On February 15, 1977, an exciting deep-sea exploration took place near the Galapagos Islands. A two-ton steel cage named Angus was lowered to the ocean floor, equipped with cameras, powerful strobe lights, and a highly sensitive temperature sensor. The goal was to find a deep-sea hydrothermal vent by detecting even the slightest changes in water temperature.
After hours of anticipation, Angus finally recorded a temperature spike. The next day, scientists eagerly developed the 3,000 photos Angus had taken during its 16-kilometer journey. They meticulously examined each photo, and during the time of the temperature anomaly, they discovered something unexpected: the seafloor was teeming with white clams and brown mussel shells. This was a surprising find, as the deep ocean was previously thought to be a barren wasteland.
Intrigued by this discovery, researchers prepared Alvin, a three-person deep-sea submarine, to explore further. Upon reaching the site, they were amazed to find warm, shimmering water emerging from cracks in the ocean floor. They had discovered the first deep-sea hydrothermal vent, a place where life thrived in a seemingly inhospitable environment. Alvin’s crew observed large white clams, brown mussels, and peculiar white crabs. They even found a site with towering eight-foot-tall tubeworms.
This discovery challenged the prevailing belief that all life depended on sunlight. Scientists wondered how these creatures survived without sunlight. The answer lay in the water samples from the vents, which smelled of rotten eggs due to hydrogen sulfide. This chemical allowed life to exist in the deep sea, marking a revolutionary shift in our understanding of life’s origins on Earth.
Hydrothermal vents form where tectonic plates separate, allowing seawater to seep through the ocean crust. The water is heated by the Earth’s interior and rises back to the surface, carrying minerals that form towering chimney structures known as black smokers. These vents, found at depths of up to 3,800 meters, emit water as hot as 400 degrees Celsius. Despite the extreme conditions, life flourishes here.
The key to these ecosystems is chemosynthesis, a process where microbes convert mineral-rich fluid into energy. Unlike photosynthesis, which relies on sunlight, chemosynthesis uses chemical reactions to produce sugar. This allows deep-sea creatures to thrive, with giant tubeworms and crabs relying on chemosynthetic bacteria for sustenance.
The discovery of chemosynthetic communities in the 1970s revolutionized our understanding of life’s origins. Previously, the primordial soup theory, based on Stanley Miller’s 1952 experiment, suggested that life began with chemical reactions triggered by external energy sources like lightning. However, this theory lacked a sustained energy source.
In 1993, geochemist Michael Russell proposed an alternative theory: life might have originated at alkaline hydrothermal vents. These vents create a natural energy gradient, essential for life. In 2000, the Lost City hydrothermal field was discovered, supporting Russell’s theory. These vents emit alkaline water and have porous chimney walls, creating the conditions necessary for life to emerge.
While not all scientists agree on the origins of life, the discovery of hydrothermal vents has significant implications. These vents have been found on other celestial bodies, like Saturn’s moon Enceladus, suggesting the possibility of life beyond Earth.
The ocean remains largely unexplored, with less than twenty percent of it mapped. The deep sea is a mysterious realm, akin to an alien world. Fascinating discoveries await, and you can learn more about them by watching “Deep Ocean,” narrated by David Attenborough on Curiosity Stream. This streaming platform offers a wealth of documentaries, including original content from educational creators on Nebula.
By subscribing to Curiosity Stream, you gain access to both platforms for just $19.99 a year, supporting a community of creators passionate about sharing knowledge and exploring the wonders of our world.
Engage in a virtual simulation of a deep-sea exploration mission. Use available software to simulate the deployment of a submersible like Alvin. Document your findings and compare them with the historical discovery of hydrothermal vents. Discuss the challenges and surprises you encounter during the simulation.
Prepare a presentation on the process of chemosynthesis and its role in sustaining life at hydrothermal vents. Include a comparison with photosynthesis and discuss the implications for understanding life in extreme environments. Present your findings to the class and facilitate a discussion on the potential for life on other planets.
