If matter falls down, does antimatter fall up? – Chloé Malbrunot

Alphabets Sounds Video

share us on:

In the lesson “If Matter Falls Down, Does Antimatter Fall Up?” by Chloé Malbrunot, two atoms—hydrogen and antihydrogen—engage in a conversation about their properties and the nature of gravity. They discuss the challenges of measuring gravitational effects on small particles and the mystery of why the universe contains more matter than antimatter, despite their expected equal creation during the Big Bang. The lesson emphasizes the importance of experiments at CERN in exploring these fundamental questions about the universe.

If Matter Falls Down, Does Antimatter Fall Up? – Chloé Malbrunot

Imagine two atoms having a chat. One is a regular hydrogen atom, and the other is its opposite, an antihydrogen atom. They are about to take a leap in an experiment at CERN, the famous research center in Switzerland. Let’s dive into their conversation and learn something cool about matter and antimatter!

The Meeting of Matter and Antimatter

“Hey, another atom. I’m hydrogen, nice to meet you. How are you feeling about the jump?” says the hydrogen atom.

“Hi there, I’m antihydrogen, your antiatom. To be honest, I’m feeling kind of neutral. My positron and antiproton balance out, just like your electron and proton, right?” replies the antihydrogen atom.

Hydrogen responds, “Hey, yeah! You look just like me, but different somehow.”

“Whoa, be careful! If we get too close, we’ll disappear in a spark of energy. I’d like to stay in one piece,” warns antihydrogen.

“Oh wow, sorry,” says hydrogen.

The Mystery of Falling

Antihydrogen continues, “It’s okay. I was just thinking, it’s kind of unusual for us to be chatting like this before our jump above CERN.”

“Why’s that?” asks hydrogen.

“Well, for starters, how do we know we’ll both fall?” wonders antihydrogen.

“Of course we’ll fall. It’s gravity, you know, the force of attraction between masses. I even know how fast we should fall. Galileo showed in that tower experiment that all falling objects accelerate at the same rate, regardless of mass,” explains hydrogen.

“That’s for bigger objects. It’s a different story for small particles like us. Our mass is so tiny that the gravitational force we experience is minuscule, and if the particles are charged, like my antiproton or your proton, then it becomes impossible to detect compared to the much greater electromagnetic force acting on them,” clarifies antihydrogen.

Neutral Particles and Gravity

“But that’s only for charged particles. You and I are both neutral. Our charges balance out, so the electromagnetic force is small and the gravitational force should be detectable. I know mine’s been measured,” says hydrogen.

“Because you’re everywhere, but I’m kind of hard to find,” replies antihydrogen.

“Why is that, anyway? Shouldn’t there have been an equal amount of matter and antimatter created in the Big Bang?” asks hydrogen.

“You’d think so, but then all of those particles would have annihilated each other into energy, remember? And the Universe is obviously full of matter. No one knows why there is more matter than antimatter, which is why scientists are so interested in studying me,” explains antihydrogen.

The Creation of Antimatter

“So where do they find you anyway?” asks hydrogen.

“Actually, I was made in that lab down there. They needed an accelerator to make my antiproton because it’s so heavy, just as heavy as your proton. Getting my positron was easier. It’s much lighter, like your electron, and there are materials that naturally decay by emitting one. Then they just had to put the two together and they got me. But it’s only recently that they’ve been able to keep me around long enough to study my properties,” shares antihydrogen.

The Big Experiment

“And now they’ve sent you on this jump with me. Hey, wait a minute,” says hydrogen.

“That’s right. We’re reenacting Galileo’s experiment, but with matter and antimatter instead of two objects made of matter,” explains antihydrogen.

“So what’s going to happen? Are you going to fall upwards or something?” asks hydrogen.

“Only one way to find out!” says antihydrogen.

This conversation highlights the intriguing world of antimatter and the mysteries scientists are trying to solve. By studying how antimatter behaves, especially in experiments like the one at CERN, researchers hope to uncover more secrets about the universe and why it is filled with more matter than antimatter.

  1. What are your thoughts on the idea of antimatter potentially falling upwards? How does this challenge your understanding of gravity?
  2. Reflect on the conversation between hydrogen and antihydrogen. What insights did you gain about the similarities and differences between matter and antimatter?
  3. How does the concept of matter and antimatter annihilating each other into energy influence your perspective on the universe’s composition?
  4. What questions do you have about the creation and existence of antimatter, based on the article’s discussion?
  5. Consider the significance of the experiment at CERN. What potential discoveries do you think could arise from studying the behavior of antimatter?
  6. How does the article’s explanation of gravitational and electromagnetic forces in small particles enhance your understanding of particle physics?
  7. Discuss the implications of the imbalance between matter and antimatter in the universe. What theories or ideas do you find most compelling?
  8. How does the article’s narrative style, using a conversation between atoms, affect your engagement and understanding of the scientific concepts presented?
  1. Role-Playing Dialogue

    Imagine you are either a hydrogen atom or an antihydrogen atom. Pair up with a classmate and recreate the conversation from the article. Add your own twist by including what you think might happen during the jump experiment. This will help you understand the differences and similarities between matter and antimatter.

