Did you know that the only job protected by the United States Constitution is journalism? It’s right there in the First Amendment, which ensures freedom of speech and the press. The founders of the U.S. believed that a free press is crucial for democracy because it holds those in power accountable. However, journalism is often misunderstood today.
The media industry is changing rapidly, with fewer newspapers and magazines than before. Despite this, there are more ways to get information than ever. The shift from traditional media, like newspapers, to digital platforms such as websites and social media, has caused much of this change.
Many people think print journalism is gone, but that’s not entirely true. In 1990, U.S. newspapers circulated over 62 million copies daily. Today, that number is around 21 or 22 million, including both print and digital versions. A report from Northwestern University’s Medill School of Journalism predicts that by next year, we might lose a third of the newspapers that existed in 2005.
Digital media has transformed news access. In 1995, 7 million Americans regularly read news online. By 2000, a significant portion of Americans had cable TV, internet access, and cell phones. Now, 85% of Americans get their news digitally.
While it seems like print is dying, it still holds value. According to Washington Post reporter Michael Rosenwald, no digital platform has matched print’s success in revenue or readership. Many readers find print news more credible and easier to understand than digital content. A study in the Journal of Journalism Practice found that print still reaches more readers than digital in local markets across all age groups.
Many people believe that news is biased, favoring one political view over another. A Gallup poll in September 2023 showed that only 7% of Americans had high confidence in the media’s fairness, while 39% had none.
However, journalism aims to report stories fully, accurately, and fairly. The Associated Press emphasizes accurate, fact-based, nonpartisan reporting. Reporters strive to avoid bias by consulting multiple sources and verifying information. Stories often go through several editors to ensure fairness.
While reporters are human and may have unconscious biases, ethical journalists work hard to keep bias out of their stories. A Gallup and KN Foundation experiment found that readers trusted news more when they didn’t know the source, suggesting that readers’ biases might affect their perception of news.
Networks like Fox News and MSNBC are often seen as biased. They mix news reporting with opinionated commentary, making it hard for audiences to differentiate between the two. This confusion contributes to distrust in journalism. Both journalists and the public seek clearer distinctions between news and opinion.
There’s a misconception that journalists are wealthy. While some top journalists earn high salaries, most are just getting by in a shrinking industry. In 2022, the median salary for news analysts, reporters, and journalists in the U.S. was $55,940 per year.
Location affects journalist salaries. In the Washington D.C. Metro Area, the average salary is over $160,000, while in Florida, it’s $72,000, in Washington State $64,000, in Ohio $51,000, and in Illinois $46,000. If you’re looking to get rich, consider other careers like oral surgery or piloting.
The phrase “if it bleeds, it leads” suggests that sensational stories sell. This idea, known as yellow journalism, still influences today’s media. Negativity bias, the tendency to focus on negative information, may explain why people perceive news as more negative than it is.
Journalists do cover positive news, but it’s a challenge against the human attraction to sensationalism. Harvard psychology professor Steven Pinker suggests focusing on “factfulness,” which shows the world is better than we think. News outlets could regularly present statistics on global and national conditions and expand fact-checking to include long-term data.
Another approach is solutions journalism, which explores specific solutions to problems and what can be learned when they don’t work.
Thanks for exploring the world of journalism with us. Newspapers and media will always play a vital role in democracy.
Engage in a class debate about the relevance of print media in today’s digital age. Divide into two groups: one advocating for the continued importance of print journalism and the other supporting the dominance of digital platforms. Use statistics and examples from the article to support your arguments.
Analyze different news articles from various sources. Identify potential biases and discuss how they might affect the reader’s perception. Reflect on how journalists can minimize bias in their reporting, using the strategies mentioned in the article.
Research the average salaries of journalists in different regions and compare them with other professions. Present your findings in a report, highlighting the economic challenges journalists face and how this impacts the industry.
Create a news story focusing on positive events or solutions to current problems. Use the concept of solutions journalism to explore how these stories can impact public perception and contribute to a more balanced news landscape.
Investigate the First Amendment’s role in protecting journalism. Discuss its significance in maintaining a democratic society and how it applies to modern media. Present your findings in a class discussion or a short essay.
Here’s a sanitized version of the provided YouTube transcript:
—
There’s only one kind of job protected by the United States Constitution, and it’s right there in the First Amendment: Congress shall make no law abridging the freedom of speech or of the press. The founders saw the free press as essential to democracy; it was the thing that held those in power accountable to the people. But is any role in a functioning free society more misunderstood these days than journalism?
As an industry, journalism has faced significant challenges, including financial losses. Journalists have been threatened or worse just for doing their jobs, and elected officials regularly accuse the news media of fabricating stories. No wonder there are so many misconceptions about it.
Hi, I’m Justin. Today, we’ll investigate some enduring myths about journalism, from its alleged bias to premature reports of its death.
Let’s get started.
**Print is Dead**
It’s no secret that today’s media industry is in flux, with fewer newspapers and magazines than just a couple of years ago. However, paradoxically, there are more sources of information and ways to obtain it than ever before. Much of the instability stems from significant changes over the past three decades in how people consume news. The main change is the shift from traditional media, like printed newspapers, to new media, including websites, apps, video, and social media.
One of the biggest misconceptions about the news business is that print journalism has disappeared. Let’s look at newspaper circulation, which is the number of copies distributed on a given day. Weekday and Sunday circulations of all U.S. newspapers totaled a little over 62 million copies each in 1990. Today, that number is more like 21 or 22 million, including print and digital copies. According to a 2021 report by Northwestern University’s Medill School of Journalism, more than 200 U.S. counties lack a local newspaper and predict that we’ll lose one-third of all newspapers that existed in 2005 by the end of next year.
