Welcome to an exciting journey at the Field Museum, where we explore the fascinating world of shoes with Alaka Wali, the curator of North American anthropology. Today, we’re diving into how shoes can tell us a lot about different cultures and their unique ways of life.
Let’s start with reef shoes. These were created by people living in the Pacific Islands. But why would someone need special shoes for reefs? Well, these shoes are perfect for fishermen who walk on coral reefs to catch fish or other marine life. They’re not your everyday shoes, but they serve a very specific purpose.
Now, let’s compare reef shoes to snowshoes. As the name suggests, snowshoes are designed for walking on snow. Both types of shoes show incredible creativity and craftsmanship. People had to think carefully about the materials and design to make them work in their environments.
Next, we have sandals. It’s amazing to see that the basic design of sandals hasn’t changed much in 2,000 years! We have ancient Egyptian sandals, modern kids’ sandals from the 1990s, and flip-flops. In hot climates, sandals are perfect, so why change something that works so well?
People everywhere want their kids to look good, and shoes are a big part of that. Some children’s shoes have cute decorations like bows and beads, which are more about fashion than function. This shows how people express pride and identity through clothing and accessories.
Let’s look at shoes from the Cheyenne and Northern regions. Originally, Native Americans didn’t have beads. They traded with Europeans to get them, which changed their way of life. They exchanged fur, like beaver pelts, for beads, which had a big impact on their culture and the environment.
Now, let’s talk about lotus slippers from China. These tiny shoes were worn by women who had their feet bound from a young age. This practice was a sign of wealth because it meant the women didn’t have to work. It’s interesting how beauty standards can vary across cultures and times.
Even today, some high-end shoes are more about showing status than comfort. Wealthy women might buy expensive shoes to show their status, even if they’re not comfortable. It’s a reminder that beauty standards can sometimes be painful!
Some women feel empowered by choosing to wear certain clothes or shoes, even if they follow traditional beauty standards. It’s not just about doing what others say; it’s about feeling confident and making choices for themselves.
Finally, we have shoes from the Ottoman Empire, made in Turkey. These shoes were for people who didn’t have to do manual labor, showing high status. In contrast, we have shoes donated by Michael Jordan, a sports legend. His shoes represent a different kind of status, earned through talent and hard work.
It’s incredible how much we can learn about cultures and history just by looking at shoes. They tell stories of creativity, status, and identity across the world.
Thanks for joining us on this exploration of shoes and culture. We hope you enjoyed this journey and learned something new. Stay tuned for more exciting discoveries in the future!
Imagine you are a shoe designer from a specific culture. Design a shoe that reflects the unique environment, needs, and traditions of that culture. Use materials and styles that would be available to that culture. Present your design to the class and explain your choices.
Choose a type of shoe from the article and write a short story from the perspective of someone who wears them. Describe their daily life, the challenges they face, and how their shoes help them. Share your story with a partner and discuss how shoes can reflect cultural identity.
Participate in a simulation where you trade goods like beads and fur, similar to the Native American trade with Europeans. Use this activity to understand the impact of trade on culture and environment. Reflect on how trade can change cultural practices and lifestyles.
Engage in a class debate about the importance of fashion versus function in shoes. Use examples from the article, such as children’s shoes with decorations or high-end shoes for status. Discuss how these choices reflect cultural values and personal identity.
Create a timeline that shows the evolution of a specific type of shoe, such as sandals or snowshoes, over time. Include images and descriptions of how the design has changed and why. Present your timeline to the class to highlight the historical and cultural significance of footwear.
Here’s a sanitized version of the transcript:
—
We are back here at the Field Museum with Alaka Wali, who is the curator of North American anthropology, and today we’re talking about shoes!
**E:** Why are we talking about shoes? We thought that shoes would be a good way to discuss cultural similarities and differences. For the first pair we’re discussing today, we have a pair of reef shoes. What would these have been used for?
**A:** These were invented by people in the Pacific Islands as a way of walking on reefs.
**E:** Why would someone be walking on coral reefs?
**A:** Well, they’re looking for fish to spear or marine life; they’re generally fishermen. So, you wouldn’t wear these just hanging around town.
**E:** They serve a very specific function.
**A:** Right. They serve a very specific function. We’re contrasting them with the snowshoe, which also has a specific function. I think the name gives it away. (laughs)
**E:** There’s so much ingenuity in it.
**A:** Exactly.
**E:** And so much craftsmanship.
**A:** Right. To gather all the materials, design it, and create something that actually functions—
**A:** Right. And that’s also true about the reef shoes because people had to think about the materials and how to make them. This shows that wherever people are, they are creative and try to figure out the best way to make what they need for their environment.
**E:** So, what are we looking at here?
**A:** I think it’s pretty obvious that these are all sandals. What’s interesting is that the form really hasn’t changed in 2,000 years. These are Egyptian sandals, 2,000 years old, from our collection. These are kids’ sandals made probably in the 1990s, and then flip-flops. When you think about it, if we’re talking about shoes for hot weather climates, this is the shoe. Why would you change the form if it suits the function? How much variation could you have on a theme?
**E:** Exactly.
**A:** So these are all children’s shoes. No matter where, people want their kids to look good. (laughs) Look at these with the cute little bows and beads. This is not useful. I mean, imagine a kid walking in these. That’s just for fashion.
