From the iconic painting “Nighthawks” to the beloved TV show “Seinfeld,” diners in New York City have become a staple of American pop culture. If you live in the U.S., chances are you have a diner that holds a special place in your heart—whether it’s a 24-hour spot where you spent late nights with friends or a cozy family-run establishment where you enjoyed Sunday breakfasts. But where did these chrome and neon eateries come from? Let’s explore the fascinating journey of diners from their humble beginnings as lunch wagons to their modern-day incarnations.
Diners originated as mobile food wagons that catered to workers on the night shift. These were literal wagons, pulled by horses, serving simple meals. While street food vendors have been around for as long as cities have existed, they typically offered limited menus, often featuring items like pies and baked potatoes. The first known nighttime food wagon was launched by Walter Scott in Providence in 1872. Scott’s wagon, repurposed from a horse-drawn vehicle, sold sandwiches, coffee, and pies, and it was so successful that he left his job as a printer. Inspired by Scott, other entrepreneurs in New England adopted the lunch wagon model, creating what were essentially 19th-century food trucks.
Initially, food was prepared on simple stoves or stored in ice boxes and served through a window to customers on the street. Some manufacturers began producing wagons with elaborate designs, featuring fancy lettering and murals, along with overhangs to protect customers from the weather. In 1887, an entrepreneur introduced inside seating, transforming lunch wagons into rolling restaurants. This concept quickly gained popularity, especially as the temperance movement sought alcohol-free dining options.
As lunch wagons grew in popularity, they extended their hours beyond nighttime, competing with traditional restaurants for the morning crowd. This led to conflicts with restaurant and saloon owners, prompting cities to restrict daytime operations. Wagon owners responded by setting up on private property, leading to the evolution of lunch wagons into more permanent lunch cars. By the 1920s, these were known as dining cars, eventually shortened to “diners.”
Diners often featured simple counter seating with stools, designed for quick turnover. One notable manufacturer, Gerry O’Mahoney from New Jersey, shipped dining cars nationwide. O’Mahoney’s stationary dining cars, inspired by railroad cars, played a significant role in popularizing diners. New Jersey became the epicenter of diner manufacturing, producing about 95% of all prefab diners in the 20th century. Many of these diners remain local, earning New Jersey the title of the diner capital of the world, with over 500 active diners today.
Casey’s in Natick, Massachusetts, holds the distinction of being America’s oldest continually operating diner. It began as a lunch wagon in the 1890s, and its current structure was built in 1922 by the Worcester Lunch Car Company. Family-owned for four generations, Casey’s continues to serve breakfast, lunch, and dinner, along with a tempting array of pies.
While lunch wagons started in urban areas, diners flourished in the suburbs. After World War II, many white Americans moved to the suburbs, and diners followed, catering to the family-oriented model of post-war America. Interiors were redesigned to reflect the era’s modern home aesthetic, featuring Formica countertops, porcelain tiles, leather booths, wood paneling, and terrazzo floors. Many diners remained open 24 hours, becoming popular hangouts for teenagers too young to visit bars.
In the 1960s, the rise of chain restaurants posed a threat to diners. However, Greek families helped preserve these establishments. Greek immigrants, drawn by the café culture of their homeland, opened diners in New York City. Many started in the back of the house, working their way up to ownership. Greek diners became known for their extensive menus, offering everything from pancakes to lobster, and their distinctive interior designs featuring chandeliers, faux crystal, and Greek statues.
In the early 21st century, as Greek diner owners retired, newer immigrants from South Korea, Bangladesh, Central America, and other regions took over. However, rising real estate costs have threatened the existence of many diners, with some being replaced by luxury high-rises or chain stores. Despite these challenges, iconic diners like B&H Dairy and Nam Wah Tea Parlor continue to thrive, offering diverse culinary experiences and serving as community hubs.
Diners remain an integral part of American culture, offering a unique blend of history, community, and culinary diversity. If you’re fortunate enough to have a family-run diner in your area, consider supporting them. Whether you’re starting a new tradition or revisiting cherished memories, these institutions deserve to be cherished for generations to come.