Since 1990, digital media has transformed how people access news. In 1995, 7 million Americans were regular online news readers. By 2000, 67% of Americans subscribed to cable TV, 54% went online, and 53% owned a cell phone. Today, 85% of Americans get their news sometimes or often on digital devices.
All this seems to suggest that print is dead, but not exactly. According to Washington Post reporter Michael Rosenwald, no app, streamlined website, social network, or algorithm has come close to matching the success of print in revenue or readership. Readers still tend to consider print news more credible, trustworthy, and of higher quality than digital content. Reading a print newspaper or magazine is easier on the eyes and results in better reading comprehension compared to digital formats.
A study in the Journal of Journalism Practice found that, contrary to widespread assumptions, the supposedly dying print product still reaches far more readers than the supposedly promising digital product in home markets across all age groups.
**Journalism is Always Biased**
A major complaint about the news today is that it’s biased. Some commenters feel the reporting is slanted toward one political viewpoint or another, or that publishers direct the coverage of certain topics while ignoring others. A September 2023 Gallup poll found that only 7% of Americans were very confident in the media’s ability to report news fairly, while 39% had zero confidence in its fairness.
Yet the core tenet of journalism is to report stories fully, accurately, and fairly. The Associated Press asserts that its values include accurate, fact-based, nonpartisan reporting. For a reporter working on a story, avoiding bias means speaking to several sources with a variety of viewpoints, quoting them accurately, and verifying their statements with additional sources.
If a news story portrays someone negatively, the reporter makes an effort to contact that person for their response. Completed news stories often go through several editors to ensure that the information is fairly presented.
Do reporters’ unconscious biases sometimes creep in? Yes, reporters are human, but ethical journalists strive to keep any hint of bias out of their stories.
So why might readers sense pervasive bias in the news? An experiment by Gallup and the KN Foundation aimed to find out. They built a website populated with news articles from diverse outlets, and a group of nearly 3,500 readers rated the trustworthiness of the stories. Half of the group could see the sources that published the stories, while the other half could only see the content. The ratings published in 2018 showed that readers who didn’t know the news source had more trust in the information.
In other words, it’s not necessarily that the news is filled with bias; it’s that readers’ own biases are likely coloring their perception of the news.
You may be thinking, what about outlets like Fox News or MSNBC, which are widely perceived as having a conservative or liberal bias? Many major news organizations, including these networks, feature news reporting as well as opinionated commentary, making it difficult for the audience to distinguish between the two.
The confusion between news and opinion leads to distrust of journalism as a whole. Both journalists and the public want clearer definitions of news and opinion in the media.
**Journalists are Rich**
This is a major misconception that needs debunking. While there are some star journalists at major news outlets making six or even seven figures, the vast majority are just trying to get by in a contracting industry. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, in 2022, the median pay for all news analysts, reporters, and journalists in the U.S. was $55,940 per year.
Geography plays a big part in journalist income too. Those working in the Washington D.C. Metro Area, the country’s top-paying market, can expect an average salary of a little over $160,000. In contrast, the average salary drops to $72,000 in Florida, $64,000 in Washington State, $51,000 in Ohio, and $46,000 in Illinois.
Bottom line: if you’re a young journalist looking to get rich, you might want to consider switching to a different role, like an oral surgeon or an airline pilot—that’s where the real money is.
**Journalists Only Want to Cover Bad News**
The phrase “if it bleeds, it leads” is often attributed to newspaper tycoon William Randolph Hearst, who believed that sensational stories would sell papers. This legacy, known as yellow journalism, is still present in today’s media landscape.
Negativity bias, the unconscious tendency to focus on negative information, may explain readers’ attraction to bad news and their perception that news is more negative than it really is. Journalists cover plenty of good and positive news, but it’s a constant fight against humanity’s inherent need for sensationalism.
To combat this, Harvard psychology professor Steven Pinker suggests focusing on factfulness, which argues that data shows the world is in better shape than we think. Hard news divisions could present regular statistics on the state of the nation and the world, while editors could expand fact-checking to include long-term data.
Another tactic is practicing solutions journalism, which investigates specific solutions to problems as well as what can be learned when solutions don’t work.
Thanks for watching. The world of journalism, newspapers, and media will always be an important part of democracy.
—
This version removes any inappropriate language and maintains a professional tone while preserving the key points and structure of the original content.
Journalism – The activity or profession of writing for newspapers, magazines, or news websites, or preparing news to be broadcast. – In her journalism class, Maria learned how to investigate and report on current events with integrity and accuracy.
Media – The main means of mass communication, such as television, radio, newspapers, and the internet, regarded collectively. – The influence of media on public opinion can shape the outcome of elections and policy decisions.
Print – The process of producing text and images, typically with ink on paper, using a printing press. – Despite the rise of digital platforms, many people still prefer to read print newspapers for their morning news.
Digital – Involving or relating to the use of computer technology, especially the internet. – The digital revolution has transformed how we access information and communicate with one another.
Bias – A tendency to favor one perspective or outcome over others, often in a way considered to be unfair. – It is important for journalists to recognize their own bias to ensure fair and balanced reporting.
News – Newly received or noteworthy information, especially about recent events. – The evening news covered the latest developments in the international trade negotiations.
Americans – Citizens or natives of the United States of America. – Many Americans rely on a variety of news sources to stay informed about national and global issues.
Reporting – The act of gathering, assessing, creating, and presenting news and information. – Investigative reporting plays a crucial role in uncovering truths and holding powerful entities accountable.
Credibility – The quality of being trusted and believed in. – A journalist’s credibility is essential for maintaining the trust of their audience and ensuring the integrity of their work.
Democracy – A system of government by the whole population, typically through elected representatives. – A free press is vital to the functioning of a healthy democracy, as it provides citizens with the information they need to make informed decisions.
