In 1874, America was on its way to becoming a more modern and civilized country. However, in the western regions beyond the Mississippi River, chaos and lawlessness were still common. States like Kansas, Nevada, and Texas were still wild frontiers where crimes like gunfights, cattle rustling, and horse theft were everyday occurrences. Among these crimes, robbery was one of the most serious offenses.
At first, robbers focused on stagecoaches and lone travelers. But as the country grew and infrastructure expanded westward, banks and wagon shipments became prime targets for criminals. A major turning point in crime history happened when the James-Younger gang, which included the notorious outlaw Jesse James, carried out one of the first train robberies in American history on July 21, 1873. They derailed a train near Adair, Iowa, resulting in the death of the engineer, and stole about $30,000 (which would be over $63,000 today) from the train’s safe and its passengers.
Just six months later, on January 31, 1874, the James-Younger gang pulled off another bold train robbery, this time in Missouri. The gang, which included Frank and Jesse James, Arthur McCoy, and two of the Younger brothers, struck in broad daylight. Wearing masks, they rode into the small community of Gads Hill in southeastern Missouri. This tiny settlement, founded only two years earlier, had just 15 residents and was named after Charles Dickens’ country house in England.
The gang targeted Gads Hill because of its small railroad platform, which was part of the railway line from St. Louis, Missouri to Texarkana, Arkansas. A train was scheduled to pass through that day at 4 PM, carrying passengers and cargo, including a safe. Although trains usually didn’t stop at Gads Hill, they slowed down significantly after climbing a steep hill. The gang didn’t know that the train was supposed to stop that day for state representative L.M. Farasto to meet his son.
The gang convinced local settlers to help them build a large bonfire beside the track. When the train approached at 4:45 PM, they lit the bonfire, and another gang member waved a red flag, signaling danger ahead. As the train stopped, the gang overpowered the conductor and captured the engineer and his crew.
The gang split into two groups. One group went to the baggage car to force the shipping agent to open the train safe and inspect the delivery parcels. It’s said that one gang member even insisted the agent update his inventory log to say “Robbed at Gads Hill.” Meanwhile, the other group went through the passenger car, selectively robbing passengers but refusing to take from women or men who seemed to be working class. They even checked men’s hands to see if they were rough or callused, indicating honest labor.
One passenger, James H. Morley, a chief engineer, protested, but when a gang member pointed a revolver at him, he quickly complied. The newspapers later sensationalized the event, claiming that as the gang left the train, one member quoted lines from William Shakespeare and handed the conductor a prewritten press release that ended with, “There’s a hell of an excitement in this part of the country.” They then shook the engineer’s hand and rode off.
The exact amount stolen varied in reports, as newspapers often exaggerated the gang’s exploits to sell more papers. The actual amount was likely around $5,000 (just under $100,000 today), along with various parcels, jewelry, a gold watch, five pistols, one ring, and a diamond stick pin. Despite a large posse being sent after them, the gang managed to escape and continued their life of crime for a while longer.
Research the history of train robberies in the United States, focusing on the James-Younger gang. Create a presentation that highlights key events, figures, and the impact of these robberies on society. Present your findings to the class, emphasizing how these events reflect the lawlessness of the American frontier during that era.
Participate in a role-playing activity where you reenact the Gads Hill train robbery. Assign roles such as gang members, train passengers, and crew. Discuss the motivations and ethical considerations of each character. After the reenactment, hold a class discussion on the moral implications of the gang’s actions and their impact on society at the time.
Write a short story from the perspective of a passenger on the train during the Gads Hill robbery. Describe your character’s background, their thoughts during the robbery, and how this event might change their view of the American frontier. Share your story with the class and discuss the different perspectives presented.
Engage in a class debate on the role of outlaws and lawmen in shaping the American frontier. Divide into two groups, with one side defending the actions of outlaws like the James-Younger gang and the other advocating for the importance of law enforcement. Use historical evidence to support your arguments and explore the complexities of justice during this period.
Create a map that traces the movements and activities of the James-Younger gang across the American frontier. Mark key locations such as robbery sites, hideouts, and encounters with law enforcement. Present your map to the class, explaining how geography and infrastructure influenced the gang’s criminal activities.
**The Great Missouri Train Robbery: Gads Hill, Missouri, 1874**
By 1874, America was evolving into a more modern and civilized nation, or so it seemed. However, west of the Mississippi River, lawlessness prevailed, and guns still ruled the day. States like Kansas, Nevada, and Texas were still very much wild frontiers, with crimes such as gunfights, cattle rustling, and horse theft being common. Among these, robbery was perhaps the most serious offense.