Investigate the origins of diners, focusing on the transition from mobile food wagons to stationary dining cars. Prepare a short presentation to share your findings with the class, highlighting key figures like Walter Scott and the impact of the temperance movement.
Organize a visit to a local diner, preferably one with historical significance. Observe its architectural features, menu offerings, and customer demographics. After the visit, write a reflection on how the diner embodies the historical and cultural elements discussed in the article.
Create a menu for a modern diner that incorporates traditional diner fare with contemporary culinary trends. Consider dietary preferences and cultural influences. Present your menu to the class and explain your choices.
Participate in a debate on the future of diners in the face of rising real estate costs and competition from chain restaurants. Argue either for the preservation of traditional diners or for their evolution to meet modern demands. Use examples from the article to support your position.
Watch a documentary or film that features diners prominently, such as “Diner” or “The American Diner Revival.” Discuss how the portrayal of diners in media reflects their cultural significance and evolution over time. Relate these portrayals to the historical context provided in the article.
Here’s a sanitized version of the provided YouTube transcript:
—
From the painting “Nighthawks” to “Seinfeld,” New York City diners are an intrinsic part of American pop culture. If you live in the U.S., you probably have a diner that’s special to you—whether it’s a 24-hour spot where you drank coffee and ate French fries as a teen, or a mom-and-pop shop where your family went for Sunday breakfast, and you always ordered the same thing. Where did these chrome and neon restaurants originate? We’re going to trace diner dining from their lunch wagon ancestors to modern takeout cups and discuss how diner culture might be changing.
Hi, I’m Justin Dodd, and welcome to Food History. Diners began as mobile food wagons that served simple meals to workers on the third shift. They were literal wagons, carts pulled by horses. Although street food vendors have existed as long as cities have, most had simple setups and sold only one kind of food—pies and baked potatoes were popular choices. The first nighttime food wagon, as far as anyone knows, was started by Walter Scott in Providence back in 1872. Scott sold sandwiches, coffee, and pies out of his repurposed horse-drawn wagon. His mini restaurant on wheels was so successful that he quit his day job as a printer. Soon, many other New England entrepreneurs mimicked Scott’s business model, and these businesses were called lunch wagons. They were essentially late 19th-century food trucks that could pull up to multiple businesses in a day.
The food was prepared inside over simple stoves or stored in ice boxes and served out a window to customers on the street. Manufacturers opened up specifically built or retrofitted wagons, decorated with fancy lettering and murals, and had an overhang to keep customers dry or shaded in inclement weather. In 1887, one entrepreneur added inside seating, and the lunch wagons became rolling restaurants. This concept spread quickly, aided by the temperance movement, as lunch wagons provided a zero-proof option for cheap coffee and sandwiches.
Eventually, these wagons became so popular that they extended their hours beyond nighttime, putting them in competition with normal restaurants for the morning rush. Faced with upset restaurateurs and saloon owners, cities that had been fine with nighttime wagons started clamping down on daytime operations. Wagon owners began parking on private property, where they could set up without incurring the wrath of local municipalities. With more or less permanent locations, these night lunch wagons started turning into lunch cars, and in the 1920s, they became known as dining cars, which was eventually shortened to “diners.”
The seating was often a simple counter with stools designed so that customers didn’t stay too long. One manufacturer, Gerry O’Mahoney, based in New Jersey, shipped cars to clients all over the country. O’Mahoney’s dining cars were essentially stationary, and he is sometimes credited with inventing the diner—a pre-fab restaurant inspired by railroad cars. Other companies outfitted decommissioned railroad cars with kitchens and indoor seating. Throughout the 20th century, New Jersey became the leading maker of diners, with about 95 percent of all prefab diners built in the state. Diners were shipped worldwide and could even be sent back to factories for updates and repairs, but many of these buildings stayed local. To this day, New Jersey is known as the diner capital of the world, with more than 500 active diners in the state.
