The mid-1500s in the British Isles were a period of chaos and change. Monarchs came and went, each with their own policies that often left the public frustrated. This unrest eventually led to the English Civil War a century later. During this time, religious tensions were high. Martin Luther’s challenge to Catholicism and King Henry VIII’s break from the Catholic Church set the stage for conflict. Henry’s daughter, Mary I, tried to bring England back to Catholicism, earning the nickname “Bloody Mary” for her violent methods. Her successor, Elizabeth I, reversed these changes, leading to further unrest.
In Scotland, King James V was known for his harsh treatment of Protestants. He used the Vatican’s fears about the Reformation to his advantage, while Henry VIII attempted to sway him away from the Papal State. Despite the Reformation’s benefits, it deepened the divide between Catholics and Protestants. The Pope wielded significant influence, even declaring rulers illegitimate, as happened to Elizabeth I in 1570. Amidst this divided populace, the nobility engaged in political intrigue and assassinations, constantly vying for power.
Mary’s father, King James V, died under mysterious circumstances, possibly from contaminated water. At just six days old, Mary became queen. Her troubles began when, at six months old, a treaty was signed for her to marry Henry VIII’s son. This angered Scottish Catholics, who took her to France. There, she was betrothed to the Dauphin Francis, and they married when she was 15. After Francis’s death, Mary returned to Scotland at 18 to claim her throne. Her Catholic faith made her a target of suspicion among Protestants, but she was known for her moderate leadership.
Mary’s personal life was as dramatic as her political one. She married her cousin, Lord Darnley, against Queen Elizabeth’s wishes. Their union sparked a rebellion, and Darnley’s ambition to rule as an equal led to conflict. After a series of betrayals and a suspicious explosion that killed Darnley, Mary was implicated in his murder. Her advisor, Lord Bothwell, was accused but acquitted. Bothwell then kidnapped and married Mary, a move that shocked the public and led to his exile. Mary was forced to abdicate in favor of her son, James, and imprisoned on an island.
Despite her imprisonment, Mary remained a political player. She was involved in numerous plots to reclaim her throne, including the Babington Plot, which aimed to assassinate Elizabeth and place Mary on the English throne. Her involvement was discovered, leading to her trial and execution. Elizabeth hesitated to execute Mary, fearing the precedent it would set, but eventually signed the death warrant. Mary faced her execution with dignity, dressed in the colors of a martyr, and forgave her executioner before her death.
Mary’s life was marked by ambition, intrigue, and tragedy. She was a fashion icon and a symbol of Catholic resistance. Her jewels and clothing were not just adornments but symbols of her status and power. Despite her tumultuous life, she left a lasting legacy, and her story continues to captivate historians and the public alike. Her final resting place at Westminster Abbey, opposite Elizabeth I, symbolizes the complex relationship between the two queens who never met in life but are forever linked in history.
Research and create a detailed timeline of the significant events in Mary, Queen of Scots’ life and the broader historical context of the 1500s. Include major political, religious, and personal milestones. Use visuals and brief descriptions to make your timeline engaging.
Participate in a debate where you take on the role of a historical figure from the 1500s, such as Mary, Queen of Scots, Elizabeth I, or a Scottish noble. Prepare arguments based on your character’s perspective on religious reforms and political alliances. Engage with your classmates to explore the complexities of the era.
Examine primary sources from the 1500s, such as letters, portraits, or legal documents related to Mary, Queen of Scots. Analyze these sources to understand the historical context and the perspectives of the people involved. Discuss your findings with the class.
Write a series of diary entries from the perspective of Mary, Queen of Scots or another key figure from the article. Capture their thoughts and emotions during pivotal moments in their life. Share your entries with the class to provide insight into the personal side of historical events.
Work in groups to create a short documentary about Mary, Queen of Scots. Use a mix of narration, reenactments, and interviews with “historical experts” (your classmates) to tell her story. Focus on her impact and legacy, and present your documentary to the class.
**Sanitized Transcript:**
This video is brought to you by Squarespace. From websites and online stores to marketing tools and analytics, Squarespace is the all-in-one platform to build a beautiful online presence and run your business. Check out Squarespace through the link in the description below; more on them in a bit.