Participate in a class debate on the origins of life. One side will argue for the primordial soup theory, while the other supports the hydrothermal vent hypothesis. Use scientific evidence to support your arguments and engage in a critical discussion about the strengths and weaknesses of each theory.
Watch the documentary “Deep Ocean” narrated by David Attenborough. After viewing, write a reflective analysis on how the documentary enhances your understanding of deep-sea ecosystems and the significance of hydrothermal vents. Share your insights with your peers in a group discussion.
Organize a field trip to a local marine research facility or aquarium with a focus on deep-sea environments. Observe exhibits related to hydrothermal vents and interact with marine biologists to learn about ongoing research. Reflect on how these experiences connect to the historical discoveries discussed in the article.
On February 15, 1977, a two-ton steel cage called Angus was lowered to the seafloor near the Galapagos Islands. It was equipped with cameras, powerful strobe lights, and a sensor that could detect water temperature changes as small as 0.00005 degrees. Throughout the night, Angus took thousands of photos while researchers monitored the temperature readings, hoping to see a spike that would indicate they had found a deep-sea hydrothermal vent.
After many hours of searching, Angus finally sent out a signal indicating a spike in water temperature. The next day, the scientists developed the 3,000 photos taken during Angus’s 16-kilometer journey. They studied every single photo frame by frame until they reached the images corresponding to the time of the temperature spike. All photographs taken before the anomaly showed only barren terrain, but for 13 frames during the spike, the photos revealed the seafloor covered with hundreds of white clams and brown mussel shells. This was certainly not what the researchers were expecting, as the deep seafloor is typically thought to be a barren wasteland.
Thrilled and confused by their discovery, the researchers prepared Alvin, a three-person deep-sea research submarine, to investigate. The pilots navigated to the location of the temperature spike, and what they found stunned them. Warm, shimmering water was coming out of small cracks in the ocean floor. They had successfully found the first-ever discovered deep-sea hydrothermal vent. However, they did not expect to find a vibrant, bizarre, and dense community of animals thriving there. From Alvin, the pilots could see one-foot-long white clams, thousands of brown mussels, and many strange-looking white crabs. Later, they found a vent site full of massive eight-foot-tall white tubeworms with bright red tops.
The discovery of these animals was surprising because, up until that point, it was believed that the entire planet’s food chain was reliant on photosynthesis and that no community of animals could live without sunlight. Researchers wondered what these animals were eating down there without sunlight. Water samples from the vents provided the first clue; as the researchers opened the first sample, the smell of rotten eggs filled the room. The water was full of hydrogen sulfide. Something about the chemicals coming from the vents allowed the animals to live at these depths without food from sunlight. This marked the beginning of a game-changing revelation in chemistry and biology, altering how we think about where and how life began on Earth.
Hydrothermal vents form in places where two tectonic plates are separating. This is why all the hydrothermal vents discovered to date—over 240 of them—are located on the boundaries of Earth’s plates. The vents result from seawater percolating down through fissures in the ocean crust near spreading centers. Due to pressure and temperature, the water is forced back up and released into the ocean, bringing many different minerals that precipitate out upon contact with the cold seafloor. These precipitations form hydrothermal chimney stacks, which can be as tall as 60 meters (or 18 stories). They are magnificent structures found at an average depth of 2,100 meters, with the deepest ones located at 3,800 meters. These chimneys, known as black smokers, are formed from deposits of iron sulfide, emitting heavy metals and sulfides that would be toxic to most creatures. The temperature of the water from the vents can reach up to 400 degrees Celsius, not boiling due to the immense pressure at these depths. Despite the harsh environment, life thrives here.
The giant clams and eight-foot-long tubeworms are exceptionally interesting, but it is the smaller organisms that make these ecosystems possible. The microbes convert the mineral-laden fluid into energy. Instead of using light energy to turn carbon dioxide into sugar like plants do, they use energy released by chemical reactions of the minerals spewed from the vents to create sugar, a process known as chemosynthesis.