A spot called Casey’s in Natick, Massachusetts, is America’s oldest continually operating diner. It started as a lunch wagon in the 1890s, and the current structure was built in 1922 by the Worcester Lunch Car Company. It has been family-owned for four generations and still serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner, along with a tempting assortment of pies.
While lunch wagons started in cities, diners thrived in the suburbs. Post-World War II, many white Americans left cities for the suburbs, and diners followed them, especially for white men who had served in the military. Government programs made buying a home accessible, and the idealized American dream included a white picket fence and a yard. At the same time, redlining housing policies reinforced segregation, forcing many families of color to stay in urban neighborhoods. Diners were rarely an exception to this divided norm.
Think of the diner’s cousin, the lunch counter, and the role sit-ins played in the Civil Rights Movement. Diners could bridge a socioeconomic divide within racially segregated communities, often occupying a geographic fringe between the city and the suburbs. They catered to factory workers, office professionals, families, and solo diners alike, reflecting their wide-ranging appeal. However, their prevailing racial segregation highlighted the limitations of food as a uniting force.
Once diners arrived in the suburbs, they had to evolve. They no longer served just rough-and-tumble male overnight workers; they needed to fit into the family-oriented model of post-war America. The interiors were redesigned to match the era’s conception of a chic modern home, featuring Formica countertops, porcelain tiles, leather booths, wood paneling, and terrazzo floors. Many diners remained open 24 hours a day to serve their original clientele, but over time, these spaces became a refuge for teenagers—a gathering place for those too young to go to bars.
The diners of the 1950s were made from sleek, modern metal railroad cars. Some were built as freestanding buildings, but they still had shiny stainless steel exteriors, neon signs, and a space-age appearance. Technically, these would be called coffee shops, as the term “diner” referred to factory-built prefab restaurants from dining cars that were shipped to a location. In modern America, “coffee shop” has taken on a different meaning, generally applying to places like Starbucks, while “diner” has become a catch-all name for family-owned, often round-the-clock restaurants.
The American Northeast still has the highest concentration of traditional diners, with about 2,000 spread across New England. However, in the 1960s, the increasing spread of chain restaurants led to a decline in diners. What saved them? If you’ve lived in the New York City area, you might remember that many diners were owned by Greek families. Anarchist poet and Greek-American historian Dan Georgakas theorized that this tradition stemmed from the café culture—a traditional Greek gathering space for men to drink coffee and socialize.
As Greek immigration to New York increased at the turn of the 20th century, these coffee shops opened in Greek neighborhoods. While there may be a thematic connection between these spaces and the Greek diners of the late 20th century, it was a second wave of immigrants, largely arriving after 1965, that made Greek-owned New York diners iconic. Food businesses are one of the most common ways new immigrants begin to build a life in America. According to the National Restaurant Association, in 2016, 29 percent of restaurant and hospitality businesses were immigrant-owned, compared to just 14 percent of all U.S. businesses. A food business doesn’t take a lot of money to start and doesn’t necessarily require complete mastery of English to run.
In the case of Greek diners, new immigrants often started in the back washing dishes and worked their way up from busboy to cook to waiter until they had enough money to buy a diner of their own. The menus and interior design of New York’s Greek diners are considered iconic. The menus can be bafflingly long, encompassing dishes ranging from pancakes to lobster, omelets to spaghetti, and more. As New York Times writer Dina Kleinman noted, one Manhattan diner boasts 220 menu items.
To set each diner apart, owners not only added menu items but also lavish or, depending on your perspective, tacky interior decorations like chandeliers, faux crystal, flowing draperies, Greek statues, fountains, and flashing LED light shows. The graphic design of these spaces has had a cultural impact; the blue and white takeout coffee cups, often printed with “We are happy to serve you,” have become so iconic that a design store sells ceramic versions of this classic cup.
