb; it was between Thomas Jefferson, a French nobleman, and a moose. In America’s early days, science and nature were integral to everyday life. Understanding the weather, finding game, and knowing which plants were poisonous were matters of life and death.
Meanwhile, across the Atlantic, science was largely the domain of the elite. The Count of Buffon was a celebrity, akin to a modern-day Carl Sagan. His natural history books were essential for anyone wanting to appear knowledgeable. However, Buffon had a negative view of the New World, which he expressed in his writings. He proposed a “Theory of American Degeneracy,” arguing that all of Earth’s mightiest species resided in the Old World. He claimed that animals common to both continents were smaller and weaker in America, and that domesticated animals would become less intelligent and less appealing when brought to the New World. Despite never visiting America, Buffon painted it as a cold and inhospitable place, suggesting that anyone who settled there would suffer a decline in their humanity.
This perception posed a challenge for young America, which needed support from Europe in the form of guns, goods, and people. The negative portrayal by one of Europe’s prominent thinkers was not helpful. Enter Thomas Jefferson. Amidst his many responsibilities, including writing the Declaration of Independence and serving as Governor of Virginia, Jefferson dedicated time to science. He responded to Buffon’s claims with his own book, demonstrating that American animals were not smaller and that the continent actually had a greater diversity of species.
One notable discovery was the remains of a giant creature referred to as “The Incognitum.” Jefferson had heard of similar bones from Siberia, known as the Mammoth. Although mammoths never lived in America, Jefferson mistakenly identified the bones he found as belonging to a mammoth, when they were actually from a mastodon.
Buffon dismissed Jefferson’s claims, asserting that the “American Mammoth” was merely a regular elephant and that the peculiar teeth belonged to a hippopotamus. He further claimed that the harsh conditions of the New World had led to the extinction of the American elephant. However, Jefferson, like many scientists of his time, did not believe in extinction and thought that mastodons and giant sloths might still exist in the West.
Jefferson’s fossil endeavors did not yield the results he hoped for, but he had one more idea: to present a living example of America’s wildlife, specifically a 7-foot-tall moose. While Jefferson was in France, his friend General John Sullivan took on the task of procuring a moose. After three years, Sullivan and his men successfully captured a moose, but unfortunately, they left the remains behind when shipping it to France.
When Jefferson learned of this, he felt disheartened. However, just two days later, a crate containing the moose was delivered to him in Northern France. Jefferson promptly sent the remains to Buffon’s estate. According to Jefferson, when Buffon examined the moose bones, he recognized his error and promised to correct his theory in the next edition of his Natural History. Unfortunately, there would be no next edition, as Buffon passed away shortly thereafter.
Despite this, American artists defended their nation. Washington Irving criticized Buffon’s ideas in his writings, while Thoreau expressed his appreciation for nature in his essay “Walking.” By the mid-1800s, the notion of New World degeneracy had faded. Sadly, Thomas Jefferson also passed away. Although his quest for the moose did not directly defeat Buffon, it contributed to the development of an American identity, a sense of national pride, and the spirit of opportunity that characterizes the nation.
Thomas Jefferson: a politician who was also a scientist, fighting for America’s moose. Stay curious. If you want to learn more about this story, check out the book “Mr. Jefferson and the Giant Moose” by Lee Dugatkin. The link is in the description.
—
This version maintains the essence of the original transcript while removing any informal language or phrases that may be considered inappropriate.
America – A continent in the Western Hemisphere, consisting of North America and South America, known for its diverse cultures and history. – Christopher Columbus is often credited with discovering America in 1492, although indigenous peoples had been living there for thousands of years.
Science – The systematic study of the structure and behavior of the physical and natural world through observation and experiment. – In science class, we learned about the laws of motion and how they apply to everyday life.
Jefferson – Thomas Jefferson was the third President of the United States and the principal author of the Declaration of Independence. – Thomas Jefferson believed in the importance of education and founded the University of Virginia.
Buffon – Georges-Louis Leclerc, Comte de Buffon, was a French naturalist known for his comprehensive work on natural history. – Buffon’s theories on the age of the Earth challenged the traditional views of his time.
Nature – The natural world, including plants, animals, landscapes, and other features and products of the earth, as opposed to humans or human creations. – The beauty of nature is evident in the changing colors of the leaves during autumn.
Animals – Living organisms that feed on organic matter, typically having specialized sense organs and nervous systems and able to respond rapidly to stimuli. – Animals like the woolly mammoth once roamed the Earth but are now extinct.
Extinction – The state or process of a species, family, or larger group being or becoming extinct, meaning no longer existing. – The extinction of the dinosaurs is believed to have been caused by a massive asteroid impact.
Fossils – The remains or impression of a prehistoric organism preserved in petrified form or as a mold or cast in rock. – Fossils provide scientists with valuable information about life on Earth millions of years ago.
Moose – A large deer with palmate antlers and a growth of skin hanging from the neck, found in northern North America and Eurasia. – The moose is the largest member of the deer family and is known for its impressive antlers.
Identity – The characteristics, feelings, or beliefs that distinguish people or things from others. – The identity of a nation can be shaped by its history, culture, and values.