Today’s episode has everything: elaborate historical costumes, intrigue, romance, beheadings, and a redhead with an ambition that won’t quit. It’s a tale of tragedy, revenge, more tragedy, and death—the most tragic tragedy of all. Prepare your ears for the true tale of Mary, Queen of Scots.
A quick primer on the history of the British Isles for those who lacked the privilege of growing up there: the mid-1500s were a time of chaos and disruption, ruled over by a series of short-term monarchs whose vastly inconsistent policies did little to dissipate the bubbling reserves of public resentment that would, a scant century later, result in the English Civil War. Today’s drama is set some 40-odd years after Martin Luther first got crossed with Catholicism and ten or so years after King Henry VIII started a religious schism in England just so he could get divorced. Later, Henry was succeeded by his daughter Mary I, also known as Bloody Mary, who attempted to forcibly return England to Catholic rule and mostly succeeded in just killing a lot of people during her five-year reign. This re-reversal was itself reversed by Queen Elizabeth I after she ascended in 1558 and also started killing people.
Meanwhile, in Scotland, James V was executing any Protestants that he felt got too uppity and played off Vatican fears about the Reformation in order to line his pockets. Henry had launched an invasion to try and encourage a break with the Papal State, which somehow failed to persuade him despite his fun new church taxes. The Pope declared him a defender of the faith in 1537 to further strengthen his loyalty to the church. Despite all the good the Reformation was doing for both English and Scottish societies, the weakening of a state theological monopoly is not without consequences, and the wedge between Catholics and Protestants deepened.
It might be surprising for modern audiences to discover how much sway the Pope used to have over the global population of Catholics. These days, the harshest the Vatican gets is threatening to take away communion from political figures, but back then, the Pope would absolutely declare his flock free of obedience to any oligarchy declared illegitimate, as would happen to Queen Elizabeth in 1570. On top of this starkly divided populace, controlling them was a motley array of nobility who only seemed to know how to get ahead in life by intrigue and assassinations in a political system where the queen would have her ambitions checked by a nobility hungry to win the crown themselves.
It would be romantic to say that Mary’s father, King James V, died because of a wound he received in battle or from the psychological toll of defeat. The actual truth of war is that the king probably drank contaminated water, and that’s all it took. For every one soldier killed by enemy weapons, four died of diarrhea. This is true for almost every conflict up until the invention of machine guns and modern medicine. So, the king passed away, and his six-day-old baby assumed the throne. This image will set the mood for all disasters to come.
On December 8, 1542, the day Mary’s troubles began, when she was six months old, England and Scotland signed a treaty promising that Mary would wed the son of Henry VIII. This outraged the Catholic wing of the Scottish regions, who formed an army and marched her off to be raised in France. A marriage alliance was proposed between Mary and the Dauphin Francis, and the King of France accepted; he was also a child at the time. If anyone was worried, Henry wanted nothing more than to deny France a military foothold in the isles, exactly the kind of foothold that Scotland provided. So, in response, England fought a war to force a marriage to a six-month-old girl in a conflict known as the Rough Wooing. That’s quite the name!
Mary spent the next 13 years being raised in the French court while her mother ruled in her stead. She married the Prince of France at age 15 and, after the death of King Henry II, served as queen of both France and Scotland until Francis also died and passed the crown to his younger brother. That same year, Mary’s mother also died, so having little else going for her in France, she headed home to take a second stab at queenship. Now 18 years old, she ascended to the Scottish throne in 1561. Because of her Catholic faith, she was regarded with suspicion by many Protestant groups, but history holds her as a fair leader who was moderate in matters of faith.
Now, we could talk about revolutionary agricultural policies, or we could talk about sex, lies, and murder instead.
Alright, we’ll get back to today’s video in just a moment, but first, here’s a word from today’s video sponsor, Squarespace. Now more than ever, people are getting creative with their time. They’re reaching deep into their savings accounts to start that new crafts business or launch that blog so they can share their opinions with their friends. Just make sure they’re not annoying opinions! The world is yours, and Squarespace is the platform to use when you’re ready to get started on the next web project that you’ve been thinking about.
