About 3 billion years ago, a tiny, single-celled organism started producing a gas that was toxic to almost all life on Earth at the time. Over hundreds of millions of years, more microorganisms began releasing this gas, filling the oceans and eventually the atmosphere. This gas was oxygen, and its introduction was so dramatic that it caused a global ice age, known as the Great Oxygen Catastrophe.
Since then, most life forms, including all multicellular organisms, have evolved to rely on oxygen. However, some environments still exist where oxygen is absent, allowing ancient microorganisms to thrive. These environments are often found deep in the ocean, but there are also accessible places on land, like a special lake in the Swiss Alps’ Piora Valley.
Lake Cadagno, formed over 10,000 years ago, is one of about 200 known meromictic lakes. This means it has two distinct layers of water that never mix. The top layer is like a regular freshwater lake, safe for swimming and home to many fish. But just 13 meters below, there’s a dense, sulfur-rich layer without any oxygen, deadly to fish and other multicellular life.
In most lakes, water mixes, allowing oxygen to spread throughout. However, in Lake Cadagno, the layers remain separate due to their unique chemical compositions. Rainwater flows into the lake in two ways: directly into the upper layer or through the Piora Valley’s dolomite rock, which is rich in salts like sulfate.
As rainwater seeps through the dolomite, it loses oxygen and gains salts, becoming heavier. This water then flows into the lake from springs below, forming the anoxic, salt-rich bottom layer. This environment is perfect for anaerobic bacteria, which thrived before oxygen became abundant on Earth.
The springs create microenvironments that support large groups of microorganisms, which form unusual shapes on the lakebed. These anaerobic microorganisms absorb sulfate from the water and release toxic sulfide. At the boundary between the layers, a thin layer of pink-bodied bacteria called Chromatium okenii thrives. These bacteria use sulfur for photosynthesis, much like plants use oxygen.
Although the water and organisms don’t move between the layers, they aren’t completely isolated. Chromatium okenii stay at the top of the bottom layer to catch sunlight. While they don’t enter the oxygen-rich waters, they’re close enough for creatures like zooplankton to dive down, eat them, and return to the upper layer. This interaction supports the lake’s food chain, including its famous fish population.
Lake Cadagno’s unique ecosystem is a treasure trove for scientists. It allows them to study an isolated anaerobic environment, offering insights into conditions before the Great Oxygen Catastrophe. For example, when Chromatium okenii form their layer, they increase its density, causing it to sink. The bacteria must swim back up, creating a slight mixing of water called bioconvection. This ancient process might reveal how early life forms developed the ability to swim, among other fascinating discoveries awaiting researchers in the depths of Lake Cadagno.
Research the concept of meromictic lakes and their global distribution. Create a presentation that explains why these lakes have distinct layers and how they compare to Lake Cadagno. Share your findings with the class, highlighting the unique characteristics and ecological significance of these lakes.
Conduct a simple experiment to simulate the layering of Lake Cadagno. Use water, salt, and food coloring to create two distinct layers in a clear container. Observe how the layers remain separate and discuss the factors that contribute to this phenomenon, relating it to the chemical composition of Lake Cadagno.
Engage in a class debate about the Great Oxygen Catastrophe. Divide into two groups: one arguing its positive impact on the evolution of life and the other discussing its destructive effects on ancient microorganisms. Use evidence from the article and additional research to support your arguments.
Write a creative story from the perspective of a Chromatium okenii bacterium living in Lake Cadagno. Describe your daily activities, interactions with other microorganisms, and the challenges you face in the unique environment of the lake. Share your story with the class to explore the microbial world creatively.
Propose a field trip to a local lake or water body. Plan activities that would help the class understand the concepts discussed in the article, such as water layering and microbial life. Include objectives, a schedule, and potential learning outcomes. Present your proposal to the class and discuss its educational value.
Here’s a sanitized version of the provided YouTube transcript:
—
Roughly 3 billion years ago, a single-celled photosynthetic bacterium began producing a new chemical that was harmful to nearly every species on Earth. Over the following hundreds of millions of years, more microorganisms started generating this toxic gas, first saturating Earth’s oceans and eventually its atmosphere. This chemical altered the composition of pre-existing gases so drastically that it triggered a global ice age. The name of this significant gas? Oxygen.
In the millions of years since the Great Oxygen Catastrophe, most life, including all multicellular organisms, has evolved to depend on this gas. However, there are some environments where oxygen-averse microorganisms, reminiscent of Earth’s earliest days, have re-emerged. Many of these environments are found in the ocean depths, beyond the reach of researchers. Yet, there are also bodies of water completely devoid of oxygen that are accessible for exploration. One such lake is located high in the Swiss Alps’ Piora Valley.