**E:** Right.
**A:** There is a common concern among people in many cultures around status, pride, and identity. Showing that off in your children through adornment or accessorizing clothes—
**E:** And embellishments. The level of detail that is put into these—
**A:** Right. This is Cheyenne, from the Southern Plains, and this is from the Northern region. Initially, they didn’t have access to beads. Beads came from Europe. When Native peoples started trading for beads, it had a big impact on their local way of life. They traded fur for many things, including beaver pelts, which were used by Europeans to make felt hats. This led to significant overkilling of animals driven by the fur trade. There’s a history there.
**E:** There are many implications about these shoes beyond just status and creativity.
**A:** Yes, while we’re discussing shoes and their implications, what are we looking at here? It’s about standards of beauty determined by men, which can vary from culture to culture. These are called lotus slippers, and from a young age, a woman’s feet would be bound tightly to fit into these. For size comparison, these are as large as my hand.
**E:** Right.
**A:** To be in a family where feet were bound—because not all women in China had their feet bound—only wealthy women could do it because the consequence was you couldn’t walk. This indicates wealth, as you were wealthy enough not to have to work. It’s ironic because, on one hand, you were wealthy, but on the other hand, you endured a lot of pain.
**E:** That’s not so different from these.
**A:** Exactly. Before we start criticizing the Chinese, think about modern high-end shoes that can cost a lot. Wealthy women buy these shoes to show their status, but they are also painful. (laughs) I could never wear these. I think I own one pair of heels and regret wearing them.
**E:** You’re putting yourself through a lot of pain to meet a standard of beauty determined by men.
**A:** Let me ask you this. I know many self-confident, empowered women, and their decision to wear clothes like this and uphold traditional beauty standards gives them confidence and empowerment. Is there room for both?
**A:** That’s a really good question and highlights the complexity of human behavior. It’s not just about doing something because a man says to; it’s also about knowing they can sometimes flip that narrative. They can wear the shoes and still feel empowered.
**E:** Absolutely.
**A:** In the case of Chinese women, it didn’t mean they were just following men’s orders. They exerted power too. Just because times are tough or someone else is making the rules, people find ways to subvert or overcome those rules and act on their own behalf.
**E:** This is our last comparison of the day, but it might be one of the more dramatic.
**A:** Totally.
**E:** So what are these?
**A:** Well, these are shoes, maybe sandals, from the Ottoman Empire, made in Turkey. Clearly, they were meant to show high status and prestige. This is for someone who doesn’t have to walk.
**E:** Right.
**A:** They don’t have to work, or they can work primarily with words and directions. No manual labor happens in these shoes. But then we’re comparing them to these. These are my favorite. These are shoes that Michael Jordan himself donated to the Field Museum for our exhibition.
**E:** That’s amazing!
**A:** Michael Jordan is a major figure in sports history and in the Chicago region. The reason for wanting to display these compared to the impractical shoes of a Turkish diplomat is that status and celebrity exist in many cultures, especially where there are class or economic differences. Showing off your status is important, but there are differences.
**E:** Right.
**A:** In Michael Jordan’s case, he attained his celebrity status by being the best athlete in the world. He and the Chicago Bulls changed the image of Chicago. Before the Jordan era, if you said you were from Chicago, people would associate it with gangsters. After Michael Jordan, they would think of him instead. That’s pretty impactful.
**E:** It’s interesting how we can have all these thoughts and ideas based on footwear.
**A:** Absolutely.
**E:** Thanks for watching this episode of The Brain Scoop! This will be our last episode for the year, and I want to thank everyone who responded to our survey. We received a lot of great feedback, and we’ll take that to heart. Stay tuned for more episodes in the new year. Have a great break!
**A:** The Brain Scoop is made possible by the Field Museum and the Harris Family Foundation.
—
This version maintains the essence of the discussion while removing any informal language and laughter for a more professional tone.
Culture – The shared beliefs, customs, practices, and social behavior of a particular nation or group of people. – Example sentence: The culture of the indigenous tribe includes unique dances and storytelling traditions.
Shoes – Footwear that can reflect cultural identity and social status in different societies. – Example sentence: In some cultures, the style and material of shoes can indicate a person’s social status.
Status – A person’s social or professional position in relation to others, often influenced by cultural factors. – Example sentence: In many societies, owning a large house is a symbol of high status.
Identity – The qualities, beliefs, and expressions that make a person or group different from others. – Example sentence: Traditional clothing can be an important part of cultural identity for many people.
Fashion – A popular trend, especially in styles of dress and ornament, that can vary greatly across cultures. – Example sentence: Fashion in Paris is often seen as a reflection of the city’s rich cultural history.
Trade – The exchange of goods and services, which can lead to cultural interactions and influences. – Example sentence: The Silk Road was an ancient trade route that connected different cultures and facilitated the exchange of goods and ideas.
Empowerment – The process of becoming stronger and more confident, often in controlling one’s life and claiming one’s rights. – Example sentence: Education can be a powerful tool for the empowerment of young people in any culture.
Craftsmanship – The skill and art of making things by hand, often reflecting cultural traditions and values. – Example sentence: The craftsmanship of the handmade pottery is a testament to the artisan’s cultural heritage.
Design – The creation of a plan or convention for the construction of an object or a system, often influenced by cultural aesthetics. – Example sentence: The design of the building incorporates elements from traditional Japanese architecture.
Anthropology – The study of human societies, cultures, and their development. – Example sentence: Anthropology helps us understand how different cultures have evolved over time.