You’re going to get in and out quick without thinking too much about what your website should look like. Use one of their quick, beautiful templates to make a website that’s fresh and for you. Or maybe you’re more of a hands-on person; you have opinions and ideas about what exactly your site should look like. Squarespace gives you all the customization options you could ever want, with no updates, no patches, no technical issues to worry about. Once you’re done setting up your website, tinkering with the design, or maybe just messing around with the colors, there are a ton of extra features that Squarespace provides so that your website can thrive: email campaigns, patronage portals, social integrations, member-only areas, analytics, commercial options, 24/7 customer support—everything you could ever want all in one place.
So when you’re ready to get started on the next web project of yours, big or small, if it involves a website, it’s got to be with Squarespace. Right now, you can go to squarespace.com for a free trial. When you’re ready to launch your new site, go to squarespace.com/biographics to save 10% on the first purchase of a website or a domain.
And now, back to today’s video. If you know one thing about Mary, it’s that she’s suspected of having conspired to kill one of her three husbands. Let’s dish the hot gossip about Lord Darnley. While Mary was mourning the Dauphin Francis, who died a boring, normal death, she met a six-foot swashbuckler named Henry Stewart, aka Lord Darnley. They both instantly fell for each other, which was convenient because they had the same grandmother, Margaret Tudor, one of the House of Tudor. Four short years later, they married against the objections of Queen Elizabeth, who rightly saw the union to her cousin Lord Darnley as a ploy to strengthen Mary’s claim to the English throne. They also skipped over the part of Catholicism where first cousins are supposed to seek papal dispensation before marriage.
The marriage of two powerhouse Catholics now set to rule over Scotland caused the first rebellion of Mary’s career. The Chaseabout Raid was uneventful; the two forces never actually met, and no battle occurred. It was more of a very slow, heavily armed footrace, but it made clear how far Scotland’s Protestant lords were willing to take their protests. Shortly thereafter, Darnley started demanding the right to rule Scotland as an equal, and he took the refusal poorly. After hearing a rumor that Mary’s pregnancy was the result of an affair, he allied himself with a handful of former enemies from the Chaseabout Raid and executed the supposed adulterer before Mary’s own eyes. Unsurprisingly, their marriage collapsed, and a few months later, Prince James was born.
There were signs of a potential reconciliation; Mary had started visiting him during an illness. But one night, while she was gone, Darnley’s house exploded, and someone left his body in the garden, dead of suffocation. Since that’s not normally one of the side effects of being exploded, a trial was demanded, and rumors swirled about Mary’s involvement. Eventually, all eyes fell on Lord Bothwell, her closest advisor. She even spent time by his side as he recovered from a serious wound, leading to no end of speculation among the queen’s detractors. But with no evidence to present, he was swiftly acquitted.
In response, the power-hungry Lord Bothwell compelled some 20-odd lords to sign a document now called the Ainslie Bond, which declared that the queen should marry a Scottish-born noble. In April of 1567, he set out to do just that, kidnapping her off the road like some common highwayman and marrying her. Her willingness to be a party to any of this is an open question, though there is an impulse to try and romanticize what otherwise would be a terrifying display of force. You can almost see the appeal of the conspiracy angle: a queen eloped with a man who killed her brutish husband is so much more appealing than a narrative that reads the queen was kidnapped and forced into marriage. That’s the bad kind of fairy tale.
Plus, even by the standards of political marriages, this one was a disaster. Bothwell hadn’t even waited two weeks after divorcing his last wife to marry Mary. Many Catholics outright rejected it. The public was actually quite shocked at the union between Mary and this accused murderer. So shocked, in fact, that an army led by 26 nobles attacked and drove Bothwell into exile in Denmark, where he was tortured so much that he actually went crazy and died. Mary, however, had to endure public mockery before forcibly abdicating the throne to her one-year-old son, whom she had seen for the last time shortly before her kidnapping. As punishment for adultery and murder, she was locked in a castle on an island in the middle of a lake.