Formed over 10,000 years ago, Lake Cadagno is one of approximately 200 known meromictic lakes, which means it consists of two distinct layers of water stacked on top of each other. The upper layer behaves like a typical freshwater body. It is safe for swimming and is known for its abundant fish population, which has been the subject of local fishing legends for centuries. However, just 13 meters beneath this layer lies a dense, sulfurous, oxygen-free pool that is lethal to any multicellular life forms, including fish.
In a typical lake, the entire body of water would gradually mix, allowing oxygen from the surface to diffuse throughout. However, in meromictic lakes like Cadagno, these two layers never mix. The reason for this separation in Cadagno is the unique chemical compositions of the waters. Both layers receive rainwater flowing down the mountains; however, this water can take two different paths. The first path leads directly into the upper layer, while the second path involves the water seeping into the Piora Valley’s vein of dolomite—a porous rock rich in salts such as sulfate.
Rainwater that sinks into the dolomite gradually makes its way to the lake, losing its oxygen and gaining salts along the way. This heavier water eventually flows from sublacustrine springs below the lake’s surface, forming the dense, salt-rich bottom layer. This lower layer is anoxic, meaning it is devoid of oxygen, making it unsuitable for oxygen-dependent life but ideal for anaerobic bacteria that thrived before the Great Oxygen Catastrophe.
The flow from the sublacustrine springs creates microenvironments that support large aggregates of microorganisms, which emerge from the lakebed in unusual shapes. Various anaerobic microorganisms absorb the water’s sulfate and release toxic sulfide. At the boundary of these layers, there exists a thin layer primarily composed of pink-bodied Chromatium okenii, a photosynthesizing bacterium that utilizes sulfur similarly to how most plants use oxygen.
While there is no movement of water or organisms between the layers, these ecosystems are not entirely isolated. Chromatium okenii inhabit the top of the bottom layer to maximize their exposure to sunlight. Although they do not enter the oxygenated waters, they are close enough for organisms like zooplankton to dive down, consume them, and return to the upper layer. This interaction forms the foundation of the upper layer’s food chain, supporting the lake’s renowned fish population.
This unique ecology is not only beneficial for Cadagno’s fishermen but also provides scientists with the opportunity to study an isolated anaerobic ecosystem, allowing them to model conditions from the time before the Great Oxygen Catastrophe. For instance, when Chromatium okenii form their layer, they increase the density of that thin layer of water. As the water sinks, these microorganisms must swim back up, resulting in a slight mixing of water known as bioconvection. This ancient phenomenon may offer clues about how early life evolved the ability to swim, among other insights awaiting researchers exploring Cadagno’s enigmatic depths.
—
This version maintains the core information while ensuring clarity and appropriateness.
Oxygen – A chemical element that is essential for the respiration of most living organisms and is a critical component of the Earth’s atmosphere. – Oxygen is released into the atmosphere as a byproduct of photosynthesis in plants.
Microorganisms – Microscopic organisms, such as bacteria, viruses, and fungi, that can exist as single cells or in a colony of cells. – Microorganisms play a crucial role in decomposing organic matter in ecosystems.
Anaerobic – Referring to processes or organisms that do not require oxygen for growth and can even be inhibited or killed by its presence. – Anaerobic bacteria are often found in environments like deep soil layers or the intestines of animals.
Meromictic – Describing a type of lake or body of water in which layers of water do not mix, often due to differences in temperature or salinity. – The meromictic lake has a distinct layer of water that remains undisturbed, preserving ancient microorganisms.
Ecosystem – A biological community of interacting organisms and their physical environment. – The rainforest ecosystem is incredibly diverse, hosting thousands of plant and animal species.
Sulfate – A salt or ester of sulfuric acid, containing the anion SO₄²⁻, commonly found in natural waters and soils. – Sulfate-reducing bacteria can convert sulfate into hydrogen sulfide in anaerobic conditions.
Bacteria – Single-celled microorganisms that can exist either as independent organisms or as parasites, some of which can cause disease. – Bacteria in the soil are essential for nutrient cycling and the decomposition of organic matter.
Photosynthesis – The process by which green plants and some other organisms use sunlight to synthesize foods with the aid of chlorophyll. – Photosynthesis is the primary source of energy for nearly all ecosystems on Earth.
Interactions – The various ways in which organisms affect each other and their environment, including competition, predation, and symbiosis. – The interactions between predators and prey can significantly influence the structure of an ecosystem.
Food Chain – A hierarchical series of organisms each dependent on the next as a source of food. – In a simple food chain, grass is eaten by rabbits, which are then preyed upon by foxes.
