Imagine a place on Earth that looks just like the Moon! This place is called the Sea of Tranquility, where humans first walked on the Moon. But there’s also a spot in Arizona that looks almost identical. If you saw pictures of both places without labels, you might not be able to tell them apart. This isn’t a coincidence or a natural phenomenon; NASA created this moon-like field in Arizona using explosives to help astronauts prepare for their lunar missions. Today, nature has mostly reclaimed these craters, but the story behind them is fascinating.
Back in the late 1960s, NASA was getting ready for the first trip to the Moon. But they had a big question: “What should the astronauts do once they get there?” At that time, scientists didn’t know much about how the Moon was formed or what its surface was made of. The best images they had were from satellites orbiting the Moon, but these images could only show the largest craters. The smaller details were still a mystery.
NASA realized that studying the Moon’s rocks, craters, and materials could teach us a lot about the origins of both the Moon and Earth. However, the astronauts would have limited time on the Moon, so they needed to make the most of every moment. That’s where Cinder Lake in Arizona came into play.
Before setting foot on the Moon, astronauts needed to become experts in geology, which is the study of rocks and Earth’s structure. They had to learn how to look at a crater and figure out its age, as well as describe the rocks and materials they found. To help them practice, NASA created a model of the Moon’s surface in a field near Flagstaff, Arizona. This field was covered in volcanic gravel, which NASA thought would be similar to the Moon’s surface.
Creating this model was a big challenge. The team used dynamite to make craters that matched the size and location of those on the Moon. They even considered the different ages of the craters. Using photos from lunar orbiters, NASA determined the ages of the craters with a principle called superposition, which means younger craters are on top of older ones.
The team marked out 143 craters and grouped them into new, intermediate, and old categories. They placed dynamite under each mark and detonated them in order, starting with the oldest. This created a realistic version of the Apollo 11 landing site.
One of the first challenges astronauts would face on the Moon was figuring out exactly where they landed. NASA had a landing site in mind, but the actual spot could be off by up to five kilometers. Without knowing their precise location, it would be hard to guide astronauts to interesting craters or track their movements. So, NASA wanted to know if astronauts could locate themselves by comparing their view from the lunar module to a map of the surface.
To test this, NASA placed a mock-up of the lunar module in the crater field and asked 28 test subjects to find their location within 30 minutes. These subjects included geologists, mathematicians, surveyors, and others. It was a tough test because seeing from above is easier than navigating on the ground, where depth perception is limited.
Each participant got a real satellite image of the Moon and had 30 minutes to mark their location. If they couldn’t find it, they received smaller maps to help narrow down their search. Out of 28 participants, only six found their location using the one-kilometer map. Others needed smaller maps to succeed.
The best method was to look for pairs of craters, as it was easier to remember the shape of two craters than a complex array. NASA was confident that with more training, astronauts would be able to locate themselves more easily.
As astronauts prepared to walk on the Moon, they needed to know what to look for. Cinder Lake was their training ground, where geologists taught them how to identify specific rocks and collect samples. They practiced field exercises and communicated their observations back to scientists via radio. NASA found it challenging to understand what the astronauts were doing just from radio communication, so they experimented with live video transmission from Cinder Lake. This greatly improved collaboration and led to live broadcasts for every moon mission.
Overall, astronauts trained at Cinder Lake until the Apollo program ended. During their missions, they brought back over 380 kilograms of samples from six different areas on the Moon. These samples are still being studied today, all thanks to the training at this small field in Arizona.
Imagine you are part of NASA’s team in the 1960s. Your task is to create a mini-moon surface using simple materials. Gather sand, flour, and small rocks to simulate the Moon’s surface. Use small objects like marbles to create craters by dropping them from different heights. Observe and record how the size and depth of the craters change with different impact forces. Discuss how this experiment relates to NASA’s use of dynamite to create craters in Arizona.
Become a geology detective like the astronauts! Collect different types of rocks from your local area or use samples provided by your teacher. Examine their features, such as color, texture, and hardness. Try to identify each rock type and hypothesize about its formation. Present your findings to the class, explaining how understanding these features would be crucial for astronauts studying the Moon’s surface.
Test your navigation skills with a map challenge! Using a map of a familiar area, such as your school or neighborhood, try to locate specific landmarks without using GPS. Work in pairs to guide each other using only the map and verbal directions. Reflect on how this activity relates to the challenges astronauts faced when locating themselves on the Moon using only maps and visual cues.
Participate in a moon landing simulation game. Use a computer or tablet to play a simulation that requires you to land a lunar module safely on the Moon’s surface. Pay attention to the challenges of landing, such as controlling speed and angle. Discuss how these simulations help astronauts prepare for real-life missions and the importance of practice in achieving successful landings.
Engage in a role-play activity to simulate the communication between astronauts and mission control. One student acts as an astronaut describing a rock sample, while another student, acting as mission control, tries to visualize and record the description. Use walkie-talkies or a similar communication tool to enhance the experience. Discuss the difficulties of communicating complex information and how live video transmission improved NASA’s missions.
Here’s a sanitized version of the provided YouTube transcript:
—
This is the Sea of Tranquility, the area where humans first walked on the moon. And this is Arizona. If these pictures weren’t labeled, it would be almost impossible to tell them apart. Each crater is remarkably similar in size and location. This isn’t a hoax or a physical phenomenon; this place was meticulously created by NASA to resemble the moon. With the help of explosives, this field in Arizona was transformed into the most moon-like place on Earth. Nowadays, the craters have mostly been reclaimed by nature.
