The biggest mistakes in mapmaking history – Kayla Wolf

Alphabets Sounds Video

share us on:

The lesson “Exploring the Evolution of World Maps: From Dragons to Discoveries” examines the historical development of world maps from the medieval period to the mid-17th century, highlighting the blend of myth and geography in cartography. It discusses the dual nature of ancient maps—functional and cosmographical—and emphasizes the contributions of Islamic and Chinese cartographers, who prioritized accuracy over fantastical elements. Despite advancements in mapping, the allure of mythical creatures persisted, reflecting a tension between exploration and the realities of indigenous cultures that were often overlooked by European mapmakers.

Exploring the Evolution of World Maps: From Dragons to Discoveries

In the early 1500s, a small copper globe marked the coast of Southeast Asia with the phrase “Here be dragons.” Although these words were rarely used, the sentiment was common among medieval European mapmakers, who often adorned uncharted territories with illustrations of dragons and sea monsters. These mythical creatures symbolized the unknown, filling the blank spaces on maps with imaginative depictions.

The Dual Nature of Ancient Maps

For millennia, people worldwide created two main types of maps: functional maps and cosmographies. Functional maps detailed trade routes, settlements, topography, water sources, and coastlines, serving practical purposes. In contrast, cosmographies illustrated the Earth’s position in the cosmos, often featuring constellations, deities, and mythical locations.

From the Middle Ages to the mid-17th century, cartographers in Eurasia and North Africa produced numerous world maps that combined elements from both traditions. These maps, often commissioned by rulers and influential figures, aimed to depict the world’s geography, though not necessarily for navigation. Given the limited knowledge of the world at the time, these maps were speculative, with some hypotheses later proven incorrect.

The Rise of Mappae Mundi and Islamic Cartography

In medieval Europe, the creation of mappae mundi marked a new trend. These maps leaned towards cosmographies, featuring mythical elements like the Garden of Eden and dragons. They typically depicted the world as a single landmass shaped like a “T” and encircled by an ocean.

Islamic mapmakers also contributed significantly to world mapping, emphasizing geographic accuracy over fantastical elements. One of the earliest and most precise maps was crafted by Ibn Hawqal, whose travels informed his work. In 1154, the King of Sicily commissioned Al-Idrisi, an Islamic mapmaker, to create the “Tabula Rogeriana,” a comprehensive guide to distant lands. This collection of maps, based on Idrisi’s travels and interviews with traders, accurately portrayed the world as a flattened sphere, albeit with some misconceptions about the continents’ arrangement.

Chinese Cartography and European Expansion

In 1389, Chinese cartographers created the “Da Ming Hunyi Tu” on a large silk canvas. Although they had never visited Africa, they relied on traders’ accounts to depict the continent, resulting in a surprisingly accurate representation of sub-Saharan Africa.

Starting in the 15th century, European cartographers expanded their world maps as explorers ventured further afield. However, this expansion was not without errors. In 1507, German cartographer Martin Waldseemüller mapped the Americas as a thin strip of land along the east coast. Spanish cartographers, influenced by expeditions to the Baja Peninsula, mistakenly depicted California as an island for over a century.

Mythical Elements and the Quest for Accuracy

Flemish cartographer Gerardus Mercator, renowned for his world map, also created a speculative map of the North Pole in 1595. He imagined the North Pole featuring the “Rupes Nigra,” a giant magnetic rock surrounded by a whirlpool, explaining why compasses pointed north.

Despite European efforts to create a complete picture of the Earth, the allure of mythical beasts in uncharted territories persisted. As late as 1657, English scholar Peter Heylin grouped Australia with fictional places like Utopia and Fairyland. However, these so-called terra incognita were not truly unknown to the indigenous peoples who inhabited them. While dragons never roamed the Earth, diverse cultures thrived in these lands, many of which were later disrupted by those who mapped their territories.