Initially, robbers targeted stagecoaches and lone travelers. But as infrastructure expanded westward, banks and wagon shipments became prime targets. A significant turning point occurred when the James-Younger gang, which included the infamous outlaw Jesse James, committed what is considered one of the first train robberies in American history on July 21, 1873. They derailed a locomotive near Adair, Iowa, resulting in the death of the engineer, and stole approximately $30,000 (over $63,000 in today’s value) from the train’s safe and the passengers on board.
Six months later, on January 31, 1874, at around 3:00 PM on a bitterly cold Friday afternoon, the James-Younger gang executed another daring train robbery—the first ever in Missouri. The gang consisted of Frank and Jesse James, Arthur McCoy, and two of the Younger brothers. In broad daylight, wearing masks, they rode into the small community of Gads Hill in southeastern Missouri. This settlement, founded just two years prior, had a population of only 15 and was named after Charles Dickens’ country house in England.
The gang was interested in Gads Hill due to its small railroad platform, which was part of the St. Louis, Missouri to Texarkana, Arkansas railway line. A train was scheduled to arrive that day at 4 PM, carrying a mix of passengers and cargo, including a safe. Although trains did not typically stop at Gads Hill, they would slow down significantly after climbing a steep gradient. Unbeknownst to the gang, the train was set to stop that day for state representative L.M. Farasto to meet his son.
The gang enlisted the help of local settlers to build a large bonfire beside the track. When the train approached at 4:45 PM, they lit the bonfire, while another member waved a red flag, the universal signal for danger ahead. As the train came to a stop, the gang overpowered the conductor and captured the engineer and his crew.
The gang split into two groups: one headed to the baggage car to force the shipping agent to open the train safe and inspect the registered delivery parcels. It was reported that one gang member insisted the agent update his inventory log to indicate “Robbed at Gads Hill.” Meanwhile, the other group went through the passenger carriage, selectively robbing passengers but refusing to take from women or men who appeared to be working class. They even checked men’s hands to determine if they were rough or callused, indicating honest labor.
One passenger, James H. Morley, a chief engineer, protested, but when a gang member pointed a revolver at him, he complied without further issue. The incident was later sensationalized in the newspapers, which claimed that as the gang exited the train, one member quoted lines from William Shakespeare and handed the conductor a prewritten press release that concluded with, “There’s a hell of an excitement in this part of the country.” They then shook the engineer’s hand and departed.
The exact amount stolen varied widely in reports, as newspapers exaggerated the exploits of the James-Younger gang to boost sales. The actual amount was likely around $5,000 (just under $100,000 in today’s value), along with various parcels, jewelry, a gold watch, five pistols, one ring, and a diamond stick pin. Despite a large posse being dispatched after them, the gang managed to escape and continued their life of crime for a while longer.
Subscribe and click the notification bell for more history videos!
Train – A series of connected vehicles traveling on railways, often used for transporting goods or passengers. – During the 19th century, the expansion of the train network significantly impacted the economic and social development of the United States.
Robbery – The act of taking property unlawfully from a person or place by force or threat of force. – The infamous Great Train Robbery of 1963 remains one of the most notorious robberies in British history.
Gang – A group of people who associate for criminal or antisocial purposes. – The James-Younger Gang was a notorious group of outlaws in the American Old West, known for their bank and train robberies.
Missouri – A U.S. state located in the Midwestern region, significant in American history for its role in westward expansion and the Civil War. – Missouri was a border state during the Civil War, with divided loyalties that led to significant internal conflict.
James – Referring to Jesse James, a famous American outlaw known for his bank and train robberies in the late 19th century. – Jesse James became a legendary figure in American folklore, symbolizing the lawlessness of the Wild West.
History – The study of past events, particularly in human affairs. – Understanding history is crucial for learning how past societies have shaped the modern world.
Crime – An action or omission that constitutes an offense and is punishable by law. – The rise of organized crime during the Prohibition era in the United States had a lasting impact on American society and law enforcement.
Passengers – People who travel in a vehicle, such as a train, bus, or airplane, but do not operate it. – The passengers on the train were unaware of the impending robbery until the outlaws boarded and demanded their valuables.
Engineer – A person who operates or is in charge of an engine, especially on a train. – The train engineer played a crucial role in ensuring the safety and timely arrival of the passengers during the journey.
Lawlessness – A state of disorder due to a disregard of the law. – The lawlessness of the American frontier during the 19th century often led to violent conflicts and the rise of vigilante justice.
