Misconceptions About The Amish

Alphabets Sounds Video

share us on:

The lesson addresses common misconceptions about the Amish, highlighting that they are not entirely isolated from modern society and technology. While they maintain unique practices and values, such as using horse-drawn buggies and gathering for worship in homes, many Amish individuals successfully run businesses and navigate a complex relationship with technology based on community guidelines. Ultimately, the lesson emphasizes the importance of understanding the shared values of family, community, and simplicity that resonate with broader society.

Misconceptions About The Amish

An Unexpected Event in Amish Country

In 1998, something surprising happened in the small village of Intercourse, Pennsylvania. Two Amish men were arrested for dealing drugs. According to a federal indictment, these men, both named Abner, were accused of getting cocaine from a motorcycle gang and distributing it within their Amish community during social events. This incident seemed unusual because the Amish are often seen as devout people living simple, quiet lives, away from the distractions of modern society. They usually avoid contact with the outside world, which has led to various stereotypes reinforced by popular culture.

The Reality of Amish Life

However, the idea that the Amish are completely untouched by modern civilization isn’t entirely true. While they are known for avoiding certain technologies, the reality is more complex. The Amish in North America trace their roots back to the Anabaptist movement in Europe during the 16th century, which promoted beliefs different from mainstream Christianity. Over time, different groups formed, including the Old Order Amish, who have unique beliefs and practices.

Technology and the Amish

One common stereotype is that the Amish reject all technology. While it’s true that many Amish communities avoid the electric grid, this decision is often misunderstood. They aren’t necessarily against electricity; rather, they are cautious about how it might affect their way of life. Each Amish community has its own set of rules, known as the ordnung, which guides their use of technology. Some communities might use power tools or other technologies that fit with their values.

Amish Wealth and Work Ethic

Another misconception is that all Amish people are poor. In reality, many Amish individuals run successful businesses, like bakeries and woodworking shops, which contribute to their financial stability. While they may not flaunt their wealth, they often support each other and have a strong work ethic, leading to successful entrepreneurial ventures.

Transportation and Rumspringa

Transportation is another area where misconceptions exist. While the Amish typically don’t drive cars, they use horse-drawn buggies for local travel. Some communities allow the use of taxis or other transportation services when needed. Additionally, Amish teenagers may go through a period called Rumspringa, where they can explore the outside world before deciding whether to fully commit to their faith.

Community and Worship

The Amish don’t have formal church buildings; instead, they gather in homes or community spaces for worship. This practice helps create close-knit relationships within their communities. While they may prefer to keep their distance from outsiders, some people raised in other religions may choose to join an Amish community if they sincerely wish to adopt their lifestyle.

Shared Values

Ultimately, the Amish focus on family, community, and simplicity, aiming to prioritize what truly matters in life. While they may seem different from mainstream society, there are shared values that many people can relate to.

  1. How did the incident in Intercourse, Pennsylvania challenge your previous perceptions of the Amish community?
  2. What aspects of Amish life, as described in the article, were most surprising to you, and why?
  3. In what ways do the Amish balance their traditional values with the realities of modern technology, according to the article?
  4. How does the article’s discussion of Amish entrepreneurship and work ethic alter your understanding of their economic status?
  5. Reflect on the concept of Rumspringa. How does this practice influence your view of Amish youth and their cultural identity?
  6. What parallels can you draw between the Amish focus on community and simplicity and your own life or values?
  7. How does the Amish approach to worship and community gatherings differ from or resemble your own experiences with religious or community events?
  8. After reading the article, what misconceptions about the Amish do you think are most prevalent in popular culture, and how might they be addressed?
  1. Research and Presentation on Amish Stereotypes

    Research common stereotypes about the Amish and compare them with the realities discussed in the article. Create a presentation to share your findings with the class, highlighting any misconceptions and the truths behind them.

  2. Debate: Technology and the Amish

    Participate in a class debate about the role of technology in Amish communities. Take a position either for or against the use of certain technologies, using evidence from the article to support your arguments.

  3. Case Study: Amish Entrepreneurship

    Examine a successful Amish business and analyze how it aligns with Amish values and work ethic. Write a report detailing the business model, challenges faced, and how it contributes to the community’s financial stability.

  4. Creative Writing: A Day in the Life of an Amish Teenager

    Write a short story from the perspective of an Amish teenager experiencing Rumspringa. Incorporate elements from the article to depict the balance between exploring the outside world and adhering to Amish traditions.

