Imagine standing next to a crocodile. You probably wouldn’t think about how much you have in common with it. But a fascinating study recently put a crocodile in a brain scanner and played classical music to it. This unusual experiment can actually teach us something interesting about ourselves: when did we first develop the ability to perceive music?
Over time, scientists have learned a lot about how our brains process sound, including music. When you listen to a song, your brain processes it in a step-by-step way. First, it picks up the basic sounds, like the frequency, harmonics, duration, and loudness of the notes. Then, it moves on to more complex tasks, like telling different instruments apart and connecting the sounds with memories you have. Finally, your brain reacts to the music, influencing how you feel or behave.
There’s a link between how our brains are structured and how complex the sounds are. The more complex the sounds, the more advanced parts of the brain get involved. Interestingly, this isn’t something unique to humans. If you played the same song to a bird, its brain would process the music in a similar way. This is amazing because humans and birds evolved separately hundreds of millions of years ago.
But what if the ability to process music developed even earlier? What if it came from a common ancestor? This is where crocodiles come into the picture. Crocodiles are the oldest surviving relatives of modern birds. If we traveled back in time about 100 million years, we’d see ancient crocodiles that looked quite similar to the ones we see today.
According to George Amato, the Director of Conservation Genomics at the American Museum of Natural History, ancient crocodiles had long snouts, lots of teeth, and could hide underwater with just their nostrils and eyes above the surface. Crocodiles, birds, and humans all share a common ancestor from around 300 million years ago. This ancestor was a simple, thick-limbed reptile that eventually evolved into mammals, dinosaurs, crocodilians, birds, and other reptiles. Studying crocodiles can help us understand if certain traits in our brains have been preserved over time.
In 2018, scientists were able to scan the brains of live reptiles for the first time. Researchers in Germany and South Africa worked together to study how crocodiles respond to sound, including music. They placed five young Nile Crocodiles in an fMRI machine and played different sounds to them: simple chord noises and complex music like Bach’s Brandenburg Concerto No. 4, which had been used in studies with birds before.
The study found that simple sounds activated the basic sensory areas of the crocodiles’ brains, while complex music activated additional regions. This means that crocodiles process sound and music in a hierarchical way, just like humans and birds do.
It’s been a long time since crocodiles, humans, and birds branched off on the evolutionary tree. Your brain’s ability to process music, from simple tones to complex sounds, likely emerged at least 300 million years ago. Despite this shared ability, you, an ancient giant crocodile, and a songbird probably have different tastes in music!
Imagine you’re a scientist studying how different creatures perceive music. Create a sound map by drawing a diagram that shows how sound travels from the environment to the brain. Label each part of the process, from the ear to the brain, and describe what happens at each stage. This will help you understand how complex sounds are processed in both humans and animals.
Choose a piece of music and listen to it carefully. Write down how it makes you feel and any memories it brings up. Then, ask a family member or friend to do the same. Compare your responses and discuss why you think the music affected you differently. This activity will help you explore the emotional impact of music and how it connects to personal experiences.
Create a timeline that traces the evolution of the ability to perceive music. Start from the common ancestor of crocodiles, birds, and humans, and highlight key evolutionary milestones. Include illustrations or images to make your timeline visually engaging. This will help you understand the long history of musical perception across different species.
Using online resources or apps, simulate how different sounds activate various parts of the brain. Experiment with simple sounds versus complex music and observe the differences in brain activity. This will give you a hands-on understanding of how sound complexity influences brain processing.
Listen to a piece of classical music and a modern song. Analyze the elements of each, such as rhythm, melody, and harmony. Discuss how these elements might be processed similarly or differently by the brains of humans, birds, and crocodiles. This will help you appreciate the universal and unique aspects of musical perception.
Sure! Here’s a sanitized version of the transcript:
—
“You know, if you happen to be standing next to a crocodile, your first thought probably isn’t how similar you are to the crocodile. Recently, I came across a study that put a crocodile in a brain scanner and played it classical music. I was intrigued! It turns out that this unusual intersection of crocodiles and technology can teach us something interesting about ourselves. Like, when did we first develop the ability to perceive music?
