Have you ever heard someone say, “I will succeed” or “I’m powerful, I’m strong, and nothing in the world can stop me”? These are examples of positive affirmations, which are often recommended by self-help books to boost confidence and motivation. However, research shows that these statements might not work for everyone and can even have the opposite effect for some people.
In a study, researchers asked people with different levels of self-esteem to repeat the phrase “I’m a lovable person.” They then measured how these individuals felt about themselves. Surprisingly, those with low self-esteem felt worse after saying the affirmation, while those with high self-esteem only felt a little better.
Another interesting finding came from a follow-up study. When people with low self-esteem were asked to list both negative and positive thoughts about themselves, their mood actually improved. This is related to the idea of “latitudes of acceptance,” which means that we are more likely to be persuaded by messages that are similar to what we already believe. If a message is too different from our beliefs, it might backfire and make us hold onto our original thoughts even more strongly.
Sometimes, our minds can get in the way of how we respond to feedback. For some people, simply thinking “I will succeed” without planning the steps to achieve success can actually decrease motivation. In one study, participants who visualized positive outcomes, like winning an essay competition, felt less energized than those who imagined negative outcomes. Similarly, people who fantasized about having a great week ended up feeling less motivated and achieved fewer goals than those who didn’t engage in such positive visualization.
Everyone is different, and we each respond to self-help techniques in our own way. Researchers suggest using more specific affirmations, like “I select good gifts for people,” instead of broad statements like “I am a generous person.” While positive thinking is important, it’s also okay to acknowledge negative thoughts sometimes, as they can be a source of motivation too.
Remember, being creative and intelligent means finding what works best for you. Explore different strategies and see what helps you feel motivated and confident. And if you’re curious to learn more, consider checking out insightful content from sources like BrainCraft for fresh ideas every week.
Imagine you are a character who uses positive affirmations daily. Create a short skit with your classmates to demonstrate how these affirmations affect your character’s self-esteem and motivation. Discuss as a group how different characters might react differently to the same affirmations.
Conduct an experiment where you and your classmates write down a positive affirmation and a specific affirmation. Over a week, repeat each affirmation daily and record your feelings and motivation levels. At the end of the week, compare your experiences and discuss which type of affirmation was more effective for you.
Try a visualization exercise where you imagine both positive and negative outcomes of a future event, like an exam or a sports game. Write down your energy and motivation levels after each visualization. Share your findings with the class and discuss how visualization affected your motivation.
Create a list of beliefs you hold about yourself. Then, write down affirmations that are slightly different from these beliefs. Share with a partner and discuss whether these affirmations feel acceptable or if they cause resistance. Reflect on how this relates to the concept of “latitudes of acceptance.”
Start a journal where you track different self-help techniques you try, such as affirmations, visualization, or listing positive and negative thoughts. Record how each technique affects your motivation and self-esteem. After a month, review your entries to identify which strategies work best for you.
Here’s a sanitized version of the provided YouTube transcript:
—
Repeat after me: “I will succeed.” “I’m powerful, I’m strong, and nothing in the world can stop me.” Many self-help books encourage us to repeat these positive affirmations and visualize success. However, research indicates that for some individuals, these statements can have a negative impact. Visualizing success may actually lead to failure for certain people.
In one study, participants with both high and low self-esteem repeated the phrase “I’m a lovable person.” Researchers then assessed their mood and self-perception. They discovered that phrases that appeared positive made individuals with low self-esteem feel worse, while those with high self-esteem experienced only a slight improvement in mood.
In a follow-up study, researchers found that when individuals with low self-esteem were asked to list negative self-thoughts alongside positive ones, their reported mood improved. This relates to the concept of “latitudes of acceptance,” which suggests that messages that align closely with your beliefs are more persuasive than those that are far removed from them. Messages outside your latitude of acceptance can backfire and reinforce your original beliefs.
Sometimes, our psychology can hinder our response to constructive feedback. For some, thinking “I will succeed” without considering the steps to get there can lead to decreased motivation. Another study revealed that visualizing success can diminish ambition. Participants who were asked to visualize either positive or negative outcomes regarding winning an essay competition reported feeling less energized in the positive visualization group compared to the negative one. Additionally, those who fantasized positively about the upcoming week felt less energized and achieved fewer goals than the control group.
Of course, individual differences mean we respond differently to self-help techniques. Overall, researchers recommend using more specific affirmations, such as “I select good gifts for people” instead of “I am a generous person.” These positive statements suggest that we should focus solely on positive thoughts. However, it’s important to acknowledge that occasional negative thoughts can also be motivational.
I’m a creative and intelligent person because I subscribe to BrainCraft for a new insightful episode every Thursday.
—
This version maintains the core ideas while removing any potentially sensitive or negative phrasing.
Positive Affirmations – Positive affirmations are encouraging statements that people repeat to themselves to promote a positive mindset and boost self-esteem. – Example sentence: By saying positive affirmations every morning, Sarah felt more confident and ready to face her day.
Self-Esteem – Self-esteem is the overall sense of value or worth that a person feels about themselves. – Example sentence: Building self-esteem can help teenagers feel more secure and capable in their abilities.
Motivation – Motivation is the inner drive or desire that pushes someone to act or achieve goals. – Example sentence: Finding motivation to study can be challenging, but setting small goals can help keep you focused.
Visualization – Visualization is the process of creating a mental image of a desired outcome to enhance performance or achieve goals. – Example sentence: Athletes often use visualization techniques to imagine themselves succeeding in their sports.
Negative Thoughts – Negative thoughts are pessimistic or self-critical ideas that can affect a person’s mood and behavior. – Example sentence: Learning to challenge negative thoughts can improve mental health and overall well-being.
Critical Thinking – Critical thinking is the ability to analyze information objectively and make a reasoned judgment. – Example sentence: Critical thinking skills are essential for evaluating the credibility of information found online.
Strategies – Strategies are planned actions or approaches designed to achieve a specific goal or solve a problem. – Example sentence: Developing effective study strategies can help students improve their academic performance.
Confidence – Confidence is the belief in one’s abilities and judgment. – Example sentence: Practicing public speaking can help build confidence in presenting ideas to an audience.
Beliefs – Beliefs are convictions or acceptances that certain things are true or real. – Example sentence: Our beliefs about ourselves can significantly influence our behavior and attitudes.
Creativity – Creativity is the ability to generate new and original ideas or solutions. – Example sentence: Encouraging creativity in problem-solving can lead to innovative solutions.
