How to understand power – Eric Liu

Alphabets Sounds Video

share us on:

The lesson “Understanding Power: Its Sources and Influence in Civic Life” explores the nature of power in democratic societies, emphasizing its role in shaping civic engagement and community decision-making. It identifies six sources of civic power—physical force, wealth, state action, social norms, ideas, and numbers—and outlines three fundamental laws of power: its dynamic nature, its fluidity, and its tendency to compound. Ultimately, the lesson encourages individuals to develop a literacy in power, advocating for a proactive approach to understanding and wielding power for the benefit of the community, while reflecting on the ethical implications of their pursuit of power.

Understanding Power: Its Sources and Influence in Civic Life

Every day, we navigate through systems of power crafted by others. But do we truly understand these systems? Do we recognize the significance of power in our lives? Power is a topic that often makes us uncomfortable, especially when discussing civic life and community living. In a democracy, power is meant to reside with the people. However, discussions about who truly holds power can seem unsavory or even sinister. Yet, power is neither inherently good nor evil; it simply exists, much like fire or physics. It dictates how governments function and who sets the rules. Understanding power is crucial to being effective, taken seriously, and not exploited.

The Essence of Power

Power is fundamentally the ability to influence others to act in a way you desire. This dynamic is present in all aspects of life, from family to work and relationships. Our focus here is on civic power, which involves guiding a community to make decisions and take actions that align with your goals.

Six Sources of Civic Power

There are six primary sources of civic power:

  • Physical Force: Control over means of force, such as police or military, represents power in its most primal form.
  • Wealth: Money enables the purchase of results and other forms of power.
  • State Action: Governmental power uses laws and bureaucracy to compel actions. In democracies, this power is granted by the people through elections, while in dictatorships, it stems from force.
  • Social Norms: These are the unwritten rules of what is considered acceptable behavior, influencing change in a softer, peer-to-peer manner.
  • Ideas: Concepts like individual liberties or racial equality can inspire significant change if they motivate enough people.
  • Numbers: A large group of people can exert power by expressing collective interests and asserting legitimacy, as seen in movements like the Arab Spring.

The Laws of Power

Power operates under three fundamental laws:

  1. Power is Never Static: It is always accumulating or decaying. If you are not actively engaging with power, you are being influenced by it.
  2. Power is Like Water: It flows through daily life, and politics involves directing this flow. Policymaking attempts to freeze and maintain a particular flow of power.
  3. Power Compounds: Power tends to generate more power, and similarly, powerlessness can lead to further powerlessness. The challenge is to prevent a concentration of power among a few individuals.

Becoming Powerful in Public Life

To become more powerful, think of it as developing literacy in power. Learn to “read” power by understanding who holds it and how it is structured in society. Analyze why things are the way they are and who benefits from maintaining the status quo. Study strategies used by others in similar situations, whether through direct confrontation or coalition-building.

To “write” power, first believe in your right to be an agent of change. Express yourself authentically, organize your ideas, and rally others. Practice building consensus and managing conflict. Like any skill, it requires practice, both locally and beyond. Set objectives, observe patterns, adapt, and repeat. This is the essence of citizenship.

The Purpose of Power

Ultimately, the question of why you seek power is crucial. Do you aim to benefit everyone or just yourself? Are your goals pro-social or anti-social? This is not merely a strategic question but one of character. Remember, power combined with character creates a great citizen, and you have the potential to be one.

  1. Reflect on your personal experiences: How have you encountered or observed the dynamics of power in your community or workplace? What insights did you gain from these experiences?
  2. Consider the six sources of civic power mentioned in the article. Which source do you believe is most influential in your community, and why?
  3. The article discusses the concept of power being neither good nor evil. How do you interpret this idea, and how does it apply to your understanding of power in civic life?
  4. Think about the three fundamental laws of power outlined in the article. Which law resonates most with you, and how have you seen it manifest in real-world situations?
  5. In what ways do you think you can develop your “power literacy” to become more effective in public life? What steps might you take to better understand and engage with power structures?
  6. Discuss the role of social norms as a source of power. How have you seen social norms influence behavior in your community, and what changes would you like to see?
  7. The article emphasizes the importance of character in wielding power. How do you define character in the context of power, and why is it important for effective citizenship?
  8. Reflect on your motivations for seeking power or influence. What are your personal goals, and how do they align with the idea of being a pro-social agent of change?
  1. Power Mapping Exercise

    Identify key figures and institutions in your community that hold power. Create a visual map showing the relationships between these entities and their sources of power (e.g., physical force, wealth, state action, social norms, ideas, numbers). Discuss how these power sources influence decisions and actions in your community.

  2. Debate on Power Sources

    Form teams and debate the effectiveness and ethical implications of different sources of civic power. For example, one team could argue that wealth is the most influential source of power, while another team could argue for the power of ideas. Use real-world examples to support your arguments.

  3. Role-Playing Scenarios

    Engage in role-playing activities where you simulate different civic situations. For instance, one scenario could involve negotiating a community project with local government officials. Each student takes on a role (e.g., community leader, government official, activist) and uses their understanding of power dynamics to achieve their goals.

  4. Case Study Analysis

    Analyze historical or contemporary case studies where power dynamics played a crucial role. Examples could include the Civil Rights Movement, the Arab Spring, or local community initiatives. Discuss how different sources of power were utilized and the outcomes of these actions.

  5. Power in Media Project

    Create a multimedia project (e.g., video, podcast, infographic) that explores how power is portrayed in media. Choose a specific topic, such as the representation of political power in news outlets or the influence of social norms in advertising. Present your findings to the class and discuss the implications.

PowerThe ability or capacity to influence or control the behavior of people or the course of events. – In a democracy, the power of the government is derived from the consent of the governed.

CivicRelating to the duties or activities of people in relation to their town, city, or local area. – Civic engagement is crucial for maintaining a healthy and functioning democracy.

CommunityA group of people living in the same place or having a particular characteristic in common. – The community came together to discuss the new policies affecting local schools.

InfluenceThe capacity to have an effect on the character, development, or behavior of someone or something. – Social media has a significant influence on public opinion and political campaigns.

DemocracyA system of government by the whole population, typically through elected representatives. – In a democracy, citizens have the right to vote and express their opinions freely.

NormsStandards or patterns of behavior that are typical or expected within a society or group. – Social norms often dictate what is considered acceptable behavior in a community.

IdeasThoughts or suggestions about what to do or how to solve a problem. – The exchange of ideas is essential for innovation and progress in society.

WealthAn abundance of valuable possessions or money. – The distribution of wealth in a society can greatly affect social equality and access to resources.

CitizenshipThe status of being a citizen, with associated rights and responsibilities. – Citizenship involves participating in civic duties such as voting and community service.

ChangeThe act or instance of making or becoming different. – Social movements often aim to bring about change in laws and societal norms.

All Video Lessons

Login your account

Please login your account to get started.

Don't have an account?

Register your account

Please sign up your account to get started.

Already have an account?