The Bizarre Physics of Electric Guitars

Alphabets Sounds Video

share us on:

The lesson discusses the controversial magnetic guitar pick, which claims to allow guitar playing without touching the strings. While it does not function as advertised—failing to directly move the strings—it interacts with the guitar’s pickups to modulate sound, creating unique effects. Despite its high price and the confusion surrounding its operation, the pick offers creative possibilities for musicians when used correctly.

The Magnetic Guitar Pick: A Controversial Innovation

Recently, a new guitar pick has stirred up quite a debate online. The creators claim it allows you to play the guitar without actually touching the strings. Critics, however, argue that it’s a hoax. But is it really possible to play a guitar this way? Well, yes, using a device called an Ebow, which uses magnetic fields to interact with the strings. This new pick is essentially a strong magnet shaped like a guitar pick. The big question is: does it work, and if so, how well?

Testing the Magnetic Pick

After trying out the pick in a guitar store, it became clear that it doesn’t generate sound from the strings without touching them. Instead, it interacts with the guitar’s pickups, which are magnetic, to modulate the sound. This means it can make the string sound quieter but not louder. If the strings are already vibrating, the pick might have some musical function.

When tested with a guitar, the pick affected the pickup but didn’t move the strings. The left hand creates vibrations, and the right hand modulates the sound. It might look like the pick is doing the work, but it’s actually the left hand hitting the strings.

How Electric Guitars Work

Electric guitars use pickups to capture the signal. These pickups convert the physical vibrations of the strings into an electrical signal. The pickups contain a coil of wire and magnets. When a magnetic string vibrates, it generates small electric currents in the wire. These currents are amplified to produce sound. The strings themselves aren’t magnetic but can become magnetized when exposed to a magnetic field, like the one created by the magnets in the pickups.

Any magnet moving near the pickups can generate electrical currents, which is what happens with the magnetic pick. It’s essentially just a magnet interacting with the guitar’s pickups.

Does the Magnetic Pick Work?

The magnetic pick doesn’t work as advertised. It doesn’t move the strings but does create the effects shown in promotional materials. The pick generates a loud, low-frequency signal pulse that, through signal processing, achieves the desired musical effects. Many people don’t understand how it works, leading to debates about its legitimacy.

While it may seem overpriced for what it is—a magnet shaped like a pick—the creators have invested significant time in developing techniques and effects that make it work. This intellectual effort is part of what you’re paying for.

Final Thoughts

The magnetic pick is poorly explained by its creators, causing confusion and misuse. However, it does achieve the effects it claims to, offering new creative possibilities for musicians. The physics behind it is simple, but the human understanding is complex.

In conclusion, while the magnetic pick doesn’t move the strings, it does interact with the pickups to create unique sounds. It’s a tool that, when used correctly, can expand musical expression. The world of electric guitars often involves post-processing effects, and this pick is no exception.

  1. What are your initial thoughts on the concept of a magnetic guitar pick, and how do you think it could impact traditional guitar playing techniques?
  2. Reflecting on the article, what do you believe are the main reasons for the controversy surrounding the magnetic guitar pick?
  3. How does the explanation of how electric guitars work help you understand the function and limitations of the magnetic pick?
  4. In what ways do you think the magnetic pick could be used creatively by musicians, despite its limitations?
  5. Considering the article’s discussion on the magnetic pick’s effectiveness, what are your thoughts on the importance of marketing and clear communication in product innovation?
  6. How do you feel about the balance between the intellectual effort invested in developing the magnetic pick and its perceived value as a simple magnet?
  7. What insights did you gain about the role of post-processing effects in electric guitar music from reading the article?
  8. After learning about the magnetic pick, how do you think it might influence future innovations in musical instruments or accessories?
  1. Experiment with Magnetic Fields

    Gather some magnets and a coil of wire to create a simple demonstration of how magnetic fields can generate electric currents. Try moving the magnets near the wire and observe the effects. This will help you understand the basic principle behind how the magnetic guitar pick interacts with the pickups.

  2. Build a Simple Electric Guitar Model

    Create a basic model of an electric guitar using cardboard, rubber bands, and a small magnet. Use this model to demonstrate how vibrations are converted into electrical signals. This hands-on activity will reinforce your understanding of how electric guitars work.

  3. Debate the Pros and Cons of the Magnetic Pick

    Form two groups and hold a debate on the effectiveness and value of the magnetic guitar pick. One group will argue in favor of its innovative potential, while the other will critique its practicality and cost. This will help you develop critical thinking and public speaking skills.

  4. Create a Marketing Campaign

    Design a marketing campaign for the magnetic guitar pick, focusing on its unique features and potential uses. Consider how you would address the criticisms and misconceptions about the product. This activity will enhance your creativity and marketing skills.

  5. Analyze Sound Waves and Frequencies

    Use a sound analysis app to visualize the sound waves produced by a guitar with and without the magnetic pick. Compare the frequencies and amplitudes to see how the pick affects the sound. This will deepen your understanding of sound modulation and signal processing.

MagneticRelating to or exhibiting magnetism, which is the force exerted by magnets when they attract or repel each other. – The magnetic field around a guitar pickup is crucial for converting string vibrations into electrical signals.

GuitarA stringed musical instrument that typically has six strings and is played by strumming or plucking. – The electric guitar uses pickups to amplify the sound produced by the strings.

PickupsDevices on electric guitars that capture the vibrations of the strings and convert them into electrical signals. – The quality of the pickups can greatly affect the tone and sound of an electric guitar.

StringsLong, thin pieces of wire or nylon on musical instruments that produce sound when vibrated. – The tension and material of the strings influence the pitch and timbre of the guitar.

VibrationsRapid oscillations of particles in a medium, which can produce sound when they reach the ear. – The vibrations of the guitar strings are transformed into sound waves by the pickups.

SoundA form of energy that is produced by vibrating objects and travels through a medium such as air. – The sound of the electric guitar is amplified through speakers after being processed by the amplifier.

ElectricRelating to or operated by electricity, often used to describe instruments that require electrical amplification. – An electric guitar relies on an amplifier to project its sound to an audience.

CurrentsFlows of electric charge, which can be used to transmit signals in electronic devices. – The electric currents generated by the pickups are shaped by the guitar’s tone controls.

EffectsElectronic devices or software that alter the sound of musical instruments, often used to create unique tones. – Guitarists often use effects like reverb and distortion to enhance their music.

MusicThe art of arranging sounds in time to produce a composition through the elements of melody, harmony, rhythm, and timbre. – The electric guitar has become a staple in many genres of music due to its versatility and range of sounds.

All Video Lessons

Login your account

Please login your account to get started.

Don't have an account?

Register your account

Please sign up your account to get started.

Already have an account?