  2. Gravity Experiment Simulation

    Conduct a simple experiment to simulate Galileo’s tower experiment. Use different objects to see how they fall at the same rate due to gravity. Discuss how this relates to the concept of matter and antimatter falling in the CERN experiment.

  3. Research Project on Antimatter

    Research and create a presentation on how antimatter is produced and studied at CERN. Include information about the challenges scientists face in creating and maintaining antihydrogen atoms. Share your findings with the class to deepen your understanding of antimatter research.

  4. Creative Writing: The Antimatter Universe

    Write a short story imagining a universe where antimatter is more prevalent than matter. Describe how this universe might differ from ours and what challenges or advantages it might present. This will help you explore the concept of matter-antimatter asymmetry.

  5. Debate: The Importance of Antimatter Research

    Participate in a class debate on the importance of antimatter research. One side will argue for the potential benefits and discoveries, while the other will discuss the challenges and costs. This activity will help you critically evaluate the significance of scientific research in understanding the universe.

Sure! Here’s a sanitized version of the transcript:

“Hey, another atom. I’m hydrogen, nice to meet you. How are you feeling about the jump?”

“Hi there, I’m antihydrogen, your antiatom, and to be honest, I’m feeling kind of neutral. My positron and antiproton balance out, just like your electron and proton, right?”

“Hey, yeah! You look just like me, but different somehow.”

“Whoa, be careful! If we get too close, we’ll disappear in a spark of energy. I’d like to stay in one piece.”

“Oh wow, sorry.”

“It’s okay. I was just thinking, it’s kind of unusual for us to be chatting like this before our jump above CERN.”

“Why’s that?”

“Well, for starters, how do we know we’ll both fall?”

“Of course we’ll fall. It’s gravity, you know, the force of attraction between masses. I even know how fast we should fall. Galileo showed in that tower experiment that all falling objects accelerate at the same rate, regardless of mass.”

“That’s for bigger objects. It’s a different story for small particles like us. Our mass is so tiny that the gravitational force we experience is minuscule, and if the particles are charged, like my antiproton or your proton, then it becomes impossible to detect compared to the much greater electromagnetic force acting on them.”

“But that’s only for charged particles. You and I are both neutral. Our charges balance out, so the electromagnetic force is small and the gravitational force should be detectable. I know mine’s been measured.”

“Because you’re everywhere, but I’m kind of hard to find.”

“Why is that, anyway? Shouldn’t there have been an equal amount of matter and antimatter created in the Big Bang?”

“You’d think so, but then all of those particles would have annihilated each other into energy, remember? And the Universe is obviously full of matter. No one knows why there is more matter than antimatter, which is why scientists are so interested in studying me.”

“So where do they find you anyway?”

“Actually, I was made in that lab down there. They needed an accelerator to make my antiproton because it’s so heavy, just as heavy as your proton. Getting my positron was easier. It’s much lighter, like your electron, and there are materials that naturally decay by emitting one. Then they just had to put the two together and they got me. But it’s only recently that they’ve been able to keep me around long enough to study my properties.”

“And now they’ve sent you on this jump with me. Hey, wait a minute.”

“That’s right. We’re reenacting Galileo’s experiment, but with matter and antimatter instead of two objects made of matter.”

“So what’s going to happen? Are you going to fall upwards or something?”

“Only one way to find out!”

Let me know if you need any further modifications!

MatterMatter is anything that has mass and takes up space. – Everything around us, including the air we breathe and the water we drink, is made up of matter.

AntimatterAntimatter is a type of matter composed of antiparticles, which have the same mass as particles of ordinary matter but opposite charges. – When matter and antimatter meet, they annihilate each other, releasing a burst of energy.

GravityGravity is the force that attracts two bodies toward each other, typically noticeable as the force that gives weight to objects with mass. – The gravity of the Earth keeps the Moon in orbit around it.

ParticlesParticles are small localized objects to which can be ascribed several physical or chemical properties such as volume or mass. – In physics, atoms are considered particles that make up all matter.

EnergyEnergy is the ability to do work or cause change, and it can exist in various forms such as kinetic, potential, thermal, and more. – The energy from the Sun is essential for life on Earth, providing light and warmth.

UniverseThe universe is the vast space that contains all of the matter and energy in existence, including galaxies, stars, and planets. – Scientists study the universe to understand its origins and the laws that govern it.

ExperimentAn experiment is a scientific procedure undertaken to test a hypothesis or demonstrate a known fact. – In the lab, we conducted an experiment to observe the effects of heat on different materials.

HydrogenHydrogen is the lightest and most abundant chemical element in the universe, consisting of one proton and one electron. – Stars, including our Sun, primarily consist of hydrogen, which fuels their energy through nuclear fusion.

ProtonA proton is a positively charged particle found in the nucleus of an atom. – The number of protons in an atom’s nucleus determines the element’s identity and its place on the periodic table.

ElectronAn electron is a negatively charged particle that orbits the nucleus of an atom. – Electrons play a crucial role in chemical reactions and electricity flow.

All Video Lessons

Login your account

Please login your account to get started.

Don't have an account?

Register your account

Please sign up your account to get started.

Already have an account?