  5. Community Values Discussion

    Facilitate a class discussion on the shared values between Amish communities and mainstream society. Reflect on how these values can be applied in your own life and community, drawing parallels with the article’s insights.

In 1998, an unusual event occurred in the small village of Intercourse, Pennsylvania, where two Amish men were arrested for drug dealing. A federal indictment alleged that both men, named Abner, had been sourcing cocaine from members of a motorcycle gang and distributing it to their Amish community during social gatherings. This incident seems out of character for the Amish, who are often portrayed as devout individuals leading simple, quiet lives, free from the distractions of modern society. They typically avoid contact with the outside world, which has led to various stereotypes reinforced by popular culture.

However, the notion that the Amish are completely untouched by modern civilization is not entirely accurate. While they do have a reputation for shunning certain technologies, the reality is more nuanced. The Amish in North America can be traced back to the Anabaptist movement of Europe in the 16th century, which promoted beliefs that diverged from mainstream Christian practices. Over time, different groups emerged, including the Old Order Amish, who have distinct beliefs and practices.

One common stereotype is that the Amish reject all technology. While it is true that many Amish communities avoid the electric grid, this decision is often misunderstood. They are not necessarily opposed to electricity; rather, they are cautious about its potential impact on their way of life. Each Amish community has its own guidelines, known as the ordnung, which dictate their approach to technology. Some communities may use power tools or other technologies that align with their values.

Another misconception is that all Amish people are poor. In reality, many Amish individuals run successful businesses, such as bakeries and woodworking shops, contributing to their financial stability. While they may not display wealth ostentatiously, they often support one another and have a strong work ethic, leading to successful entrepreneurial ventures.

Transportation is another area where misconceptions abound. While the Amish do not typically drive cars, they may use horse-drawn buggies for local travel. Some communities allow for the use of taxis or other transportation services when necessary. Additionally, Amish teenagers may experience a period known as Rumspringa, where they can explore the outside world before deciding whether to fully commit to their faith.

The Amish do not have formal church buildings; instead, they gather in homes or community spaces for worship. This practice fosters close-knit relationships within their communities. While they may prefer to keep their distance from outsiders, some individuals raised in other religions may seek to join an Amish community if they demonstrate a sincere desire to adopt their lifestyle.

Ultimately, the Amish focus on family, community, and simplicity, seeking to prioritize what matters most in life. While they may seem different from mainstream society, there are shared values that many can relate to.

AmishA religious and cultural group known for simple living, plain dress, and reluctance to adopt modern technology, primarily found in the United States and Canada. – The Amish community is often studied in social studies for their unique lifestyle and resistance to modern technology.

TechnologyThe application of scientific knowledge for practical purposes, especially in industry and everyday life. – The impact of technology on society is a major topic in social studies, as it influences everything from communication to transportation.

CommunityA group of people living in the same place or having a particular characteristic in common, often sharing resources and responsibilities. – In social studies, the concept of community is crucial for understanding how individuals interact and support each other in society.

RumspringaA period of adolescence for some Amish youth, during which they are given greater freedom to explore the outside world before deciding whether to join the church permanently. – Rumspringa is an important cultural practice that highlights the Amish approach to faith and personal choice.

ValuesPrinciples or standards of behavior that are considered important or beneficial by a society or group. – Social studies often examine how values shape the laws and customs of different cultures and societies.

ReligionA system of beliefs, practices, and moral values that often involves worship of a higher power or deity. – Religion plays a significant role in shaping cultural identities and societal norms, making it a key topic in social studies.

StereotypesOversimplified and widely held fixed ideas or images of a particular type of person or thing. – Social studies classes often address stereotypes to promote understanding and reduce prejudice among different cultural groups.

WorkPhysical or mental effort directed towards achieving a purpose or producing something, often for economic gain. – The study of work and labor systems is essential in social studies to understand economic structures and social hierarchies.

TransportationThe movement of people or goods from one place to another, often using vehicles or infrastructure. – Transportation systems are a critical area of study in social studies, as they influence economic development and cultural exchange.

SimplicityThe quality or condition of being easy to understand or do, often associated with a lifestyle that minimizes material possessions and complexity. – The Amish are often admired for their simplicity, which reflects their values and religious beliefs.

All Video Lessons

Login your account

Please login your account to get started.

Don't have an account?

Register your account

Please sign up your account to get started.

Already have an account?