[BrainCraft intro]
Over the years, we’ve learned how our brains process sound, including tones and music. For example, listen to this song. As you hear it, you process sound in a hierarchical way. First, you register the basic acoustic building blocks like frequency, harmonics, duration, and loudness of notes. Next are the more complicated elements, like differentiating instruments and linking the sounds with stored memories. Finally, there are the most complex responses, like your behavioral reaction to the sound.
There’s a relationship between brain structure and sound complexity – the more complex the sounds get, the more high-order brain areas activate. But this isn’t unique to humans. If I played this song to a bird, we’d see similar processing in their brain too. You and a songbird process music in a remarkably similar way, which is fascinating considering we branched off from each other hundreds of millions of years ago, evolving down separate paths.
But what if the ability to process music developed even earlier? What if it came from a common ancestor? This is where the crocodile comes in. Crocodiles are the oldest surviving relatives of modern birds. Ancient crocodiles looked quite similar to the ones we know today. If we took a quick trip back in time, say 100 million years, we would see a form of crocodile that resembles today’s species.
This is George Amato, the Director of Conservation Genomics for the American Museum of Natural History. While they wouldn’t look exactly the same as modern crocodiles, they would have had an elongated snout, lots of teeth, and the ability to be hidden underwater, with most of their body submerged, just their nostrils and eyes above the surface.
Crocodiles, birds, and humans all shared a common ancestor around 300 million years ago. This ancestor was a generic-looking, thick-limbed reptile that eventually gave rise to mammals, dinosaurs, crocodilians, birds, and other reptiles. This makes them a valuable example to study if certain traits in our brains have been conserved over time.
In 2018, science advanced enough to allow us to scan the brains of live reptiles. Researchers in Germany and South Africa collaborated to study how crocodiles respond to sound – both tones and music. Five young Nile Crocodiles were placed in an fMRI machine and exposed to different auditory stimuli: simple chord noises and then complex sounds, like Bach’s Brandenburg Concerto No. 4, which has been used in previous studies with birds.
The researchers found that simple tones activated their basic sensory areas, while complex sounds like music activated additional regions. So, crocodiles process sound and music in a hierarchical way, just like humans and birds.
It’s been a long time since crocodiles, humans, and birds branched off on the evolutionary tree. Your brain’s ability to process music from simple tones and decipher complex sounds likely emerged at least 300 million years ago. Still, despite this commonality, you, an ancient giant crocodile, and a songbird probably have different tastes in music.”
—
This version maintains the essence of the original transcript while removing any informal language or expressions.
Music – A form of sound organized in time, often used to express emotions and can affect the brain’s activity. – Listening to music can help improve concentration and reduce stress by influencing brain waves.
Brain – The organ in the head of animals, including humans, responsible for thought, memory, emotion, and sensory processing. – The brain processes information from our senses, allowing us to understand and react to the world around us.
Sound – Vibrations that travel through the air or another medium and can be heard when they reach a person’s or animal’s ear. – The sound of a bird singing can trigger memories and emotions in the human brain.
Crocodile – A large aquatic reptile with a long snout, known for its powerful bite and ancient lineage. – Crocodiles have been around for millions of years, surviving many changes in their environment through evolution.
Birds – Warm-blooded vertebrates with feathers, wings, and beaks, known for their ability to fly. – Birds are believed to have evolved from dinosaur ancestors, showcasing the power of evolution.
Ancestor – An early form of an organism from which later forms descend, often used to describe evolutionary history. – Humans and chimpanzees share a common ancestor, which explains some similarities in our DNA.
Process – A series of actions or steps taken to achieve a particular end, often used to describe biological or psychological functions. – Photosynthesis is the process by which plants convert sunlight into energy.
Complex – Consisting of many different and connected parts, often used to describe systems in biology and psychology. – The human brain is a complex organ, capable of processing vast amounts of information simultaneously.
Evolution – The gradual development of organisms over time through changes in heritable traits. – Evolution explains how species adapt to their environments and can lead to the emergence of new species.
Emotions – Psychological states that arise spontaneously rather than through conscious effort, often accompanied by physiological changes. – Emotions like happiness and fear are processed in the brain and can influence our behavior and decision-making.