  1. How did the use of mythical creatures on ancient maps reflect the mapmakers’ understanding and perception of the world during that time?
  2. In what ways did the dual nature of ancient maps, combining functional and cosmographic elements, influence the way people viewed their place in the world?
  3. What can the evolution of mappae mundi and Islamic cartography tell us about the cultural and scientific exchanges between different regions during the medieval period?
  4. How did the inaccuracies in early European maps, such as the depiction of California as an island, impact exploration and colonization efforts?
  5. What role did traders and travelers play in shaping the accuracy of world maps in different cultures, such as in Chinese cartography?
  6. How did the persistence of mythical elements in maps, even as geographic knowledge improved, reflect the tension between imagination and scientific inquiry?
  7. In what ways did the mapping of terra incognita affect the indigenous cultures that inhabited these regions, and how is this reflected in modern cartography?
  8. Reflecting on the article, what insights have you gained about the historical development of cartography and its impact on our current understanding of the world?
  1. Create Your Own Medieval Map

    Imagine you are a medieval cartographer. Draw a map of an imaginary land, including both functional elements like trade routes and settlements, and cosmographic elements such as mythical creatures and deities. Use your creativity to fill in the unknown areas with imaginative depictions.

  2. Map Comparison Project

    Research different historical maps mentioned in the article, such as the mappae mundi, the “Tabula Rogeriana,” and the “Da Ming Hunyi Tu.” Create a presentation comparing these maps, focusing on their accuracy, the inclusion of mythical elements, and their purposes. Discuss how these maps reflect the knowledge and beliefs of their time.

  3. Interactive Timeline of Cartography

    Create an interactive timeline that traces the evolution of world maps from the early 1500s to the 17th century. Include key events, such as the creation of the “Tabula Rogeriana” and the mapping of the Americas by Martin Waldseemüller. Add images and descriptions to make the timeline engaging and informative.

  4. Mythical Creatures Research

    Choose a mythical creature that was commonly depicted on medieval maps, such as dragons or sea monsters. Research the origins and cultural significance of this creature. Create a report or a poster that includes illustrations, stories, and how these creatures were used to represent the unknown on maps.

  5. Mapmaking Workshop

    Participate in a hands-on workshop where you learn the basics of cartography. Use tools like compasses and rulers to create a simple map of your school or neighborhood. Discuss how modern mapmaking techniques differ from those used in the past and how accuracy has improved over time.

MapsMaps are visual representations of an area that show the relationships between different elements, such as landforms, roads, and cities. – A map of the world can help you understand where different countries are located.

GeographyGeography is the study of the Earth’s landscapes, environments, and the relationships between people and their environments. – Learning geography helps us understand how different cultures interact with their surroundings.

CartographyCartography is the art and science of making maps. – The cartography of ancient civilizations shows how they viewed their world and what was important to them.

DragonsDragons are mythical creatures often depicted in folklore and stories, sometimes associated with different cultures around the world. – In many European legends, dragons are portrayed as fierce guardians of treasure.

EuropeEurope is a continent located entirely in the Northern Hemisphere and mostly in the Eastern Hemisphere, known for its diverse cultures and histories. – Europe is home to many famous landmarks, such as the Eiffel Tower and the Colosseum.

AsiaAsia is the largest continent on Earth, known for its vast landscapes, diverse cultures, and significant historical events. – Asia is where some of the world’s oldest civilizations, like China and India, began.

IslamicIslamic refers to anything related to Islam, a major world religion that began in the 7th century in the Arabian Peninsula. – The Islamic Golden Age was a period of great cultural, economic, and scientific advancements.

TradeTrade is the exchange of goods and services between people or countries. – The Silk Road was an important trade route that connected Asia and Europe, allowing for the exchange of silk, spices, and ideas.

ContinentsContinents are large landmasses on Earth, typically classified into seven main areas: Africa, Antarctica, Asia, Europe, North America, Australia, and South America. – Understanding the continents helps us learn about the different cultures and environments around the world.

ExplorationExploration is the act of traveling through an unfamiliar area to learn about it. – The Age of Exploration saw many explorers, like Christopher Columbus, sailing to new lands and discovering new cultures.

All Video Lessons

Login your account

Please login your account to get started.

Don't have an account?

Register your account

Please sign up your account to get started.

Already have an account?