Hi there! I’m Ellie, and today we’re going to explore some common misconceptions about getting rid of hiccups. Hiccups are those annoying little spasms that can catch us off guard, and while many people have their own remedies, not all of them are backed by science. Let’s dive into some popular beliefs and see what experts have to say about them.
First off, it’s important to know that scientists aren’t completely sure why we get hiccups. They think it might involve the vagus nerve, a part of our brain called the central processor, and the diaphragm, which helps us breathe. Because of this uncertainty, many hiccup remedies are based on old myths rather than scientific facts. Maybe one day, with more research, we’ll have a definite cure!
Many people believe that holding your breath can stop hiccups. However, a study by the American Association of Colleges of Osteopathic Medicine found that this method isn’t effective. Some think that holding your breath might increase carbon dioxide in your body and help, but there’s no solid evidence to support this.
Another popular idea is that getting scared can cure hiccups. Unfortunately, studies have shown that this doesn’t work either. So, you might want to skip the surprise scares!
Some people suggest breathing into a paper bag to increase carbon dioxide levels, which they believe might help with hiccups. However, scientific reviews have found this method to be based on outdated information. While it won’t harm you, there’s no proof it works.
Drinking water, whether sipping or chugging, is a common suggestion for hiccups. While it’s a harmless remedy, there’s no scientific evidence that it actually helps.
In 1981, a small study found that eating a lemon wedge soaked in Angostura bitters helped some people with alcohol-related hiccups. However, the study was very limited and not well-controlled, so we can’t be sure it’s effective.
Some studies claim acupuncture can help with hiccups, but experts argue that these studies aren’t reliable. Many believe acupuncture works no better than a placebo for hiccups.
There’s a product called hiccup pops, which contains water, sugar, and apple cider vinegar. The company claims an 80% success rate, but there’s no scientific proof to back this up yet.
Some people say hypnotherapy has cured their hiccups, but experts find there’s not enough evidence to support this claim.
For persistent hiccups, doctors might prescribe medications like chlorpromazine or haloperidol. However, studies haven’t shown these to be consistently effective.
While some remedies, like eating a spoonful of sugar or peanut butter, seem to work for some people, there’s no confirmed cure for hiccups. A review in 2012 found insufficient evidence to recommend any specific treatment.
Thanks for joining me on this exploration of hiccup misconceptions. If you have any topics you’d like us to cover in future episodes, let us know in the comments. See you next time!
Research the role of the vagus nerve and the diaphragm in the human body. Create a short presentation to explain how these might be involved in causing hiccups. Use diagrams or models to make your presentation more engaging.
Choose one of the common hiccup remedies mentioned in the article, such as holding your breath or drinking water. Conduct a small experiment with your classmates to test its effectiveness. Record your findings and discuss whether the results align with the article’s claims.
Write a short story or comic strip that humorously explores one of the misconceptions about hiccup remedies. Use your creativity to illustrate why the remedy might not work, based on the information from the article.
Prepare a set of questions and conduct a mock interview with a “scientist” (a classmate or teacher) about hiccups and their causes. Focus on the scientific perspective and what current research suggests about hiccup remedies.
Design an infographic that summarizes the common misconceptions about hiccup remedies. Include facts from the article and any additional research you find. Make sure your infographic is visually appealing and easy to understand.
Sure! Here’s a sanitized version of the transcript:
—
Hi, I’m Ellie, and this is Mental Floss. Today, I’m going to talk about some misconceptions about getting rid of hiccups.
First, I want to mention that experts still aren’t entirely sure why and how we get hiccups. They believe it involves the vagus nerve, central processor, and diaphragm. Most treatments at this point are based on old wives’ tales, and we may not discover effective remedies until hiccups are studied and understood more thoroughly. However, scientists often have other priorities, so it’s possible that someday an item on this list will no longer be considered a misconception. If that’s the case, sorry future people, but you won’t have to deal with hiccups anymore!
Now, let’s dive into the misconceptions.
**Misconception number one: Hold your breath.** A study conducted by the American Association of Colleges of Osteopathic Medicine from 1995 to 2000 tested various remedies on 54 hospital patients with hiccups. Holding one’s breath was not found to be an effective cure. According to Tyler Simon, who conducted the study, “People have very interesting interventions, but these aren’t based in science.” Some suggest that holding your breath and increasing carbon dioxide intake might help decrease persistent hiccups, but there hasn’t been a study that proves this yet.
