Imagine you’re trying to get comfortable on the couch, but your dog is already there, looking cozy. You gently nudge him to move, thinking about how you’re the one who can plan and dream. But did your dog just outsmart you, or was he simply acting on instinct? What exactly is going on in his mind?
To figure this out, we need to understand what “thinking” means and how we measure it. Philosophers like Aristotle and Descartes had different views on this. Aristotle thought humans had reason, while animals only acted on basic instincts for survival. Descartes took it further, comparing animals to robots that mechanically respond to their environment.
However, this view started to change with Charles Darwin’s Theory of Evolution. Darwin suggested that intelligence could evolve from simple instincts. He noticed that earthworms made decisions about how to pull leaves into their burrows, similar to how humans solve problems. If humans evolved from simpler creatures, maybe our minds are just more advanced versions of theirs.
Recent studies have shown that many animals can solve complex problems, supporting Darwin’s ideas. For example, elephants use tools to reach things they can’t otherwise get to. Crows make their own tools and can use water to get rewards. Octopuses can open jars after watching others do it and remember how to do it months later. These tasks show that animals can think about problems and remember solutions for the future.
But how do we know if animals are truly thinking? Behaviorists like Pavlov and Thorndike believed animals were just reacting to rewards or punishments. Take Clever Hans, a horse that seemed to solve math problems but was actually picking up on his trainer’s subtle cues. While Hans couldn’t really count, he could understand social signals, a skill many animals share.
Elephants recognize each other even after years apart and seem to mourn their dead. Bees perform a special dance to show where food is. Chimpanzees use deception, suggesting they understand that others have thoughts too. Then there’s Alex the Grey Parrot, who could use human language to identify colors and shapes and understand concepts like “bigger” and “smaller.” This seems like intelligence, not just mindless behavior.
For humans, thinking also involves consciousness—the ability to reflect on our actions. But do animals have this kind of awareness? We don’t know if a dog feels proud of outsmarting us. What we really want to understand is what it’s like to be a dog, an octopus, or a crow. This is known as The Hard Problem in philosophy because we can’t truly know what it’s like to be another creature, even if they can communicate like Alex the Parrot.
What if consciousness exists in different forms? Would we even recognize the consciousness of bees? How can we be sure other people have consciousness and aren’t just functioning beings? These questions about animal minds challenge our understanding and might reveal more about our own minds than theirs.
Engage in a classroom debate about whether animals act purely on instinct or if they possess intelligence similar to humans. Research examples from the article, such as elephants using tools or crows making their own tools, to support your arguments. Consider the perspectives of philosophers like Aristotle, Descartes, and Darwin.
Visit a local zoo or watch live animal cams online. Choose an animal to observe and take notes on its behavior. Reflect on whether the actions you observe seem instinctual or if they suggest problem-solving abilities. Share your observations with the class and discuss how they relate to the concepts in the article.
Write a short story from the perspective of an animal discussed in the article, such as an octopus or a crow. Imagine what it might be like to experience the world through their senses and intelligence. Consider how they might solve problems or interact with their environment. Share your story with classmates and discuss the different perspectives.
If you have a pet, design a simple problem-solving experiment, such as hiding a treat under a cup. Observe how your pet attempts to solve the problem. Does it use trial and error, or does it seem to understand the task? Record your observations and compare them with the animal intelligence examples from the article.
Participate in a group discussion about “The Hard Problem” of consciousness mentioned in the article. Consider questions like: Can we ever truly understand what it’s like to be another creature? How do we define consciousness? Discuss how these questions challenge our understanding of both animal and human minds.
Here’s a sanitized version of the provided YouTube transcript:
—
Your dog loves to curl up on the couch, but so do you, so you gently encourage him to move and settle in for a cozy evening. After all, you’re the human here. You’re capable of planning and dreaming. But did your dog just outsmart you and feel happy about it? Or was he simply following his instincts? Is there even a difference? What is he thinking?
Well, it depends on what we mean by “thinking” and the criteria we use to evaluate it. Philosophers like Aristotle and Descartes used instinct and intelligence to differentiate between animals and humans. Aristotle believed that humans possess reason, while animals could only follow basic instincts for survival and reproduction. Centuries later, Descartes suggested a more extreme version of that idea, arguing that animals following instincts were similar to robots responding mechanically to their environments.