In the early 21st century, Greek diner owners began to retire and sell their businesses to newer generations of immigrants from South Korea, Bangladesh, Central America, and more. However, with the rising cost of real estate in the tri-state area, some diners are being priced out of existence. Classic establishments have been torn down for luxury high-rises, while others have been displaced by drugstore chains or banks. Surviving diners face competition from restaurant franchises, and these challenges existed before the COVID-19 pandemic, which halted most dining out. More than half of New York City’s diners have closed in the last 25 years.
Despite these challenges, many of New York City’s stalwarts remain. B&H Dairy, a kosher dairy restaurant in the East Village that opened in 1938, is currently owned by an Egyptian man and a Polish woman, along with a staff from all over the world. One of the oldest continually operated diners in New York is Nam Wah Tea Parlor, a dim sum shop that opened in 1920. When you think of diners, you might not immediately think of dumplings and chicken feet, but this New York institution suggests the expanse of culinary traditions that can fit under the ever-evolving label of “diner.” Its classic interior hasn’t been significantly updated since the 1960s and features tile floors, Formica tables, chrome stools, and red vinyl booths.
For New Yorkers, these diners are places of community and sometimes celebrity. After all, “Seinfeld” made the facade of Tom’s Restaurant in Morningside Heights iconic. They are family-owned businesses and sometimes refuges for families. New York City and the country at large are ever-changing, and it’s hard to say if the diner will survive the next transition. So, if you’re lucky enough to have a family-run diner in your city or town, make sure to support them. Start a new pancake tradition, visit after a long night like you did as a teen, or treat yourself to a break from doing dishes on a Sunday morning at a place where you can order hash browns, chicken fingers, and a martini all from the same comfortable booth. These institutions deserve to see another generation sit at their counters.
We’re going to start 2023 making Food History episodes all about beloved dishes. If you have one you’d like us to cover in the coming year, drop it in the comments below. Thanks for watching, and thanks to culinary historian and writer Sarah Lohmann for writing this script. We’ve linked to her book “Eight Flavors” in the description below. See you next time!
—
This version removes any informal language, personal anecdotes, and specific references that may not be suitable for all audiences while retaining the overall content and structure.
Diner – A small, informal restaurant that is often found in the United States, typically serving classic American dishes and open for extended hours. – During the 1950s, diners became a popular meeting place for Americans, reflecting the social dynamics and cultural shifts of the post-war era.
History – The study of past events, particularly in human affairs, often focusing on the analysis and interpretation of records and artifacts. – Understanding the history of the Roman Empire provides insight into the development of modern governance and legal systems.
Culture – The social behavior, norms, beliefs, and traditions practiced by a particular group of people or society. – The Renaissance was a pivotal period in European history that saw a flourishing of art and culture, influencing generations to come.
Immigrants – Individuals who move from one country to another, often seeking better living conditions, opportunities, or escaping conflict. – The influx of immigrants in the early 20th century significantly contributed to the cultural and economic landscape of the United States.
Restaurants – Establishments where meals are prepared and served to customers, often reflecting the culinary traditions of a particular culture or region. – The proliferation of Chinese restaurants in the late 19th century introduced many Americans to new flavors and dining experiences.
Evolution – The gradual development and change of something over time, often used to describe the adaptation and transformation of societies, technologies, or ideas. – The evolution of democratic ideals can be traced back to ancient civilizations and has shaped modern political systems.
Community – A group of people living in the same place or having a particular characteristic in common, often sharing resources, values, and goals. – The Harlem Renaissance was a cultural movement that emerged from the African American community, influencing art, music, and literature.
Cuisine – A style or method of cooking, especially as characteristic of a particular country, region, or establishment. – French cuisine has had a profound impact on global culinary practices, known for its emphasis on technique and presentation.
Suburbs – Residential areas on the outskirts of a city, often characterized by a lower population density and a more family-oriented environment. – The growth of suburbs in the post-World War II era was driven by the desire for affordable housing and a higher quality of life.
Dining – The act of eating a meal, often in a formal or social setting, which can reflect cultural practices and social structures. – The tradition of formal dining in Victorian England was a reflection of social status and etiquette.
