In today’s digital age, social media platforms have become a go-to source for many seeking updates during breaking news or emergencies. However, these platforms are not always the most reliable for factual news or information. I’m Renee DiResta, the technical research manager at Stanford Internet Observatory, where we explore how narratives and information spread online. Often, your phone will buzz with alerts about significant breaking news, featuring headlines crafted to grab your attention rather than provide a comprehensive understanding of the situation.
My name is David Barstow, and I bring 33 years of experience as a reporter and journalist. Currently, I teach investigative reporting at the University of California, Berkeley Graduate School of Journalism. It’s common to see topics trending due to breaking news, and clicking on these trends often leads to information being disseminated faster than traditional news outlets can manage. While this speed can be engaging, it also poses challenges in distinguishing the most critical stories from the surrounding noise.
Understanding the difference between misinformation and disinformation is crucial. Misinformation refers to incorrect information shared without harmful intent, whereas disinformation involves deliberate attempts to mislead. Social media influencers and others with specific agendas, particularly in politics, often spread misleading content. This can create confusion, making it difficult for people to discern the truth amidst competing narratives.
One common issue is that individuals may not remember where they encountered certain information, which can be problematic. The central question is whether we will organize ourselves around facts and truth or around misleading information and propaganda. The desire to be the first to know can lead to the spread of low-quality content, as some individuals seek to gain influence on social media without regard for accuracy.
To effectively navigate the social media landscape, especially during election seasons, consider these four key tips:
Avoid rushing to judgment. Allow stories to develop over time and revisit them later to gain a fuller understanding of the situation.
Think before sharing. Even if you have a small following, your posts can reach a wide audience. Take a moment to consider the validity of the information you are about to share.
Headlines are often crafted to attract attention and may not accurately reflect the content of the article. Sharing misleading information can contribute to confusion.
Assess the credibility of the information you encounter. As a journalist, evaluating sources is crucial. Reflect on whether the source has earned your trust.
By following these guidelines, you can become a more discerning consumer of news and help mitigate the spread of misinformation and disinformation on social media.
Choose a recent breaking news event that gained traction on social media. Analyze how the story was reported across different platforms. Identify instances of misinformation or disinformation and discuss the impact of these inaccuracies on public perception.
Participate in a role-playing debate where you take on the roles of journalists, social media influencers, and fact-checkers. Discuss the responsibilities each role has in ensuring accurate information dissemination during breaking news events.
Develop a comprehensive guide for fact-checking news on social media. Include strategies for verifying sources, recognizing sensationalism, and identifying credible information. Share your guide with peers to promote responsible social media usage.
Conduct a case study analysis on a past instance of misinformation or disinformation that spread on social media. Examine the origins, spread, and consequences of the false information. Discuss lessons learned and propose solutions to prevent similar occurrences.
Attend an interactive workshop focused on evaluating the credibility of news sources. Engage in activities that challenge you to assess the trustworthiness of various sources and practice applying these skills to real-world scenarios.
Here’s a sanitized version of the provided YouTube transcript:
—
Social media platforms are not always the best sources for factual news or information. However, during breaking news or emergencies, many people turn to social media for updates. I’m Renee DiResta, the technical research manager at Stanford Internet Observatory, where we study how narratives and information spread online. Often, your phone will alert you to significant breaking news, with headlines designed to capture your attention rather than provide a nuanced understanding of the situation.
My name is David Barstow, and I have been a reporter and journalist for 33 years. I currently teach investigative reporting at the University of California, Berkeley Graduate School of Journalism. There are many instances when something is trending due to breaking news. Clicking on these trends often leads to information being released faster than it appears on traditional news outlets. This speed can draw people in, but it also presents challenges in distinguishing the most important stories from the noise.
Misinformation and disinformation differ primarily in intent. Misinformation refers to incorrect information shared without harmful intent, while disinformation involves deliberate attempts to mislead. There are numerous examples of misleading content propagated by social media influencers and others with specific agendas, particularly in politics. This can create confusion, as people may struggle to discern the truth amidst competing narratives.
Often, individuals may not remember where they encountered certain information, which can be problematic. The key issue is whether we will organize ourselves around facts and truth or around misleading information and propaganda. The desire to be the first to know can lead to the spread of low-quality content, as some individuals seek to gain influence on social media without regard for accuracy.
To navigate this environment, here are four key tips, especially relevant during election seasons:
1. **Be Patient**: Avoid rushing to judgment. Allow stories to develop and revisit them later to gain a fuller understanding of the situation.
2. **Be Responsible on Social Media**: Think before sharing. Even if you have a small following, your posts can reach a wide audience. Take a moment to consider the validity of the information.
3. **Be Skeptical of Sensationalism**: Headlines are often crafted to attract attention and may not accurately reflect the content of the article. Sharing misleading information can contribute to confusion.
4. **Consider the Source**: Assess the credibility of the information you encounter. As a journalist, evaluating sources is crucial. Reflect on whether the source has earned your trust.
—
This version maintains the core ideas while removing any informal language and ensuring clarity.
Social Media – Platforms and tools that allow individuals to create, share, and exchange information and ideas in virtual communities and networks. – Social media has become a powerful tool in shaping public opinion and influencing political discourse.
Misinformation – False or inaccurate information that is spread, regardless of intent to deceive. – The rapid spread of misinformation on social media can lead to widespread public misunderstanding of critical issues.
Disinformation – Deliberately misleading or biased information, manipulated narrative or facts, or propaganda spread with the intent to deceive. – Disinformation campaigns have been used to manipulate public perception during elections.
Critical Thinking – The objective analysis and evaluation of an issue in order to form a judgment. – University students are encouraged to develop critical thinking skills to assess the credibility of sources.
Credibility – The quality of being trusted and believed in, often applied to sources of information. – Evaluating the credibility of a news source is essential for informed decision-making.
Narratives – Structured accounts or stories that provide a particular perspective or interpretation of events. – Competing narratives in the media can influence public perception of social and political issues.
Journalism – The activity or profession of writing for newspapers, magazines, or news websites or preparing news to be broadcast. – Ethical journalism plays a crucial role in maintaining an informed and engaged citizenry.
Propaganda – Information, especially of a biased or misleading nature, used to promote a political cause or point of view. – During wartime, propaganda is often used to bolster national morale and support for the government.
Elections – Formal and organized processes of selecting individuals for public office or accepting or rejecting political propositions by voting. – Free and fair elections are fundamental to the functioning of a democratic society.
Awareness – Knowledge or perception of a situation or fact, often leading to a heightened understanding of social or political issues. – Increasing public awareness of climate change is essential for driving policy change and sustainable practices.