You’d think after running through three husbands in under six years that Mary might be interested in chilling on punishment island for just a minute. That’s a lot to endure at 25 years of age. She lasted about six months before escaping, raising an army, and trying to kill the dude who led the rebellion. She failed and ran to safety in England, where instead of supporting her ambitions, Elizabeth decided to investigate exactly how involved Mary actually was with Darnley’s murder. Her cousin and royal subject presented as evidence of Mary’s role in the Darnley conspiracy a back of eight letters and a handful of sonnets written by Mary to the Earl of Bothwell, which allegedly proved her active role in organizing the murder. Mary and her team were denied the right to counter-examine the evidence, and since the originals were destroyed a decade later by Mary’s son, historians will never be able to conclusively answer the question of their authenticity. Are they forgeries? Proof of a conspiracy? We will never know.
For Elizabeth, these letters were enough to justify a policy of containment. While Mary’s supporters fought a civil war against the region’s usurper, the queen in exile was confined to the estate of the Earl of Shrewsbury and held under close watch. In this case, close watch meant her own private castle, along with over a dozen staff and 30 carts of sumptuous decorations. Crime pays, apparently, when you’re a queen.
Now, with her first 26 years being one long expanse of death and conflict, maybe she would be interested in cooling her heels. A considerable portion of Catholic England believed Mary had a valid claim to the throne, and she clearly agreed with them. With so many back in Scotland still fighting for her, she saw this as an opportunity to grab two crowns. So no, there would be no cooling of heels. You’d think that a political prisoner wouldn’t have an especially active social life, but you would be mistaken. She held enough dances and parties that it was expected one of them would be the cover for an escape attempt. As dramatic as that would have been, sadly, none of her escape plans succeeded in freeing her from the grasp of English nobility.
Despite her failing health, she was involved in a large number of schemes during her imprisonment. At one point, a pope even endorsed a marriage plot as a pretext for a Spanish invasion of England. So often did the English discover plots to murder Elizabeth that a number of laws were passed to prevent anyone from benefiting too much from her untimely death. In 1584, rendered lame with rheumatism, she proposed an alliance with her teenage son James, who had started ruling on his own just a few years earlier, in exchange for her formal retirement and a promise to cease her plotting. She requested to end her imprisonment. Despite initial interest, both James and Elizabeth rejected her terms and formed an alliance of their own.
We talked a lot about the perils and hardships she faced but little about the advantages of royalty. Mary was a fashion icon in her day and continues to be a modern source of inspiration. Mary first started collecting her trinkets in France when she received a shipment of treasure from her late father. Included among them was a gold mermaid hat badge holding a mirror and a ruby comb. When she became queen, she used her queenly status to further her collection: diamonds, rubies, sapphires—even baby James’s swaddling clothes were held in place by a diamond cross. So important were her jewels to her that the Wikipedia article about her jewels is only marginally shorter than the article about the queen herself.
In addition to bedecking her queenly bazaar, she also used them like currency. She’d wear them to dances and balls in order to build up a reputation about them, then reward them to friends or co-conspirators, even if the recipient was plotting against her. Selling the gift helped spread knowledge of the queen’s reputation. When she had to flee to Scotland, the chests of treasure she left behind were seized by her supporters and used to further the war effort.
Clothing was incredibly important in this period of history because it instantly revealed your social role and political allegiances. Castle staff dressed in their lord’s finery because he was the lord and to gloat their status over the peasants dying in the fields. There were no secondhand shops where a peasant could buy a second-hand bard’s uniform. Mary had to comport herself as if she was God’s chosen representative on earth because, to a lot of people, she literally was. She couldn’t flounce around in pajamas like a work-from-home slob, or no one would have died for her. All the lace, the pearls, the huge frilly neck—whatever—all served some kind of purpose, broadcasting her power and status, even though she was essentially under house arrest.
Sadly, all the style in the world could not save her from the consequences of her actions. The Babington Plot, orchestrated between sympathetic Spanish, French, and English Catholic forces, sought to re-establish Catholicism as the dominant state religion by placing Mary upon the English throne. It would not come to pass. Mary’s role in it was discovered after one of Elizabeth’s spymasters tricked Mary into sending coded letters hidden in beer barrels. She was arrested and put on trial in October 1586. She was convicted on the 25th of that same month and sentenced to death.