For reference, plant photosynthesis uses the sun’s energy to transfer electrons from water to carbon dioxide to produce carbohydrates. In contrast, during chemosynthesis, the source of energy is liberated from a chemical reaction, specifically the oxidation of an inorganic substance. Hot water flowing from the hydrothermal vents is saturated with inorganic compounds like hydrogen sulfide. The bacteria use energy stored in the chemical bonds of hydrogen sulfide to make glucose from water and carbon dioxide, producing pure sulfur and sulfur compounds as byproducts. This process allows the vibrant communities of deep-sea animals to survive. For example, giant tubeworms live symbiotically with these bacteria, allowing the worms to utilize the sugar molecules created.
Other animals, such as crabs, also populate hydrothermal vent areas in massive numbers, surviving off the sugars produced by the chemosynthetic bacteria growing in their bristles. All creatures forming the hydrothermal vent communities are part of a food chain made possible by chemosynthesis.
Our knowledge of chemosynthetic communities began with the discovery of the first hydrothermal vent communities in the 1970s. Since then, chemosynthetic bacteria have been found in hot springs on land and on whale carcasses and sunken ships at the bottom of the ocean. Their discovery has changed how scientists think about the origins of life itself.
Scientists generally agree that the origin of life on Earth involved an evolutionary process of increasing complexity, including molecular self-replication, self-assembly, and the emergence of cell membranes. However, there are many theories about how this could have happened. For years, the prevailing theory, known as the primordial soup theory, was largely based on Stanley Miller’s 1952 experiment, which demonstrated that most amino acids can be synthesized from inorganic compounds by sending an electrical charge through a chemical solution of methane, ammonia, hydrogen, and water. Scientists proposed that an external energy source, like lightning, may have triggered these reactions in early Earth. Critics of the soup theory argue that there is no sustained energy source to make inorganic compounds react, and without an energy source, life as we know it couldn’t have emerged.
An opposing theory was introduced in 1993 by geochemist Michael Russell from NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory. He suggested that life originated from harnessing the energy gradients that exist when alkaline vent water mixes with more acidic seawater, providing the continuous energy source needed. The rationale is that life as we know it is based on physical compartmentalization from the environment, where chemical reactions occur in a self-contained environment, or inside cells. Researchers like Russell hypothesized that inorganic matter with similar compartmentalization attributes could lead to organic life.
Proton gradients across cell walls and membranes create charge differentials essential for life, known as the proton motive force. This typically involves a difference of about three pH units across a membrane, effectively storing potential energy that can be harnessed when protons pass through the membrane to phosphorylate ADP, making ATP, the chemical that provides energy for living cells. The precursor to life would similarly need a chemical gradient across a physical boundary. For these reasons, Russell proposed that life could have originated at deep-sea hydrothermal vent chimneys if those chimneys had pores that could provide a template for living cells and if there was a three pH unit difference across the thin mineral walls separating the vent and seawater. This energy could allow for the reduction of carbon dioxide and the production of organic molecules, leading to self-replicating molecules like RNA and eventually true cells with their own membranes.
Scientists praised this theory as hypothetically possible, but no such vent had ever been found. The ones discovered were not alkaline in nature and therefore lacked a chemical gradient that could be harnessed. However, in 2000, the missing piece was found at the Lost City hydrothermal field in the middle of the Atlantic Ocean. This vent was different from those previously discovered; it spewed alkaline water. The Lost City vents differ from black smoker-type vents as they are located several kilometers away from spreading zones, meaning the water does not come into close contact with the magma chambers beneath the crust. Instead, it is heated by chemical reactions between seawater and mantle rocks, resulting in an average temperature of around 90 degrees Celsius instead of 400 degrees Celsius like in black smokers. Additionally, due to the mineral makeup of the Earth beneath the Lost City, the vents emit highly alkaline water with a pH of around 11. The chimney walls are also full of tiny pores that separate the warm alkaline vent fluid from the cooler acidic seawater, creating a natural charge gradient.
Scientists realized that this could be the pH gradient and compartmental structure that Russell proposed would be needed for life to emerge. While not all scientists agree that life began in a deep-sea hydrothermal system, and there are many details that need to be worked out, this theory has significant implications for our world and beyond. Hydrothermal vents have recently been found on other worlds, like Saturn’s moon Enceladus, where conditions might allow for life to exist and potentially begin.