**Misconception number two: Have someone scare you.** This is another remedy that Simon tested in his study. He found this one to be ineffective as well, and there is yet to be a study that proves this works.
**Misconception number three: Breathe into a paper bag.** Many believe this technique helps increase carbon dioxide and may help get rid of hiccups. However, a scientific review published in the Journal of Anesthesia Progress categorized this treatment as anecdotal and based on dated publications that have failed scientific scrutiny. Still, the author notes that doing this won’t harm the patient, so they can try it if they want.
**Misconception number four: Drink a lot of water.** Some people recommend sipping or chugging water, even eating ice chips. While this is a common remedy, there is no evidence that it’s effective, although it won’t hurt you.
**Misconception number five: Lemon with bitters.** This one had some promising results in a study from 1981, where two men had an 88% rate of curing hiccups by feeding participants a lemon wedge soaked in Angostura bitters. However, the study only had 16 participants and wasn’t placebo-controlled. Even if it is effective, it only works for hiccups caused by alcohol.
**Misconception number six: Acupuncture.** Some studies claim that acupuncture is effective for hiccups, but experts point out that these aren’t blind or placebo-controlled studies. Many consider acupuncture to be as effective as a placebo for treating hiccups.
**Misconception number seven: Hiccup lollipops.** There’s a product known as hiccup pops, which contain water, sugar, and apple cider vinegar. While the company claims their product has an 80% success rate, there is no scientific evidence to support this. They specify that they plan to conduct clinical research but haven’t yet.
**Misconception number eight: Hypnotherapy.** A few individuals claim to have been cured of hiccups through hypnotherapy, but experts find insufficient evidence to prove that it is an effective treatment.
**Misconception number nine: Medication.** For very persistent hiccups, a doctor may prescribe medication such as chlorpromazine, buphen, or haloperidol. However, studies have yet to prove that any of these are consistently effective in treating hiccups.
**Misconception number ten: There’s a confirmed cure for hiccups.** Some things seem to produce results, and some studies suggest that eating a spoonful of sugar or peanut butter works. However, according to a systematic review in 2012, there is insufficient evidence to recommend a particular treatment for hiccups.
Thank you for watching this episode of Mental Floss. If you have a topic for an upcoming episode that you would like to see, let us know in the comments, and we’ll check them out. See you next week!
—
Let me know if you need any further modifications!
Hiccups – An involuntary contraction of the diaphragm followed by a quick closure of the vocal cords, producing a characteristic sound. – During the biology class, we learned that hiccups can be caused by eating too quickly or drinking carbonated beverages.
Science – The systematic study of the structure and behavior of the physical and natural world through observation and experiment. – In science class, we conducted an experiment to observe the effects of different temperatures on plant growth.
Diaphragm – A dome-shaped muscular partition separating the thorax from the abdomen in mammals, playing a major role in breathing. – The diaphragm contracts and flattens when you inhale, allowing your lungs to expand and fill with air.
Remedies – Methods or treatments used to cure or alleviate a disease or condition. – Our teacher explained various natural remedies for common ailments, such as using honey for a sore throat.
Misconceptions – Incorrect or mistaken views or ideas about a particular concept or phenomenon. – One of the common misconceptions in biology is that humans only use 10% of their brains, which is not true.
Carbon – A chemical element with symbol C and atomic number 6, essential to all known life forms. – Carbon is a key component of organic molecules, which are the building blocks of life.
Dioxide – A compound consisting of two oxygen atoms bonded to a single atom of another element, such as carbon dioxide (CO2). – Plants use carbon dioxide during photosynthesis to produce oxygen and glucose.
Water – A transparent, tasteless, odorless, and nearly colorless chemical substance, essential for all known forms of life. – Water is vital for cellular processes and helps regulate body temperature in living organisms.
Acupuncture – A traditional Chinese medical practice involving the insertion of thin needles into specific points on the body to relieve pain or treat various conditions. – Some people use acupuncture as an alternative remedy to alleviate chronic pain.
Medication – A substance used for medical treatment, especially a medicine or drug. – The doctor prescribed medication to help reduce the symptoms of the patient’s allergy.