You might be asking why you would allow someone to live in your backyard for 19 years if you know they’re plotting to kill you. The truth is Queen Elizabeth was hesitant to start a precedent of executing queens. Regicide is definitely one of those once-you-pop type addictions. She had an extremely vested interest in preserving the image of queens as un-executable. It took her until February 1, 1587, to sign the death warrant and entrusted the task to the Privy Council of England. Six days later, Mary was informed she would be executed at the first light of dawn. She spent a final day distributing her belongings to her staff, praying, and writing her will.
As she marched up to the executioner’s block, she revealed her final outfit: black satin with black trim sleeves and a petticoat in crimson brown velvet, the Catholic liturgical color of martyrs. Historians agree this served to stunt upon her haters. For 19 years, she had lived on their dime, plotting to kill them all the moment she had the opportunity, and she dressed to rub it in their faces. As was the tradition, she stopped to offer forgiveness to her executioner, saying, “I forgive you with all my heart; for now, I hope you should make an end of all my troubles.” To translate that into modern English: “I’m so tired of both being and not being queen at the same time; you might as well just kill me. All my husbands are dead, and my son never rides.”
She was blindfolded, forced to her knees, and prayed her final prayer. In a fitting end to such a tragic figure, it took a few blows to fully sever the neck, and after the executioner lifted up her head, it fell, revealing a vibrant red wig. Illness had left her with thin white hair, which the crowd witnessed as her head bounced around the floor. Her clothes, belongings, even the executioner’s block itself were all burned in order to prevent the creation of relics. The last thing Elizabeth wanted was for Mary to become a martyr for the Catholic cause. Her body was embalmed and stored above ground in a lead coffin and only moved at night. It wasn’t until 1612, after King James VI of Scotland also became King James I of England, that she was reinterred with the other royalty at Westminster Abbey, where she rests opposite the tomb of Elizabeth. The two queens never once met during their lifetimes, and now they spend eternity with their coffins stacked on top of each other.
You’ve probably noticed that scarcely a year went by in this poor woman’s life where someone wasn’t trying to kill her or vice versa. There were plots stacked upon schemes, smothering cutthroat ambition, and palace intrigue.
Mary – A reference to Mary, Queen of Scots, a significant historical figure who was the queen of Scotland from 1542 to 1567. – Mary, Queen of Scots, faced numerous challenges during her reign, including political intrigue and religious conflict.
Scotland – A country that is part of the United Kingdom, known for its rich history and cultural heritage. – The history of Scotland is marked by its struggles for independence and its complex relationship with England.
Protestants – Members of the Christian churches that separated from the Roman Catholic Church during the Reformation. – The rise of the Protestants during the Reformation significantly altered the religious landscape of Europe.
Catholics – Followers of the Roman Catholic Church, which was the dominant religious institution in Europe before the Reformation. – The conflict between Catholics and Protestants led to a series of religious wars in Europe.
Reformation – A religious movement in the 16th century that led to the establishment of Protestant churches and significant changes in the Catholic Church. – The Reformation was a pivotal event in European history, challenging the authority of the Catholic Church and reshaping religious beliefs.
Intrigue – The practice of engaging in secretive or underhanded schemes, often for political purposes. – The court of Mary, Queen of Scots, was rife with intrigue, as nobles vied for power and influence.
Execution – The carrying out of a sentence of death on a condemned person. – The execution of Mary, Queen of Scots, was a controversial act that had significant political repercussions.
Legacy – The lasting impact or influence of a person, event, or period in history. – The legacy of the Reformation can still be seen today in the diverse religious practices across Europe.
Monarchy – A form of government with a monarch at the head, often hereditary, such as a king or queen. – The monarchy of England played a crucial role in shaping the nation’s history and culture.
History – The study of past events, particularly in human affairs, and the interpretation of those events. – Understanding history is essential for comprehending the complexities of modern society and the roots of contemporary issues.