The ocean makes up most of the world’s surface, yet we have explored less than twenty percent of it by some estimates, and less than one percent by others. It may as well be an alien world. The first-ever photo of a living giant squid was taken in 2004, and only four people have ever ventured to the bottom of the deepest part of the Mariana Trench, called the Challenger Deep, almost 11,000 meters down. For reference, 12 people have walked on the moon.
Many can relate to the fascination with the dark depths of the sea, both for the amazing discoveries made and for what still remains to be seen. You can learn more about the fascinating expeditions to the deep and the incredible animals found there by watching “Deep Ocean,” narrated by David Attenborough on Curiosity Stream. Curiosity Stream is a streaming platform with thousands of high-quality, high-budget documentaries. The “Deep Ocean” series explores how researchers uncover the secrets of the Mariana Trench, studying newly discovered deep-sea animals and their quest to uncover the ocean’s most ancient creatures.
To make it even better, your Curiosity Stream subscription now also includes a subscription to Nebula, a streaming platform created by top educational content creators like Wendover Productions, Tier Zoo, Real Life Lore, and our other channel, Real Engineering. Nebula allows creators to produce exciting original content without worrying about the YouTube algorithm or demonetization. There are many episodes and shows being added all the time, like City Beautiful’s new series on the planning of ancient Rome, which traces the rise of the city that spawned an empire, or Working Titles, where different creators break down the intros for their favorite TV series, or Real Engineering’s new “Logistics of D-Day” series, which tracks the strategy and decisions that led to the Allies’ successful invasion of Normandy on D-Day.
If you sign up using the link below, you’ll gain access to all of Curiosity Stream and all of Nebula for just $19.99 a year, while supporting a community of creators who love making new and exciting content.
Deep-sea – Referring to the deepest parts of the ocean, typically below 200 meters, where sunlight does not penetrate, and unique biological processes occur. – The deep-sea environment hosts a variety of organisms that have adapted to high-pressure and low-light conditions.
Hydrothermal – Relating to the action of heated water, often associated with volcanic activity on the ocean floor, where mineral-rich fluids are expelled. – Hydrothermal vents are crucial for understanding the chemical processes that support life in the absence of sunlight.
Vents – Openings on the ocean floor that emit hot, mineral-rich water, supporting unique biological communities. – The discovery of vents along the mid-ocean ridges has revolutionized our understanding of marine ecosystems.
Chemosynthesis – A process by which certain organisms synthesize organic compounds using energy derived from chemical reactions, rather than sunlight. – Chemosynthesis is the primary source of energy for life forms residing near hydrothermal vents.
Ecosystems – Communities of living organisms interacting with their physical environment, which can be as diverse as coral reefs or deep-sea hydrothermal vent systems. – The ecosystems around hydrothermal vents are among the most unique on Earth, relying on chemosynthesis instead of photosynthesis.
Microbes – Microscopic organisms, including bacteria and archaea, that play essential roles in nutrient cycling and energy flow in ecosystems. – Microbes at hydrothermal vents are capable of chemosynthesis, converting inorganic molecules into energy.
Minerals – Inorganic substances that are naturally occurring and are often found in the form of crystals, playing a crucial role in various biological and geological processes. – The minerals expelled from hydrothermal vents provide the necessary nutrients for chemosynthetic bacteria.
Temperature – A measure of the thermal energy within a system, influencing chemical reactions and biological processes. – The extreme temperature gradients near hydrothermal vents create unique habitats for specialized organisms.
Life – The condition that distinguishes living organisms from inorganic matter, characterized by growth, reproduction, and response to stimuli. – The discovery of life in the extreme conditions of hydrothermal vents challenges our understanding of the limits of biological survival.
Exploration – The act of investigating unknown regions, often leading to new scientific discoveries and insights. – The exploration of deep-sea environments has uncovered ecosystems that thrive in conditions previously thought uninhabitable.