In the late ’60s, NASA was preparing for their first trip to the moon, but the question was, “What would they do when they got there?” At that time, very little was known about how the moon formed and the materials that made up its surface. The most detailed images available were from lunar orbiter satellites, which had a resolution of about 2 meters. With these images, only the largest craters could be seen, and the finer details of the surface remained unknown.
As NASA prepared to send humans to the moon, they realized that studying the rocks, craters, and materials on the surface could provide valuable insights into the origins of the Moon and Earth. However, the astronauts’ time on the moon was limited, making it crucial to maximize the scientific knowledge gained from each trip. That’s where Cinder Lake came in.
Before astronauts stepped foot on the moon, they needed to become experts in geology. They had to be able to look at a crater and determine its age, as well as provide detailed descriptions of rocks and materials while exploring the lunar surface. To achieve this, NASA created a model of the moon’s surface in a field near Flagstaff, Arizona. This field, located near a former volcano, was covered in volcanic gravel, which NASA believed would be similar to the material on the moon.
Creating a one-to-one scale model of the Apollo landing site was challenging. To transform this field into a moon-like surface, the team in Arizona used dynamite. They aimed to replicate the exact size and location of each crater, as well as the different ages of the craters. Based on lunar orbiter photos, NASA determined the relative ages using a principle called superposition, which states that younger craters lie on top of older ones.
To replicate the different ages, the team marked out all 143 craters and categorized them into three groups: new, intermediate, and old. They placed precise amounts of dynamite under each crater mark and detonated them in sequence, starting with the oldest craters first. The result was an incredibly accurate depiction of the Apollo 11 landing site.
One of the first challenges astronauts would face upon landing on the moon was determining their exact location. Although NASA had a landing site in mind, the actual spot could vary by up to five kilometers. Without knowing their precise location, NASA couldn’t guide the astronauts to the most interesting craters or track their movements. This led NASA to ask whether astronauts could accurately locate themselves by comparing their view from the lunar module to a map of the surface.
A mock-up of the lunar module was placed at a random location in the crater field, and 28 test subjects were given 30 minutes to find their location. The subjects included geologists, mathematicians, surveyors, and individuals from various backgrounds. Despite their experience, this was a challenging test. Observing from above is much easier than navigating on the surface, where depth perception is limited due to the lack of atmosphere.
Each participant received a real satellite image of the Moon and had 30 minutes to mark their location. If they couldn’t find it, they were given progressively smaller maps to narrow down their search. The results were intriguing: out of 28 participants, only six found their location using the one-kilometer map, while others used smaller maps with varying success.
The most effective method involved searching for pairs of craters, as remembering the shape of two craters was easier than visualizing a complex array. NASA was confident that with more training and familiarity with the area, astronauts would be able to locate themselves more easily.
As astronauts prepared to walk on the lunar surface, they needed to know what to look for. Cinder Lake served as a training ground where geologists taught astronauts how to identify specific rocks and collect samples. They conducted field exercises, communicating their observations back to scientists via radio. NASA realized that it was challenging to know what the astronauts were doing based solely on radio communication, leading them to experiment with live video transmission from Cinder Lake. This innovation greatly improved collaboration between NASA and the astronauts, resulting in live broadcasts for every moon mission.
Overall, astronauts trained at Cinder Lake until the Apollo program concluded. During the missions, they brought back over 380 kilograms of samples from six different areas on the moon, stored in containers that preserved them for ongoing scientific study. All of this was made possible thanks to this small field in Arizona.
And now, it’s time for the Primal Space giveaway. The winner of the previous giveaway is Ivan. Congratulations! In the next video, we’ll be giving away an awesome Apollo framed print. To enter, sign up at the link below, like the video, and leave a comment about your favorite Apollo moment. Thank you for watching, and I’ll see you in the next video. This October, Primal Space will be at the Space Creator Day in Germany, an exciting event where you can meet and hang out with your favorite space YouTubers and other space enthusiasts. Click the link in the description to get your tickets.
—
This version maintains the original content while removing any promotional or potentially sensitive material.
Moon – The natural satellite that orbits the Earth and is visible at night. – The moon reflects sunlight, which is why it shines brightly in the night sky.
Astronauts – People who are trained to travel and work in space. – Astronauts aboard the International Space Station conduct experiments to learn more about living in space.
Craters – Large, round pits on the surface of a planet or moon, usually caused by the impact of a meteorite. – The surface of the moon is covered with craters formed by ancient asteroid impacts.
Geology – The study of the Earth’s physical structure and substance, including the study of other planets and moons. – Lunar geology helps scientists understand the history and composition of the moon.
Training – The process of learning the skills needed for a particular job or activity, such as space missions. – Astronauts undergo extensive training to prepare for the challenges of space travel.
Surface – The outermost layer or boundary of an object, such as a planet or moon. – The surface of Mars is covered with red dust and rocky terrain.
Location – A particular place or position, often used to describe where something is in space. – The location of the new space telescope will allow it to capture clear images of distant galaxies.
Samples – Small parts or quantities taken from a larger whole, often used for scientific analysis. – Scientists study rock samples from the moon to learn about its composition and history.
Exploration – The act of traveling through an unfamiliar area to learn about it, often used in the context of space. – Space exploration has led to many discoveries about our solar system and beyond.
NASA – The National Aeronautics and Space Administration, the United States government agency responsible for the nation’s civilian space program. – NASA’s missions have greatly expanded our understanding of the universe.