However, the consensus against animal intelligence began to change with Darwin’s Theory of Evolution. Darwin proposed that intelligence could evolve from simpler instincts. He observed earthworms making choices about how to drag oddly shaped leaves into their burrows and noted that humans might use similar strategies to solve problems. If humans are descended from simpler creatures, then perhaps our minds exist on a continuum, differing in degree but not in kind.
Recent experiments have shown that many species can solve complex problems, supporting Darwin’s hypothesis. Elephants use tools to reach inaccessible places. Crows create their own tools and can use water displacement to obtain rewards. Octopuses can open jars after observing others do so and can remember the process months later. Such tasks involve considering aspects of a problem separately from the immediate situation and retaining strategies for future use.
Still, while animals can solve complex problems, how do we know what, or even that, they are thinking? Behaviorists, such as Pavlov and Thorndike, argue that animals that appear to think are usually just responding to rewards or punishments. This was the case with Clever Hans, a horse that seemed to answer math problems but was actually reading his trainer’s subtle nonverbal cues. So, while Hans couldn’t count, does that mean he wasn’t thinking? He could interpret nuanced social messages, a quality shared by many non-human animals.
Elephants recognize each other after years apart and seem to mourn their dead. Bees communicate using a special waggle dance to indicate the location and quality of food sources. Chimpanzees engage in complex deception schemes, suggesting they not only think but also understand that others do too. Then there is Alex the Grey Parrot, who could use human language to distinguish colors and shapes of absent objects and understand abstract concepts like bigger and smaller. This sounds a lot like intelligence, not just the work of mindless machines.
However, for humans, thinking also involves consciousness—the ability to reflect on our actions, not simply to perform them. So far, our studies do not tell us if having the intelligence to outsmart us means that our dog can also feel good about doing so. What we really want to know is what it is like to be a dog, an octopus, or a crow. Philosophers of mind refer to this as The Hard Problem, because while we can describe what it feels like to be human, no one can speak for a horse. Even a talking parrot like Alex couldn’t tell us how he feels about the colors he can name.
What if consciousness comes in different forms? Would we even recognize the consciousness of bees? For that matter, how can we be sure that other people have consciousness? Perhaps they are just well-functioning beings. Regardless, animal minds continue to challenge our understanding, and how we frame them may reveal more about our minds than theirs.
—
This version maintains the essence of the original content while removing any potentially sensitive or inappropriate language.
Thinking – The process of using one’s mind to consider or reason about something. – In philosophy, thinking critically about ethical dilemmas helps us understand different moral perspectives.
Consciousness – The state of being aware of and able to think about one’s own existence, thoughts, and surroundings. – The nature of consciousness is a central question in both philosophy and psychology, as it relates to how we perceive reality.
Intelligence – The ability to acquire and apply knowledge and skills. – Philosophers often debate whether artificial intelligence can truly replicate human intelligence and understanding.
Instinct – An innate, typically fixed pattern of behavior in animals in response to certain stimuli. – While humans rely on rational thinking, many animals depend on instinct to survive in their natural environments.
Philosophy – The study of the fundamental nature of knowledge, reality, and existence, especially when considered as an academic discipline. – Philosophy encourages students to question the assumptions underlying their beliefs and the world around them.
Behavior – The way in which one acts or conducts oneself, especially towards others. – Understanding human behavior is crucial in psychology to address mental health issues and improve interpersonal relationships.
Evolution – The process by which different kinds of living organisms are thought to have developed and diversified from earlier forms during the history of the earth. – The theory of evolution has significant implications for understanding the development of human consciousness and behavior.
Awareness – Knowledge or perception of a situation or fact. – Increasing awareness of cognitive biases can help individuals make more rational decisions.
Problem-solving – The process of finding solutions to difficult or complex issues. – In psychology, problem-solving skills are essential for overcoming challenges and achieving personal goals.
Animals – Living organisms that feed on organic matter, typically having specialized sense organs and nervous systems and able to respond rapidly to stimuli. – Philosophers often explore the moral status of animals and whether they possess consciousness similar to humans.
